Neoseeker.com Forum Thread: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions - page 9

reprinted from http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/
original thread: http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/44117/t1423915-requests-feedback-suggestions/9.htm


Author:   Slash
Date:   Sep 27, 09 at 11:35pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
As logcar said we could at least try to see if the idea works =/



Author:   Shadow Bolt
Date:   Sep 27, 09 at 11:39pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
quote Tf916
quote Shadowbolt
Without clans; this forum will have less people... =P
Platinum diddn't have clans and it's real active and new people come in everyday.
Compare that activity with the Diamond forums...



Author:   ProudLoz
Date:   Sep 28, 09 at 11:20am (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
quote Shadowbolt
quote Tf916
quote Shadowbolt
Without clans; this forum will have less people... =P
Platinum diddn't have clans and it's real active and new people come in everyday.
Compare that activity with the Diamond forums...
The only reason Diamond has that kind of activity is because you have a bunch of little kids going post happy. Imagine if they found that Platinum, HeartGold, and SoulSilver had Clan forums too. They're posting habits would increase, since that's all they do.

Unfortunately, we can't discuss this properly here, because this decision will most likely be based on a Moderator Level.




Author:   Glory Tyrant
Date:   Sep 28, 09 at 11:59am (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
I, personally, like the idea of a clan. I can, however, agree that it is annoying that little kids spam in certain posts but quite a bit of the posting on the clan forums is actual posting done by people who can comprehend things.

Hopefully the Moderator decides to let the Clans at least get a test run in the SS/HG forums.




Author:   Icekickseverything
Date:   Sep 28, 09 at 12:11pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
quote Glory Tyrant
I, personally, like the idea of a clan. I can, however, agree that it is annoying that little kids spam in certain posts but quite a bit of the posting on the clan forums is actual posting done by people who can comprehend things.
I agree
well we should at least try



Author:   MegaBassMan
Date:   Sep 28, 09 at 12:15pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
Clans do make it fun... But little kids DO go spam happy...


I prefer if we just stick it to the Diamond or possibly have a central Pokemon Clan Forum for D/P/PT/HG/SS.




Author:   Relmutsie AN
Date:   Sep 28, 09 at 1:03pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
Great idea guy! To bring more people to the forum, create a massive spam fest!



The general clan forum idea would not work. You are honestly just better off going to a Pokemon social forum. Oh, wait, we have one. Nobody uses it though.

Better yet, just host your own...I've always been in favour of running your own forum for clans (hell I did it before...but that's a different story) since it keeps all the little children away who're desperate to join every clan they possibly can.

Obviously people would be against this idea, but it's always been my take on the whole thing. Clans are, in essence, social forums, and they really shouldn't be on a site like Neoseeker. We have General Pokemon for that.




Author:   Sakura
Date:   Sep 28, 09 at 2:03pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
Okay, here's how it is. I don't even know if we are allowed to have clan forums anymore, because at one point they were trying to get rid of them (and they might still be). The input will be valuable for deciding if we should have them (if we are allowed to) about six months from now. For now though, let's discuss more relevant stuff. ^__^

Are the links under the header good? Do you guys want some fadey links like suggested on one of the earlier pages?




Author:   Dragoon
Date:   Sep 28, 09 at 2:19pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
The links in the header look nice, neat and professional. ^___^



Author:   Linnie
Date:   Sep 28, 09 at 9:17pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
I say we should see if these clans can mature before we try new ones. But I like the idea of HG/SS Clans.



Author:   Stormy
Date:   Sep 29, 09 at 3:09am (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
The links under the header look good. Maybe there could be one for the General Pokemon forum, though? I like the idea of that being used as an alternative to the apparently spammy clans.

This message was edited by Stormy on Sep 28 2009.



Author:   Soda
Date:   Oct 01, 09 at 12:25am (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
The layout of the forum is pretty.



Author:   Mor Havoc
Date:   Oct 01, 09 at 3:52am (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
Can I ask who made the header? Kudos to whoever it was.



Author:   Soda
Date:   Oct 01, 09 at 3:57am (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
quote Bottom of page
Header Created By: YoshiStar
Footer Created By: Lauzi




Author:   Bass
Date:   Oct 03, 09 at 10:30pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
-------------------------------------------
quote Relmutsie AN
Great idea guy! To bring more people to the forum, create a massive spam fest!



The general clan forum idea would not work. You are honestly just better off going to a Pokemon social forum. Oh, wait, we have one. Nobody uses it though.

Better yet, just host your own...I've always been in favour of running your own forum for clans (hell I did it before...but that's a different story) since it keeps all the little children away who're desperate to join every clan they possibly can.

Obviously people would be against this idea, but it's always been my take on the whole thing. Clans are, in essence, social forums, and they really shouldn't be on a site like Neoseeker. We have General Pokemon for that.



I just threw an idea out there. I didn't really think about it.


But yeah... They are pretty cool. How long did it take?



Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2014.
All Rights Reserved.