Neoseeker.com Forum Thread: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii - page 1

reprinted from http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/
original thread: http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/32039/t1081664-games-faceoff-brawl-vs-mario-kart-wii/


Author:   Twisted
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 12:21am (PST)
Subject:   Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
Remember that thread that we had a while ago that people would vote for a game, and whichever won would go on to face off against other game? Well instead of bumping that thread, I made a new one.

Rules: You can only vote once per each round. The winners will be posted every 3 days.

Round 1:
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess vs. Super Mario Galaxy.

Super Mario Galaxy: 7 Votes


The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess: 10 Votes


I vote for TP.

Have fun!


Twilight Princess wins.


[size=1][color=#666666]This message was edited by Andrew5 on May 04 2008.




Author:   ConkerASkyJockey
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 12:24am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
Did you get moderator permission to start a game thread?

If so, then I vote for the Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess. Don't get me wrong, both games are incredible. Only that Twilight Princess had better exploration, difficulties and length.




Author:   Twisted
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 12:25am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
Oh, no, I didn't ask Sonic Flash for permission... But since there was a thread like this a while ago, I thought it would be ok.
And Sonic Flash, if this is not ok with you then close it.




Author:   Big A2
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 1:23am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
Twilight Princess, and would you mind shosing the real cover for SMG?



Author:   gameboy613
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 1:44am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
TP. Stunning visuals, excellent gameplay. The best Zelda game ever created IMO. Only thing it lacked was a difficult final boss.



Author:   WHY ME11
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 3:30am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
Zelda



Author:   Peek_a_buu
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 4:55am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff- Super Mario Galaxy vs. Twilight Princess
-------------------------------------------
Are you guys serious? An updated port of a Gamecube game better than Super Mario Galaxy? I love Twilight Princess as much as the next guy, but Mario is much better and suits the Wii better.



Author:   ConkerASkyJockey
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 5:21am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
What's your point? Twilight Princess had better controls, length, difficulty and maybe even in graphics. It deserves some credit, and Galaxy isn't that good as it seems.



Author:   Halowner
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 5:27am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
Twilight Princess. More innovative, easier to control. I struggled with Mario trying to walk upside down. Sup CASJ?



Author:   Nintendo_boy_94
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 5:39am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
Are you people seirous?

Super Mario Galaxy owns Toilet Princess! Who wants to have to actually THINK when playing a video game? I just wanna sit down and get from point A to point B with out having to always look at guides.

Thats what schools for, thinking. I get enough of that during the week, thank you very much.


I VOTE FOR GALAXY!!



Author:   ConkerASkyJockey
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 5:43am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff- Super Mario Galaxy vs. Twilight Princess
-------------------------------------------
When I get a adventure game, I expect it to be long and challenging. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess gave me that, while Galaxy gave me half of the challenging part.

Also, nobody cares if your that dumb in video games.


This message was edited by ConkerASkyJockey06 on Jan 19 2008.



Author:   Princess Midna
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 5:57am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
Twilight Princess for sure would be my vote



Author:   My Apocalypse
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 8:31am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
Twilight Princess, hands down.

Sure, the graphics probably aren't as good as Galaxy, and yeah it probably could have used the Wii controls a bit better, but considering it was ported from the GameCube, it's truly awesome. Deep story line, action-adventure style game play, fair sized main quest, how could you go wrong with Twilight Princess?

And before somebody else asks, yes. I'm serious. DEAD serious.



Author:   Quill
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 9:47am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
its really hard to choose but...

I enjoyed twilight princess stroyline and the graphics were fantastic. Mario Galaxy had a better storyline im sure i really enjoyed it more.

Mario Galaxy is my vote



Author:   Peek_a_buu
Date:   Jan 20, 08 at 10:27am (PST)
Subject:   re: Games Faceoff - Brawl VS. Mario Kart Wii
-------------------------------------------
quote quill9
its really hard to choose but...

I enjoyed twilight princess stroyline and the graphics were fantastic. Mario Galaxy had a better storyline im sure i really enjoyed it more.

Mario Galaxy is my vote
Mario Galaxy has not got a storyline. I don't know what game you were playing, but the plot in SMG was Bowser kidnaps Princess, Mario saves her. Not really comparable to TP. Although I still voted SMG, I know TP has a better plot.

ConkerASkyJockey06, what in gods name are you talking about, TP having better graphics than Super Mario Galaxy? Have you played it? TP is a Gamecube port, SMG has probably the best graphics of any game on Wii.

And My Apocalypse, when you say "considering it was ported from the GameCube, it's truly awesome" what the hell does that mean. It's the same game flipped around and using Wii controls. That's it. I loved TP alot, but Super Mario Galaxy is so much better in terms of pure fun.



Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2014.
All Rights Reserved.