Select any of the three objects you want to know more about and channel it; the others will have to wait for another playthrough. After this walk around the room, drink some water and talk to Cole. When Nathan returns, converse any way you like (I'd tell that douche to go fuck himself, personally; also, how unbelievably unrealistic is this scene anyway? Like *anyone* would respond like that in a first conversation).
In Jodie's room grab your stuff; Mr. Rabbit, a picture of Nathan and Cole, some clothes, some things from the bathroom, a picture from your parents (near the kitchen) and lastly a painting on the board near the entrance.