Neoseeker.com Forum Thread: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what. - page 3

reprinted from http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/
original thread: http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/32197/t1133553-brawl-vs-melee-better-about/3.htm


Author:   Brawlfan1234
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 2:16am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote billybob11223
quote kirbyhyrule
quote billybob11223
quote kirbyhyrule
quote billybob11223
quote Brawlfan1234
Pichu= Epic Fail
okay im just gunna stop arguing. although no one is saying any LOGICAL resoning of pichu being bad. none of u guys like cute things thats y!
only hurt herself on down b attack andi thought it sis same amont of damage
Pichu, hurts him/her self when doing attacks, he/she is faster and smaller but does less damage.
�_�

Well the point is, Pichu is lower than Pikachu in the tier list so, there Pikachu is better.
wat the crap is a tier
Wow. Just WoW

lol, really look at the sticky Tier Disscusion



Author:   billybob1
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 2:18am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
oh my gosh. u people just going like WOWOOOWOOWOOW is not helping me



Author:   Templeton
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 2:23am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
dont be mean.
a tier list is a list of all the characters that some people assume determines which characters are best.
They take speed, power, combos, strategy etc. into mind to make the list.
Number one being the "Best"



Author:   billybob1
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 2:24am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote Templeton
dont be mean.
a tier list is a list of all the characters that some people assume determines which characters are best.
They take speed, power, combos, strategy etc. into mind to make the list.
Number one being the "Best"
thats the stupidest thing ive ever heard. i bet my main is at the bottom just because jiggly is light. gosh i hate that!



Author:   Goats
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 2:53am (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote billybob11223
thats the stupidest thing ive ever heard. i bet my main is at the bottom just because jiggly is light. gosh i hate that!
Actually, Jigglypuff is around the middle.


On topic, Brawl seems so much more enjoyable to me. When I first played Melee, I got bored of it within the first week, even if I played with humans. I have not been sick of Brawl, yet.

Brawl's soundtrack is superior to Melee's in every way possible, as well.



Author:   billybob1
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 12:47pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote Goats
quote billybob11223
thats the stupidest thing ive ever heard. i bet my main is at the bottom just because jiggly is light. gosh i hate that!
Actually, Jigglypuff is around the middle.


On topic, Brawl seems so much more enjoyable to me. When I first played Melee, I got bored of it within the first week, even if I played with humans. I have not been sick of Brawl, yet.

Brawl's soundtrack is superior to Melee's in every way possible, as well.
yeah, but i never got tired of meelee when it was out. it was really fun with all my buds, but now i got a better one



Author:   Brolynick
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 2:03pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
How about this...Melee beats Brawl in faster gameplay, more combos, loading times...



Author:   Brawlfan1234
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 7:36pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Umm no, it doesnt beat it in faster gameplay



Author:   SuperSonic123
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 8:31pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Loading times? They had loading times? And Brawl can be fast if you know how to play right.



Author:   KOjira94
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 8:37pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
I justhate lag and that they removed some potentially buffed characters like roy mewtwo and young link. imo roy is a waaay better than marth with the fire and stuff. all they had to do was make him less of a clone like what they did to falco, but nooo they just gave him teh boot instead.

srry for rambling



Author:   Delighted
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 8:47pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote billybob11223
quote Templeton
dont be mean.
a tier list is a list of all the characters that some people assume determines which characters are best.
They take speed, power, combos, strategy etc. into mind to make the list.
Number one being the "Best"
thats the stupidest thing ive ever heard. i bet my main is at the bottom just because jiggly is light. gosh i hate that!
Well, once you actually read the sticky on the page, I'm sure that you'll understand better about the whole thing and it's not just about the weight of the character.

On a side note, Mr. Game and Watch is one of the lightest characters in the game and he's at the top of the Middle tier. Almost in the high/top tier.

On topic :

I prefer Brawl over Melee. Mainly because I disliked the BGM of Melee's menus and stages, and in Brawl, you get to actually hear different soundtracks.

Brawl has Wi-Fi, and it's fun once you get a non-laggy match.

No more wavedashing. (Sorry to people who love to WD)

Items are a bit more hax. (In Brawl) So, I'd go with Melee's items this time. (They took out Red Shells/Flippers!)




Author:   Gotitmemorized
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 9:09pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
quote Steel Eyer
ok... going back to the topic
i personally like melee better...

cause i liked it wen you had to work ur butt off trying to unlock the characters.. in brawl theres an option of also going through subspace to unlock the characters...

i liked it better when u earned the characters the hard way
agreed. I unlocked all the characters in two easy days. In melee alot of the challenge was unlocking characters, especially those who didnt just lppk up how to do it (like me)

edit:: oh, and anybody who thinks Brawl keeps up with Melee's game speed....needs to go back and play melee. Brawl is slow motion compared to Melee.



Author:   Kilik 64
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 9:50pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Ike is in Brawl. Ike > Roy



Author:   billybob1
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 10:27pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
i think that the characters were harder to unlock in meelee but i liked that jiggly was extremely easy. i could play as jiggly more hurah.

i like brawl becauz its straight to the point and the fact that it has a story mode, unlike meelee who had adventure mode but no story



Author:   The5thAvocado
Date:   Apr 10, 08 at 10:32pm (PST)
Subject:   re: Brawl Vs Melee. What is better about what.
-------------------------------------------
Items in this game are crap, but that's all the more reason to never use them.

Melee was more artistically realistic. Peach looked like a woman, a real woman. Bowser looked like a lizard, as did Yoshi. Mario's overalls looked like real denim. But now there are softer effects and less realistic characters. Yoshi is fat, lighter green, and not scaly. And Bowser is definitely not scaly (not to mention he sounds like a car without a muffler instead of hm... AN EVIL LIZARD?)


Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2014.
All Rights Reserved.