Neoseeker.com Forum Thread: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what. - page 4

reprinted from http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/
original thread: http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/32197/t1133553-brawl-vs-melee-better-about/4.htm


Author:   kingy
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 10:35pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
I liked Melee for the sound of the attacks, and the overall feel of the game. I don't know what it is, but Melee just seems to be a more epic game for VS matches and tourneys.



Author:   billybob1
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 10:38pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote The5thAvacado
Items in this game are crap, but that's all the more reason to never use them.

Melee was more artistically realistic. Peach looked like a woman, a real woman. Bowser looked like a lizard, as did Yoshi. Mario's overalls looked like real denim. But now there are softer effects and less realistic characters. Yoshi is fat, lighter green, and not scaly. And Bowser is definitely not scaly (not to mention he sounds like a car without a muffler instead of hm... AN EVIL LIZARD?)
WHAT! you gotta be kidding me. havent u seen the details in peachs dress let alone giga bowser and his stupidity



Author:   The5thAvocado
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 10:48pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
I never said anything about G. Koops... He's still pretty cool, I guess, but I've only seen him in action once and I've seen his trophy.

But Peach's dress is too wide, and her body itself is too thin. She looks similar, but she was just more human looking in Melee.



Author:   Weavilax
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 10:59pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote billybob11223
quote Riquisimo
Brawl is awesome and all, yeah,

but i pwned with Roy. Marth is faster, but if you used Roy right, you could match well.

I wish they ported Roy.



..but im glad Pichu's gone. Pichu sucked. The End.
pikachu=pichu

they were the same thing in meelee, so y not bring pichu instead
First off, no, they weren't the same, alot of move
mechanics were different, second, Pikachu > Pichu
because he's the mascot for pokemon T_T



Author:   Ario92
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 11:21pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
^Pichu was faster, weaker and did self damage when using electric moves

I'm on the fence, I used to play as Samus but feel she's been nerfed a bit for Brawl, too floaty and slow. Whoever thought of tripping needs to be shot. Repeatedly. In the crotch.



Author:   GameTester113
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 11:28pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
They should keep every character they ever did and add new ones like Geno most people like this mega man and just me Jak I mean who wouldn't want to use 9 different guns in a game like this.



Author:   Frozen Atari
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 11:29pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
I like Melee because it flowed better and not every character relied primarily on forward smash and Forward aerial to KO a person. Yet Brawl feels more balanced and unlike Melee, every move has its uses. (Save just a few)

If only I could make some crazy monster hybrid of the two games...



Author:   Forsaker
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 11:35pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
I played all the SSB series Melee was good but Brawl was pure awesome I mean seriously you can go days playing that game not realizing that your half dead!



Author:   billybob1
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 11:51pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote Weavilax
quote billybob11223
quote Riquisimo
Brawl is awesome and all, yeah,

but i pwned with Roy. Marth is faster, but if you used Roy right, you could match well.

I wish they ported Roy.



..but im glad Pichu's gone. Pichu sucked. The End.
pikachu=pichu

they were the same thing in meelee, so y not bring pichu instead
First off, no, they weren't the same, alot of move
mechanics were different, second, Pikachu > Pichu
because he's the mascot for pokemon T_T
lol but u cant make a pikachu without starting with a pichu.

I think that pichu was pretty cool, not one of my faves though, so u guys shouldnt be trying to make a fight bout her when pichu is ok



Author:   Eggz14
Date:   Apr 11, 08 at 12:36am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
at least brawl actually has a plot to adventure mode.
melee's adventure mode had no point. it was just some characters going place to place if i remember.



Author:   The5thAvocado
Date:   Apr 11, 08 at 12:40am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote Frozen Atari
I like Melee because it flowed better and not every character relied primarily on forward smash and Forward aerial to KO a person.
What?

I admit, many characters' Fairs are their better attacks (Sonic, Meta Knight), but there are people like Ike whose Bair is faster and better. Wolf has a good Fair, but his Bair is beastly. I also know that few characters rely on Fsmashes to win.



Author:   Distortion
Date:   Apr 11, 08 at 12:40am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote GameTester113
They should keep every character they ever did and add new ones like Geno most people like this mega man and just me Jak I mean who wouldn't want to use 9 different guns in a game like this.
Geno is property of Square Enix and so likely will never appear in another Nintendo game. Same with Mega Man and Capcom.

Of course the graphics are better on Brawl, and the gameplay feels smoother, if a little slower.




Author:   Kilik 64
Date:   Apr 11, 08 at 1:12am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote shadow993
Geno is property of Square Enix and so likely will never appear in another Nintendo game. Same with Mega Man and Capcom.
Wrong. As far as we can tell, any character can be in, assuming they have been in a game on a Nintendo console that did well. While I'm not too sure about Geno, Megaman has without a doubt been an asset to Nintendo.



Author:   Brawlfan1234
Date:   Apr 11, 08 at 2:00am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
For all you saying Pichu > Pikachu

Pichu is an epic failure

Case closed



Author:   Distortion
Date:   Apr 11, 08 at 2:14am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote Kilik 64
quote shadow993
Geno is property of Square Enix and so likely will never appear in another Nintendo game. Same with Mega Man and Capcom.
Wrong. As far as we can tell, any character can be in, assuming they have been in a game on a Nintendo console that did well. While I'm not too sure about Geno, Megaman has without a doubt been an asset to Nintendo.
And how, exactly has he been an asset to Nintendo?


Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2014.
All Rights Reserved.