Thread titleFromLast replied
Now searching...
Neoseeker Forums » » » » Football Manager 2013 » Everyone has one » Post Reply

Note to Guests: For the enjoyment of other visitors, and to help keep this forum tidy and working smoothly, please make sure you search the forum before posting your question.
Name:* Members, please LOGIN before posting
Email: We use this to display your Gravatar

Sign in with

HTML is not allowed
markup is allowed

Help with markup tags

Enabling Buttons in IE7

  ·all smilies here
:) :P ;) :( :| ;( :D :confused: :cool: :# :o ^_^ :colored: :thick:
Community Badges

Join to get access to all the badges!

AS Roma Brisbane Roar Australia MK Dons Elgin City Hibernian FC Barcelona Real Madrid Hellas Verona Lazio Liverpool FC Fluminense Some United Bloke Atalanta Bologna Partick Thistle Palermo Parma Napoli Torino Bromley AFC Bournemouth Arsenal Aston Villa Barnsley Birmingham Blackburn Rovers Blackpool Bolton Wanderers Bradford Brentford Burnley Cardiff City Charlton Athletic Chelsea Chesterfield Crewe Crystal Palace Derby County Everton Exeter Fulham Grimsby Hull City Ipswich Leeds United Leicester City Luton Town Manchester City Manchester United Middlesbrough FC Millwall Newcastle United Norwich Nottingham Forest Peterborough Portsmouth QPR Reading Rotherham United Sheffield United Sheffield Wednesday Southampton Southend United Stevenage Stoke City Swansea Tottenham Tranmere Rovers Watford West Bromwich Albion West Ham Wigan Wolves England FC United of Manchester Olympiakos Milan Fiorentina WC14 Algeria WC14 Argentina WC14 Australia Leighton Baines 3 Leighton Baines Leighton Baines 2 WC14 Belgium WC14 Bosnia and Herzegovina Borussia Dortmund WC14 Brazil Cagliari Catania Aberdeen Celtic Chester WC14 Chile Verona WC14 Ivory Coast WC14 Cameroon WC14 Colombia WC14 Costa Rica WC14 Croatia WC14 Ecuador WC14 England WC14 Spain WC14 France Genoa WC14 Germany WC14 Ghana WC14 Greece Heart of Midlothian WC14 Honduras Casillas Inter WC14 Iran WC14 Italy WC14 Japan Juventus WC14 South Korea Siena WC14 Mexico WC14 Holland WC14 Nigeria Lyon Pescara WC14 Portugal Rangers Real Salt Lake Rugby Town WC14 Russia Sunderland AFC Sampdoria WC14 Switzerland Totti 1 Totti 2 Udinese WC14 Uruguay WC14 USA Van Der Vaart

hideOriginal Post

Dec 07, 12 at 3:21amModiga

Everyone has that one player who the scouts and attributes say isn't as good as the rest of the team but seems to always play really well. With my Cuiaba side, I have a right winger called Heider, who my staff only rate as a 2 star player. Since coming into the side last season due to injury he's forced his way into the first team. Now he's a key player for me and the captain of the team, while still being only rated 2 star. Become part of an interchanging front four that score a tonne of goals and assist each other. Had it last year with my Liverpool team and Ryan Tunnicliffe as well, he seemed to always play well for them, even though he was rated only 2 star.

Anyone else had similar experiences with a player?

Thread Recap (last 10 posts from newest to oldest)

Dec 08, 12 at 7:42pm

Marko Marin in FM12 for me

assistant rates him no higher than 2* (or was it 2.5 - can't remember)
yet he gets shortlisted for WorldPlayerOfTheYear

work that one out

Dec 08, 12 at 7:21pm

For me it was Fabian Delph on last year's for my Liverpool team. Coaches didn't rate him massively but he was one of our most consistent performers and created so many chances it was unbelievable.

Dec 08, 12 at 7:14pm

It's funny because your scouts and ass man can only tell you how good a players CA and PA are, not how well their stat distribution will make them play so you always have to trust your eyes.

For my Luverdense squad I have a right back named Regis that my ass man keeps trying to get me to drop but he's second on my squad in avg rating and assists so I will just keep playing him, thank you very much.

Dec 08, 12 at 6:22pm

I have had a few but none as the good as the ones in here

Dec 08, 12 at 1:07pm

I had Kieran Mcalla at West Brom. I had much better players but I had an injury crisis so promoted him from the reserves and he performed amazingly well and ended up being 1st team for a few seasons

Dec 08, 12 at 3:55am

in the Youth Academy Challenge i had a striker in my Under 18 side at the start who had 3 for finishing but due to an injury crisis i had to play him.

he scored 32 goals in 28 games. and now has 173 goals in 217 games since then.

Dec 08, 12 at 3:35am

quote RVD1000
quote RAT_Dave
Jonny Evans. **1/2, yet had an average rating of 7.9 last season. Where I comically got 85 points and finished 4th. I hate this game.
That's terribly unlucky, I've won titles with fewer points than that.


Dec 08, 12 at 3:17am

quote RAT_Dave
Jonny Evans. **1/2, yet had an average rating of 7.9 last season. Where I comically got 85 points and finished 4th. I hate this game.
That's terribly unlucky, I've won titles with fewer points than that.

Dec 08, 12 at 2:42am

Andrea Poli..

Overall rating of atleast 7.20 every season, atleast two goals and 5 assists every season (peaking at 5 goals and 15 assists) over 5 seasons

and Anderson..

Atleast 10 goals, and 10 assists for 3 season with an average of atleast 7.50 over 3 seasons

Both said to be between 2 and a half stars to 3.

they are also both favourites at the club.

Dec 07, 12 at 3:18pm

I moved from Fulham to Man Utd cos they had a massive budget and this regen, he is rated 1.5* current abilityers was my first signing from Boca Juniors, he was called Hugo Romano and he is actually really good, forcing out a few big players

Powered by neoforums v2.3.0 (Bolieve)
Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2014   |   Forum Rules   |   Forum FAQ   |   Neoseeker Terms of Use   |   Supermods On Duty [ server id: web8 ··· elapsed: 0.1485]
Chat and Lounges
Game Platforms
Mobile Platforms