Neoseeker.com Forum Thread: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what. - page 5

reprinted from http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/
original thread: http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/32197/t1133553-brawl-vs-melee-better-about/5.htm


Author:   Wiitard
Date:   Apr 11, 08 at 5:51am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Melee- faster gameplay...

Brawl- better single player, still good gameplay just not as fast, better graphics, an almost decent online



Author:   Jungys
Date:   Apr 15, 08 at 4:34am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Brawl Pros:
ALOT of music choice
Larger Roster
Nice new stages
Stage Builder
Online Play
Variety of Control Types
Subspace Emissary

Brawl Cons:
Take out a few chars we know and love
Subspace gets REALLY boring after a while
Online is laggy
Wayyy too floaty and slower paced
Graphics haven't improved THAT much.

Melee Pros:
Its faster paced and more technical
Still looks pretty good for being a GC game
It wasn't super easy like brawl...
An original :]

Melee Cons:
No Wifi
An Okay 1st Player Mode
Doesn't have as much variety


I liked Melee better cuz it was so much faster, more exciting, and its a classic! Melee is like, Brawl's father. I also like melee better because most of it's music doesnt annoy the crap out of me. And because they nerfed Marth. Brawl is MUCHH too floaty. I hate it when your enemy is at 200 and won't die from Marth's fsmash and gets back to pull a lucky shot and kill you. >.< I think Brawl is just alittle too flashy. Although I do like the many new characters that they've added :]



Author:   johnnytwothumbs
Date:   Nov 26, 11 at 2:31am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Melee. Brawl is too easy, much less ways to be amazing at brawl. Melee is more difficult to play, allowing players to be better at it. Graphics don't matter, story doesn't matter, the game exists mainly for the multiplayer. The online takes away from the fun of having friends over and playing. Melee came out when I was in first grade and my friends and I still play it every weekend. I got bored of brawl pretty quickly



Author:   a
Date:   Mar 03, 12 at 1:50pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
melee beats brawl in every way possible.



Author:   Guilphlosion
Date:   Mar 03, 12 at 3:50pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Add Wolf and PT to melee then we'll talk. Give Bowser his flying slam in melee too.



Author:   Sephiroth25
Date:   Mar 30, 12 at 9:07pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Either something is terribly wrong with the universe and I didn't post in this thread, or my post got deleted because I posted in this thread.



Author:   HellYesNya
Date:   Apr 03, 12 at 7:48pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote Riquisimo
Brawl is awesome and all, yeah,

but i pwned with Roy. Marth is faster, but if you used Roy right, you could match well.

I wish they ported Roy.



..but im glad Pichu's gone. Pichu sucked. The End.

very well said i agree. ROY IS THE MOST BADASS CHARACTER.
in brawl i find that marth is not as good as he was in melee. he STILL lacks power



Author:   Sosai X
Date:   Apr 17, 12 at 3:53am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote Jungys
Brawl Pros:
ALOT of music choice
Larger Roster
Nice new stages
Stage Builder
Online Play
Variety of Control Types
Subspace Emissary

Brawl Cons:
Take out a few chars we know and love
Subspace gets REALLY boring after a while
Online is laggy
Wayyy too floaty and slower paced
Graphics haven't improved THAT much.

Melee Pros:
Its faster paced and more technical
Still looks pretty good for being a GC game
It wasn't super easy like brawl...
An original :]

Melee Cons:
No Wifi
An Okay 1st Player Mode
Doesn't have as much variety


I liked Melee better cuz it was so much faster, more exciting, and its a classic! Melee is like, Brawl's father. I also like melee better because most of it's music doesnt annoy the crap out of me. And because they nerfed Marth. Brawl is MUCHH too floaty. I hate it when your enemy is at 200 and won't die from Marth's fsmash and gets back to pull a lucky shot and kill you. >.< I think Brawl is just alittle too flashy. Although I do like the many new characters that they've added :]


I agree to pretty much everything he said. (:



Author:   Kingy
Date:   Apr 17, 12 at 10:34am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
The thing I love about Melee that Brawl just doesn't have is speed and sound effects. Smacking people around on Brawl just isn't as satisfying as it is on Melee. Half the reason I play Super Smash Brothers is because of the sound effects.



Author:   HellYesNya
Date:   Apr 17, 12 at 6:31pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote King X2
The thing I love about Melee that Brawl just doesn't have is speed and sound effects. Smacking people around on Brawl just isn't as satisfying as it is on Melee. Half the reason I play Super Smash Brothers is because of the sound effects.
actually i think brawl has more sound effects, cause they included FX for when you take damage, which melee did not have. but, i like the sound effects in melee better because there arent as many so its less obnoxious, and they really should have left the speed the same because it makes me fudge up on both games because my timing is either too slow or too fast



Author:   Game Hacker 9000
Date:   Jul 16, 12 at 5:33am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Well, I think brawl wins, I wish they didnt replace Mewtwo with Lucario though D:<



Author:   AgatioGanon
Date:   Sep 22, 12 at 12:21pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Brawl is definately better

Everytime I try to play Melee, I end up shutting it off in like 5 minutes because it's so boring.

They should of replaced Jigglypuff instead because Jigglypuff is a piece of garbage and it's a normal type and everyone knows normal type suck.

I would of loved to see Mewtwo vs Lucario in Brawl!

I think another pokemon, Blazeken was supposed to be in Brawl too, it would have interesting to him put in or put another trainer in, maybe May so she would have Blazeken.



Author:   Mario_1
Date:   Sep 24, 12 at 10:33am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Wow, this is an old thread, but I guess I might as well post.

Melee has the superior gravity, and no one ever trips.
For everything else, though, I prefer Brawl easily.



Author:   WooperOnALedge
Date:   Oct 01, 12 at 4:20am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
i prefer brawl, after playing brawl so much its hard to go back to melee



Author:   communist fish
Date:   Jan 10, 14 at 10:50pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Project:M is better than brawl and it's basically melee 2.


Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2014.
All Rights Reserved.