Neoseeker : News : Sunday Special: Which Console Is Right For You?
Hardware Newsletter:
Email:

Latest News
Tue, Nov 18
Mon, Nov 17
Sun, Nov 16
Sat, Nov 15
Fri, Nov 14
Thu, Nov 13

send article hardware newsletter   article comments (14)

Sunday Special: Which Console Is Right For You?
Lydia Sung - Sunday, September 14th, 2008 | 12:24PM (PT)


A not-so-intimate look at who buys what

As it stands, the 7th generation console war is still ongoing.  Though it would be unfair to place all three popular consoles side to side for a comparison, many continue to do so for reasons completely lost upon me.  It certainly doesn't help that countless so-called market analysts continue comparing Microsoft's Xbox 360, Sony's PlayStation 3, and the well-received Nintendo Wii in their seemingly weekly articles, poorly predicting the next big thing in video gaming.

If you ask me, it's pretty much all moot.  Analysts get paid for spouting nonsense, fanboys get off on being obnoxious, and the rest of us just try to get by with our console(s) of choice.

But in the spirit of fun, let's take a look at these three contenders in this alleged war.  If you're thinking of making a purchase and have to choose, how can you be sure you're making the right choice?  A console can say a lot about who you are, acting as a gaming machine and status symbol (much like a car), and you certainly don't want to convey the wrong message.  This is where I step in to guide you on your journey.

Xbox 360

Microsoft launched its successor to the original Xbox back in November 2005.  Its sleek design was a vast improvement over a bulky predecessor that was big enough to club a moose with.  The 360 also adopted a new color theme -- white and green.  With several price drops and different models under its belt, the 360 is now one of the cheaper consoles out there but carries an unfortunate reputation involving a red ring, usually caused by overheating problems within the machine.  Since the Red Ring of Death began plaguing early generation models, Microsoft has literally tossed billions out the window providing warranties to address the 360's issues (which extended beyond the RRoD).  Thankfully, the company has drastically reduced these problems in newer units currently on the market.

Xbox LIVE is the 360's community service and includes the Xbox LIVE Marketplace; another notable feature is the ability to sync your 360 with your PC or Zune, compliments of Microsoft.

Having been around longer than the PlayStation 3 and Wii, the Xbox LIVE community is much larger than its competitors, and the wider array of games to offer.  That being said, the Xbox 360 also tends to inspire the image of a roudy fraternity punk humping a beer bong because of its many FPS exclusives, the most popular being Halo.

Antithesis: weeaboos, Asians

PlayStation 3

Sony's PlayStation 3 is usually seen as the Xbox 360's biggest rival, both being advertised as next generation and sharing many of the same games.  It's officially marketed in CAPS as PLAYSTATION 3 because...  Well, we're not sure why, but a lot of PS3-related trademarks are written that way, such as the licensed SIXAXIS.  Unexplained love affair with CAPS LOCK aside, the Sixaxis Wireless Controller looks just like the PS2 controller, but sports a motion detector on top of the DUALSHOCK 3 feature.  Sony's answer to Xbox LIVE is the PlayStation Network, or PSN, a free service that has been around longer than LIVE but received little attention up until these past couple of years.  PS3 owners are still eagerly awaiting the highly hyped and anticipated PlayStation Home, which is expected to offer much of what the LIVE Dashboard currently has (if not more).

While early PS3s suffered errors and heating issues of their own, Sony has since begun replacing problematic units for disgruntled owners.  Its Blu-Ray unit has been known to burn out even in the high end 80GB model.

The PS3 is by far the most expensive of the three consoles but can also be considered a rather cheap Blu-Ray player.  As such, many consumers who wouldn't consider themselves gamers have settled for one of these shiny behemoths.  Indeed, even Sony sees their product as more of a multimedia machine, capable of much more than just gaming.  Those who fancy themselves media- or HiDef-philes are often drawn to the PS3.  Hence forth, PS3 archetypes are typically more sophistocated than the 360 stereotype, though everyone winds up sounding like an idiot when they get into fanboy forum fights.  They can also be quite sensitive, quick to jump to their console's defense at any given opportunity.

Antithesis: poor folk, anyone without an impressive home theatre, Final Fantasy fanatics (oh wait-...)

Wii

Aside from having the most unassuming name, Nintendo's toy console has been enjoying the most success out of these three.  Since its release in November 2006 (a few days after the PS3), the Wii has sold nearly 30 million units as of July 2008, putting it well ahead of its competitors.  At this point, only the low end 360 Arcade can compete in terms of price.  That being said, the Wii is also viewed as a light weight, with its target demographic being the new casual gamer group that encompasses just about anyone with motor skills and hand-eye coordination.  The Wii's design is simple, with a pleasant white and blue color scheme.

Early on, Wii owners claimed the Wii Remote was a hazard after incidents of "strap failure" that resulted in property damage and bodily injury.  Since then, Nintendo has replaced the wrist straps for such mentally challenged (we're not allowed to use the r-word) players.  Staying true to Nintendo tradition, the Wii does require peripherals for many of its games, with the Nunchuk being a must-have.

Gamers have been complaining about Nintendo's target audience, claiming that the company has forgotten about the hardcore fans who have remained loyal by choosing the Wii over other consoles.  Another common belief is that the Wii's third party games are generally subpar; as such, passionate gamers might want to take a second look at the Wii's inventory before investing in one.  Graphically, it cannot compare to the Xbox 360 or PS3, but the Wii maintains its own unique appeal with that Nintendo charm.

Antithesis: people who hate cute and colors 

Here's a disclaimer for anyone who may be tempted to take this more seriously than intended: I do own an Xbox 360, and I don't personally consider PS3 owners to be any more educated than the next -- PC gamers tend to claim that prestige for themselves.

  Related Stories

  Related Reviews & Articles

back to news    comments or corrections
- This news story is archived and is closed to comments now -

Comments:

September 14th, 2008 9:35PM(PT)
NathanFido
Nice article, certainly gave me a laugh.
September 14th, 2008 10:28PM(PT)
Cheesysoapopra
Seems like an opinion based article to fill up space on a slow news day.
September 15th, 2008 12:03AM(PT)
MrGrimm
waa waa baww ps3 neutral colors only, it sux 360 only green, i haet green.. also wii is spel rong i haet... GBA win /sarcasm

...Yeah. I liked this article.
September 15th, 2008 1:14AM(PT)
walnuts
Well, this has certaintly helped me out. I'm considering purchasing one, and this article has tipped me towards the Wii. Thanks Lydia!
September 15th, 2008 1:19AM(PT)
RabidChinaGirl
quote Cheesysoapopra
Seems like an opinion based article to fill up space on a slow news day.
Can't slip anything past you, sleuth.
September 15th, 2008 3:12AM(PT)
PS3Owner
I wish people would stop labelling the PS3 as "by far the most expensive" without any attempt to explain the reasons behind the price. I know this article was tongue in cheek but it still bugs me.

The PS3 does not give you the option to "buy in installments" that's how I view it - take the 360 Arcade and add on the $100 Wi-fi, the $50 online access, $100 HDD, $15 controller charger etc etc, and you're already WAY over the cost of the PS3 that has these things out of the box!

People need to be clear that there is more to the price differnece than just the Blu-ray player (though that is another $300+ freebie from Sony), the 360's perceived value is nothing more than smoke and mirrors advertising from Microsoft.

If you sit down and work it out, the fully-loaded price of a 360 Arcade to bring it to a comparable spec as the PS3 is actually $820 (increasing by $50 each year), which makes the PS3's $399 price tag more than reasonable...
September 15th, 2008 4:30AM(PT)
Playstation freak
PS3 owns bitches
September 15th, 2008 5:08AM(PT)
oni_hero
Back fanboys back! *Smacks away with large stick*

Seriously, I don't get why they are like that either.

The consoles should not be compared ffs! Each is different and for a different kind of person!
The xbox360 is for your average gamer who wants some action games along with sports and such.
The PS3 is for the more hardcore gamer who is obsessive about the tech in their console and is looking for games like Metal gear solid and other PS3 exclusives.
The Wii is for your casual gamer who is looking to just have some fun with their console, mainly Wiisports type games that may come off gimmicky, but are fun and easy to learn.

So shut up you fan boy twats, your console isn't better then the others, you just get off on thinking it is. Keep your opinions to yourself and get out of your mother's basement already!
I personally don't own any of these consoles because I refuse to shell out that much money for something that might get me killed on the way out of the store(Wii), Something that might kill over after a few hours(xbox360}, or something that seems to turn everyone that touches one into an insane d bag(PS3}. I am more then happy with my last gen consoles and atari..... and N64....and sega genesis.
September 15th, 2008 11:05AM(PT)
RabidChinaGirl
Over 10 Sunday Special articles later, and people are still taking these a little too seriously. Man, PS3 owners can be so touchy. I'm tired of the Xbox stereotype -- I'm not a tea-bagging frat boy, I'm a 5'3" Asian chick who likes the spirit of competition. Xbox 360's don't explode after a month of use, and people still associate them with RRoD (while many fail to understand what RRoD is). Oh well? So what if the PS3 is labeled as the most expensive console?

The article isn't supposed to be some revelation to those without a clue. If you haven't noticed, most readers on this site know their consoles, and most Sunday Specials do nothing more than make fun of the obvious. Now come off that high horse, people.

Yes, I am the author.
September 15th, 2008 12:14PM(PT)
JT gAnGstA
quote oni_hero
The xbox360 is for your average gamer who wants some action games along with sports and such.
I consider GOW 2 to fall under the hardcore column, as well as the 360 in general (many people bought the 360 for halo/GOW alone, and that is pretty hardcore fanship there)

quote oni_hero
The PS3 is for the more hardcore gamer who is obsessive about the tech in their console and is looking for games like Metal gear solid and other PS3 exclusives.
The PS3 is hardcore as well, but it is not more hardcore than the 360, and before you say I'm a fanboy, I think both consoles are both as hardcore, and it depends on which one you like.

quote oni_hero
The Wii is for your casual gamer who is looking to just have some fun with their console, mainly Wiisports type games that may come off gimmicky, but are fun and easy to learn.
The Wii is casual other than the hardcore Nintendo games. However, there are a lot of hardcore third party titles coming to the Wii, and they all look promising, so the Wii will improve on that issue eventually.
September 15th, 2008 2:22PM(PT)
ron
ps1 and ps2 are the best, i would say ps3 but that piece of crap wont play my ps1 and ps2 games that i have spent hundreds on....

is this sony saying once you complete a game you go out and buy another £45 game instead of being ableto play a ps1 or ps2 game while your saving for your next ps3 game....
September 15th, 2008 2:58PM(PT)
kspiess
The PC is better than consoles anyways
September 15th, 2008 3:05PM(PT)
DavidWinchester
"is now one of the cheaper consoles out there but carries an unfortunate reputation involving a red ring, caused by overheating problems within the machine"

you just showed yourself a fanboy with this...
the RRoD its not just because overheating, that by the way only happens cuz MS try to stuff a HDD and wireless controler in a late stage of development.
there are tuns of ways the 360 can die, even a MS eg said that "every 360 out there is a time bomb"

as for hardware, MS stoped saiyng "we have the most powerful and cheap console" after games like Uncharted outshine anything on their system, that by the way was Gears of War.
and lets not forget MGS4 that cleans is @$$ with anything and everything the 360 has to ofer.

to close, XBL doesn't have anything that the PSN don't, and on the PSN you get it for free, even the themes for your precious dashboard are paid, the ones for the XMB are free.
Trophies > gamerscore in every way, and games are already outshining the 360 ones, look at Heavy Rain, i don't think the 360 can run that.

360 had their moment in the 1st year of the PS3, when multy plat games look slight better on the 360, but thats over now. multy plat games are starting to look better on the PS3, like Burnout and GTAIV, not only GTAIV lookt better on the PS3 (standart low brightness on the 360 doesn't count as better graphycs, you can get even better results on the PS3 if you lower the brightness) but the fact that you can play with no pause is a clear statment that standart HDD on the PS3 is a big advantage.

and what to say about MGS4 50GB? how many DVD for that? don't just 50/7=7.14 doesn't work that way, stuff like iPod songs, wireframe and skins of guns, guns sound efects, etc, etc, etc, etc, have to be in all the DVD's, cuz you allways have to acess them.
and no HDD doesn't help too...


realy i hate guys that say "i'm no fanboy, and then start writing stuff like you do"

PS3>360

price cut up the poor sales of 360? have fun with a sys that has over 37% chance of dying (PS3 is 0,3% or something like that, and by the way, Sony doesn't patch up a broken system like MS, Sony gives you a brand new one, MS just patch them up and send them back to you, thats why 3 weeks later in on MS again...)
September 15th, 2008 8:13PM(PT)
twizttid13
Have to agree with JT that the 360 does have games for the hardcore fanbase as well, not just the PS3.

quote kspiess
The PC is better than consoles anyways
Yea I'm a big PC fan too. I like the ability to upgrade it. On another note PS3 owners seem to be very touchy.

- This news story is archived and is closed to new comments now -

  RSS Feeds

Latest Comments
Most Comments

Latest Net Reviews:
Latest Inhouse:


Compare Prices

Motherboards
 Abit
 ASUS
 Gigabyte
 Intel
 iWill
 Shuttle
 Soyo
 Super Micro
 Tyan
 More...

Processors
 AMD
 Intel
 More...

Memory
 SDRAM
 RDRAM
 DDRAM
 More...

Video Cards
 ATI
 Visiontek
 PNY
 3Dfx
 More...

search for lowest prices
(0.1892/d/nova)