Tomb Raider developer continues to insist game contains no sexual assault
Despite obvious groping, Crystal Dynamics stands firm
Tomb Raider developer Crystal Dynamics has further commented on the huge controversy surrounding a would-be rape scene in the franchise's forthcoming reboot.
Global brand director Karl Stewart stressed the comments made by executive producer Ron Rosenberg where he mentioned the word "rape" is not in the developer's "vocabulary" or "communication."
As for the scene in question to which the controversy is based on (an island enemy inappropriately stroking Lara), Stewart stated despite the lead character being female, it still cannot be classified as sexual assault.
"He did say it… It’s his personal opinion and certainly… like I said, it’s not something that we communicate."
He goes on to note that the scene is not really rape, more of a "pathological situation" meant to evoke fear and intimidation. Although he admits that the groping wouldn't have happened to a male character such as Nathan Drake, he continues to insist the scene doesn't portray sexual assault.
"We have a female character that we're very proud and very honored to be able to have in our game and build a story around. And by giving her motivation to become the stronger action-adventure hero and the girl that’s willing to fight to stay alive and move forward throughout the game, we use that device and that intimidation to make her stronger. To make her feel empowered and to take her beyond that breaking point where she realises the severity of the situation and she’s willing to fight to stay alive."
When Stewart is pushed into further comments, PR stepped in, interrupting his explanation and stating "nothing sexual occurred" after the uncomfortable scene. Says the PR rep:
"I’m pretty sure Karl answered as well as he can the question- I understand where you’re going with this, I think it’s like, you can see the outcome if this continues, but nothing sexual occurred. Violence occurred as a result of that. I just don’t think you’re going to get any further than what you’re getting out of Karl."
Ultimately, Stewart concluded by somewhat defending Rosenberg's use of the word in question:
"We are not building a game where we’re basically saying ‘Hey… our goal is to have the player protect Lara. That’s your choice in playing the game. How you interpret it is your choice. What Ron is saying… that’s the results from fairly significant amounts of play-testers."
Tomb Raider is due for a release on March 5, 2013. You can read our impressions of the E3 demo here, during which the described scene was showcased to attendees.
Source: Kotaku
Sections: Microsoft Consoles, Console Games, PC Games, Sony Consoles
Latest Comments
- PC port of Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance confirmed, no release date given [10]
- Assassin's Creed movie, starring Michael Fassbender, coming to theaters Memorial Day 2015 [8]
- The Wonderful 101's not so wonderful release date announced, pushed to September 15 [4]
- Sonic Lost World announced, exclusive to Wii U and 3DS, as Sega and Nintendo form partnership [21]
- EA opens Los Angeles studio to act as DICE's base in the United States, help recruit talent [7]
- The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past successor announced for the 3DS, this holiday season [49]
- It's official, GameStop will stop taking PS2 trade-ins starting June 1, at least in the US [20]
- Prepare for another Metal Gear pack, PS3-only Metal Gear Solid: The Legacy Collection arriving July 9 [17]
Most Comments
- Several Pokemon revealed in latest CoroCoro Pokemon X and Y feature, also trainer customization [73]
- Pokemon X and Y welcomes us to Kalos, trailer showcases quartet of recently announced Pokemon [63]
- Rockstar introduces three very different Grand Theft Auto V psychopaths in three very exciting trailers [45]
- The Top 10 Manliest Manly Men in League of Legends [41]
- Rumor: Sony pitching "Greatness Awaits" as PlayStation 4's rallying cry [38]
- Anonymous encourages another Internet blackout on April 22 in protest of CISPA [36]
Latest News
- Sat, May 18
- Assassin's Creed movie, starring Michael Fassbender, coming to theaters Memorial Day 2015
- Fri, May 17
- Dust: An Elysian Tail hitting PC May 24, the Blade of Ahrah and the power it controls awaits
- PC port of Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance confirmed, no release date given
- The Wonderful 101's not so wonderful release date announced, pushed to September 15
- Trion Worlds, developer for MMOs RIFT and Defiance, suffers heavy layoffs
- Team Fortress' "Robotic Boogaloo" update hits, first to be entirely developed by the community
- Pikmin 3 replaces Olimar with Alph, Brittany and Captain Charlie, fresh and fruity details
- Prepare for another Metal Gear pack, PS3-only Metal Gear Solid: The Legacy Collection arriving July 9
- 13 Game Gear games coming to the 3DS Virtual Console, including Columns and Sonic the Hedgehog
- Mario & Sonic at the Sochi 2014 Olympic Winter Games hitting the slopes on Wii U, very cool
- Sonic Lost World announced, exclusive to Wii U and 3DS, as Sega and Nintendo form partnership
- Nintendo Direct May 17: Liveblog and Discussion
- Thu, May 16
- April NPD Number Crunch: DC superheroes & zombies dethrone BioShock: Infinite
- EA enters the world of fantasy MOBA with Dawngate, since there can never be enough
- Metro: Last Light patched to allow FOV adjustments, also fixes AMD problems
- Lords of the Fallen announced for next-gen consoles and PC, made by Sniper devs CI Games
- Panopticon teaser trailer from Sony Japan Studio goes full anime, futuristic apocalypse with giant robots
- May Nintendo Direct event tomorrow, May 17, to cover summer launches for Wii U and 3DS
- Official teaser trailer for Batman: Arkham Origins hits, just like Deathstroke would like to do to Batman
- Microsoft reportedly dropping Xbox Points in favor of new gift card system
- Wed, May 15
- Far Cry 3 rakes in 6 million sales, Assassin's Creed 3 and Just Dance 4 also performing well for Ubisoft
- Ubisoft reports $83.3 million in profits for the first fiscal year of 2013, thanks to successful franchises
- Valve announces Steam Trading Cards, earn virtual cards by playing games on Steam
- Ubisoft suspends 1666 development after firing Partice Desilets
- Edward Kenway's bloody quest for freedom in Assassin's Creed 4's 'Under the Black Flag' trailer
Latest Net Reviews
| · | Noctua NH-U14S |
| · | Plextor M5 Pro (German) |
| · | Seasonic Platinum SS-660XP2 (German) |
| · | Rosewill RDEE-12002 |
| · | Cooler Master V700 (French) |
| · | 32/64GB USB 3.0 Flash Memory Drive |




next
1 2
"Psh, what sexual assault?" Uh...
I just hope they keep the scene in and stand their ground.
Look at Hollywood, if a movie wants to build tension with a female character being threatened by a male antagonist, it usually involves something sexual, Why? Because it is a truly evil disgusting act. It pushes the fact that the individual is a truly sick and deranged creature, that hardly has any attachment to human emotion. Someone simply holding a knife to someone's throat shows deranged sure, but not sick and twisted, it's too common of a tool now adays. It's like watching a scene from an old Friday the 13th where someone gets his head chopped off, and then watching a scene from a movie like Hostel(I can't stand the movie personally) and watching someone be slowly tortured and then after living through all the pain and suffering, getting their head chopped off.
Tell me that you would have the same reaction emotionally to someone holding a knife to her throat, as to someone who is looking to harm her in a far worse way and THEN kill her after torturing her. Honestly it makes her character that much more powerful for fighting her way out of it. It amplifies the scene so much more, and it never, at least in my mind, crosses the line into the distasteful.
"Attempting to begin sexual assault" is much more accurate.
On a side note, that trailer guarantedd my purchase of this game. Looks amazing.
They really could be handling this with a lot more grace, either way.
Or something. I hope I phrased that right. And as a side note to that, this doesn't mean games should get away with sexual assault for the sake of it. In this case, it works, managing to convey emotion and give the player a sense that the character is progressing and growing stronger, mentally and emotionally in this case. Beating up a woman and *bleep* her....that's disgusting and is a form of sexual assault that hopefully won't be in any future games.
Once again, I hope I phrased that right. I have a hard time getting my point across through text alone.
I don't see how the controversy over this so called 'sexual assault' scene even came to be. The devs did the right thing by including that scene; it was to get their message across. I don't see what's so hard to understand about that. Just goes to show how ridiculous and hypocritical the media is getting today.
Personally I think an arrow to the knee would do the job, threaten to end her adventuring days once and for all!
next
1 2