Neoseeker.com Forum Thread: Which players do you think will be overrated? - page 5

reprinted from http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/
original thread: http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/57790/t1745986-which-players-you-think-overrated/5.htm


Author:   Jord22
Date:   Jul 26, 12 at 5:47pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
Doubt Kagawa will be overated considering he's absolute class.

Overating was never Fifa's problem imo, it was good players being underated.

Saying that Evra will be a brick wall yet again.



Author:   Scottyefc
Date:   Jul 28, 12 at 4:24pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
Carragher will be overrated even though he's past it now.



Author:   Pestar
Date:   Jul 28, 12 at 4:27pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
Pienaar will be overrated to balance out Everton's squad.



Author:   Scottyefc
Date:   Jul 28, 12 at 4:28pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
quote PEStar
Pienaar will be overrated to balance out Everton's squad.
Now, now PEStar. There's no need to resort to childish digs is there?



Author:   Pestar
Date:   Jul 28, 12 at 4:30pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
I've done enough of those tonight.

I'm saying he will to get up to the lofty brilliance of the Toffees' squad Michael.



Author:   Scottyefc
Date:   Jul 28, 12 at 4:31pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
Ah well Paul, that's just fine and dandy isn't it!



Author:   IRISH BEATDOWN
Date:   Aug 07, 12 at 1:40pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
Most of the Liverpool players and I support them...



Author:   sheva chenko
Date:   Aug 09, 12 at 5:32pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
Pirlo better than Xavi. Not even in Pirlo's wildest dreams. Put him against a team that know how to stop the way Pirlo plays and he's hopeless. Xavi on the other hand can change his game. I think it was against Racing and a player was man marking Xavi so what did Xavi do? he dropped into his own half and the Racing player followed him leaving Iniesta and Messi(who dropped into midfield) in miles of space. Take the Spain - Italy game for example they were in Pirlo's face and then the game passed him by....how? because he's a 1 trick pony. Get off his dick because he was good in the Euros and decent last season.

Anyways overrated players...the usual suspects.



Author:   C0N0RH_AFC
Date:   Aug 10, 12 at 6:20am (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
quote sheva chenko
Pirlo better than Xavi. Not even in Pirlo's wildest dreams. Put him against a team that know how to stop the way Pirlo plays and he's hopeless. Xavi on the other hand can change his game. I think it was against Racing and a player was man marking Xavi so what did Xavi do? he dropped into his own half and the Racing player followed him leaving Iniesta and Messi(who dropped into midfield) in miles of space. Take the Spain - Italy game for example they were in Pirlo's face and then the game passed him by....how? because he's a 1 trick pony. Get off his dick because he was good in the Euros and decent last season.

Anyways overrated players...the usual suspects.
Oh dear. Good in the Euros and a decent season? player of the tournament and led Juve to the title more like. You're forgetting Pirlo has won the World Cup and Champions League(twice) I take it?

Not sure why you're using the final to prove anything, when they were playing with 10 for alot of the game, Cheillini went off after ten minutes and they hadn't had a rest after extra time with England.

May I remind you Italy played Spain in the group stage, did that game pass him by? well?

Bored of the Xavi wankfest, and this PIrlo vs Xavi, wonder ball vs 5 yard square pass, Incredible flowing locks vs greasy chip fat spikes.



Author:   sheva chenko
Date:   Aug 10, 12 at 7:03am (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
quote C0N0RH_AFC
Oh dear. Good in the Euros and a decent season? player of the tournament and led Juve to the title more like. You're forgetting Pirlo has won the World Cup and Champions League(twice) I take it?

Not sure why you're using the final to prove anything, when they were playing with 10 for alot of the game, Cheillini went off after ten minutes and they hadn't had a rest after extra time with England.

May I remind you Italy played Spain in the group stage, did that game pass him by? well?

Bored of the Xavi wankfest, and this PIrlo vs Xavi, wonder ball vs 5 yard square pass, Incredible flowing locks vs greasy chip fat spikes.
Ok then CL final Istanbul. Pirlo bossed the game first half...agreed? rafa figured this out at half time and realised he had to stop him so he brought on Hamann and did a shuffle so Pirlo wouldn't have time to dictate play. What was the result? the game passed him by and they lost the 2nd half 3-0. Fact! On more than 1 occasion Pirlo goes invisible aginst teams with a decent midfield. No plan B once you've stop him.....you have stopped him. Fact!

"I've watched him since he played for Brescia" Yeah he was good there but how about his spell at Inter? yeah he was average at best. You blatantly haven't been watching him his whole career.

Comments I made last season I slightly understated by saying decent, but I don't want to say great because of the match fixing involved during the full season.



Author:   C0N0RH_AFC
Date:   Aug 10, 12 at 8:01am (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
quote sheva chenko
"I've watched him since he played for Brescia" Yeah he was good there but how about his spell at Inter? yeah he was average at best. You blatantly haven't been watching him his whole career.

I never said that, you must be thinking of someone else.

Inter played him in his wrong position IIRC.



Author:   thetwilight
Date:   Aug 11, 12 at 9:01am (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
Aiden McGeady: Sure, he's one of the best and most creative wingers in the world, but he's not that good.



Author:   Suicide Messiah
Date:   Aug 11, 12 at 3:15pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
quote thetwilight
Aiden McGeady: Sure, he's one of the best and most creative wingers in the world, but he's not that good.




Author:   sheva chenko
Date:   Aug 12, 12 at 11:35am (PST)
Subject:   re: Which players do you think will be overrated?
-------------------------------------------
quote C0N0RH_AFC
I never said that, you must be thinking of someone else.

Inter played him in his wrong position IIRC.

Possibly someone else, not sure who said it.

Well when he was at Brescia he played more advanced then what he does now, so at the time it was the right position but in hindsight it was the wrong position. He really only became a deep lying playmaker at Milan.


Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2014.
All Rights Reserved.