SPOILER WARNING: DO NOT READ IF YOU HAVE NOT READ THE BOOK OR WATCHED THE MOVIE!! (I AM NOT RESPONSIBLE IF YOU GET YOUR READING OR MOVIE EXPERIENCE DAMAGED BY AN SPOILER POST. ENJOY
I believe that this movie was not as good as the others in the fact that they could have added 1 more hour and given more details about the things happening
The scenes were a little out of order (isn't Malfoy's group appointed to be high inquisitors or or whatever they were named after Dumbledore leaves Hogwarts?)
Some scenes did not correspond to the book (Dobby warns DA before they are officially discovered they were not at the room and there were no wall breaking and the decrees were not all corresponding to the book)
the movie lacks a lot of important scenes (like the fight at the headmaster's office)
I believe there could be more Fred and George and Quidditch scenes
I'm not ranting, only criticizing and giving an opinion what do you think?
I liked it, although I think criticism is always a plus for movies
Thread Recap (last 10 posts from newest to oldest)
Jan 03, 12 at 3:14am
look the movies always leave stuff out that was in the book. they are always out of order because of hollywood and stuff.
It was okay, much better than the last 2. But yeah, it should of had more scenes so people who didn't read the book can undestand it.
I think that the fourth one was better than Order of Phoneix.
Mar 31, 09 at 8:22pm
Shave ya Head
Do you people have any idea how long the film would be if it showed everything that is written in the book, besides it couldnt, cos the films are BASED on the books
Dec 17, 08 at 9:13pm
OMG the films are soooo much better than the books (in my opinion) It was a bit disappointed though I agree.
Dec 13, 08 at 7:22am
Sorry the last thing was
Tom Marvlolo Riddle = I Am Lord Voldimort = LAME AND GAY!!
Dec 13, 08 at 7:14am
Well, if i must say i enjoyed the movie because to me it did make sence, since i am english i supoz it would make since Muggles are so unappointed.And if you like Voldimort you are so stupid because the main line is about Harry NOT Voldimort. If those people who liked it add me as a friend i could give them updates on some pix.
Tom Marvolo Riddle = I am Voldemort + LAMB and GAY
Dec 04, 08 at 3:48pm
I'm just gutted that Lordy V don't show in the film/book, only as flashbacks and memories, and that's before he turned awesome...
Apr 17, 08 at 10:08pm
I actually quite enjoyed the movie except for two things........
Snape's Worst Memory should have been more elaborate. They didn't even show Lily Potter! How are they gonna cover up?
The explanation of the prophecy was not well done. My friend who didn't read the book couldn't understand it completely.
Otherwise it is better than the previous four.
At last they are taking a great decision in making a two part movie out of Deathly Hallows................
Apr 09, 08 at 9:41am
you think the exact same thing as my friend. she watches the movie with a pen and paper and finds all the mistakes. im gonna have to tell her about them ones though. its really funny.
Feb 01, 08 at 10:16am
I did like this movie but i was very dissappointed in the way they left alot of things out.
BE FOR WARNED SPOILERS !!
The fact that the left out them clearing out the house and coming across the locket. The whole Fred & George thing they decided to leave after Umbridge was going to kick them out not during the exam. Hagrid showing them all the Testrals, so how did they fly on them at the end? The fight in the department of mysteries was all mixed around and Bellatrix didnt kill Sirius that way they had a fight.
There are alot more but i'll have to read the book again.
Powered by neoforums v1.9.0 (annabelle) Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2013