Neoseeker : News : Microsoft says Sony, Nintendo and Apple aren't mean enough to modders
Hardware Newsletter:
Email:

Latest News
Tue, Nov 18
Mon, Nov 17
Sun, Nov 16
Sat, Nov 15
Fri, Nov 14
Thu, Nov 13

send article   article comments (5)

Microsoft says Sony, Nintendo and Apple aren't mean enough to modders
Sean Ridgeley - Friday, April 11th, 2008 | 10:49AM (PT)


No XNA measures means asking for trouble?

Microsoft says Sony, Nintendo and Apple aren't mean enough to modders Image 1

According to Chris Satchell, Microsoft's XNA group manager, companies like Sony, Nintendo and Apple (everyone but Microsoft basically) are "inviting trouble" if they aren't implementing XNA-style security measures to protect against malicious user-generated content. XNA, if you don't know, is a set of tools designed by the company that assists in computer game design, development and management.

"I think there's a potential risk on any platform where you're allowing...where you're running in what we call native mode, where you're writing straight to the metal, not a sandbox layer like XNA, and then that runs a script engine and you let people do that in that script engine," Satchell told Eurogamer. "Any platform that let's you do that, and doesn't have the right security measures in place - whether it's Sony, whether it's Nintendo, whether it's Apple, whether it's anyone - you're inviting trouble, because sooner or later someone will want to prove they can do it."

Of course, I'd kind of expect a Microsoft man to encourage every big company in the industry to use his product, but, you know, maybe he's right? In any case, I do kind of have to wonder if all this stuff is useless. I mean, I think that maybe implementing this kind of system is, in its own way, inviting trouble, because, just as he said, sooner or later someone will want to prove they can do it. The harder something is to crack, the harder someone out there will try, and then share their success with everyone else.

Don't take this to mean Microsoft is against modding however, because, as previously discussed over on our sister site, GameGrep, they most certainly are not, they simply want appropriate content in their online communities, which is entirely reasonable. Should Sony, Nintendo and Apple go after the same?

  Related Stories

  Related Reviews & Articles

back to news    comments or corrections
- This news story is archived and is closed to comments now -

Comments:

April 11th, 2008 11:45AM(PT)
imaballa
Thats kinda stupid statement to make by Microsoft considering their firmware for the Xbox 360 got hacked within 4 months of its release, and hackers have yet to crack the PS3 firmware fully after over a year being on the market.
April 12th, 2008 4:58AM(PT)
THM
None of the electronic companies are immuned to hackers or modders!!!

Not even NASA!!!
April 12th, 2008 8:52AM(PT)
chautemoc
Haha. NASA should totally make a console.
April 12th, 2008 11:59AM(PT)
riiaku
Personally modding promotes innovation. If you go the microsoft way, innovation goes out the window and you get crap built on crap. Crap that they believe is cool. More power to the modders. Look at counterstrike, that started off as a mod and became a net sensation. Whether it be hardware or software mod, keep it going. There will always be something or someone better that has a better mod. Microsoft shouldn't have the power to decide what is the ultimate say.
April 12th, 2008 12:02PM(PT)
chautemoc
riiaku, I agree. Well said. The industry should be more free. The more free, the more healthy it is, and the better experiences we all get in the end.
April 12th, 2008 2:32PM(PT)
DeathMonkey
Except when some people get hack/cheat happy, thereby ruining the game

- This news story is archived and is closed to new comments now -

  RSS Feeds

Latest Comments
Most Comments

Latest Net Reviews:
Latest Inhouse:


Compare Prices

Motherboards
 Abit
 ASUS
 Gigabyte
 Intel
 iWill
 Shuttle
 Soyo
 Super Micro
 Tyan
 More...

Processors
 AMD
 Intel
 More...

Memory
 SDRAM
 RDRAM
 DDRAM
 More...

Video Cards
 ATI
 Visiontek
 PNY
 3Dfx
 More...

search for lowest prices
(0.2500/mc/ascension)