Thread titleFromLast replied
Now searching...
Neoseeker Forums » » » » Pokémon SoulSilver Version » Red or Ash???????? » Post Reply

Note to Guests: For the enjoyment of other visitors, and to help keep this forum tidy and working smoothly, please make sure you search the forum before posting your question.Hey! Want advice/feedback on your Pokemon team? All Competitive "rate my team" threads belong in the Strategy forum!
Name:* Members, please LOGIN before posting
Email: We use this to display your Gravatar

Sign in with

HTML is not allowed
markup is allowed

Help with markup tags

Enabling Buttons in IE7

  ·all smilies here
:) :P ;) :( :| ;( :D :confused: :cool: :# :o ^_^ :colored: :thick:
Community Badges

Join to get access to all the badges!

Pidgeot Pikachu Surf 1 Pangoro Mareep Trozei Ivysaur Altaria Shiny Altaria Shiny Armaldo Stunfisk Adamant Orb Aguav Berry Armor Fossil Aspear Berry Berry Juice Bicycle Big Pearl Bulk Berry Cheri Berry Cherish Ball Chesto Berry Claw Fossil Cover Fossil Dawn Stone Dive Ball DNA Splicers Dome Fossil Dream Ball Dusk Ball Dusk Stone Enigma Berry Enigma Stone Fast Ball Figy Berry Fire Stone Fresh Water Friend Ball Great Ball Heal Ball Heavy Ball Helix Fossil Iapapa Berry Kelpsy Berry Leaf Stone Lemonade Level Ball Love Ball Lum Berry Lure Ball Luxury Ball Mago Berry Master Ball Max Revive MooMoo Milk Moon Ball Moon Stone Nanab Berry Nest Ball Net Ball Nugget Old Amber Oran Berry Park Ball Pearl Pecha Berry Persim Berry Pinap Berry Plume Fossil PokeDoll PokeToy Pomeg Berry Premier Ball Quick Ball Rainbow Wing Rawst Berry Razz Berry Repeat Ball Revival Herb Revive Root Fossil Safari Ball Shiny Stone Sitrus Berry Skull Fossil Slowpoke Tail Soda Pop Soul Dew Sport Ball Star Piece Stardust Sun Stone Super Rod Thunder Stone Timer Ball Ultra Ball Water Stone Wepear Berry Wiki Berry Biker Bird Keeper 1 Blackbelt Blastoise Blue 1 Blue 2 Brock 1 Bruno 1 Bruno 2 Buena 1 Bulbasaur Lapras Surf 1 Charizard Charmander Charmeleon Chuck Clair 1 Darkrai Golden Dialga Pikachu Surf 2 Quagsire Electrike Elm 1 Espurr Ethan 1 Shiny Umbreon Firebreather 1 Fisherman 2 Fisherman 1 Flareon Furfrou PokeBall Glaceon Griseous Orb GS Ball Lapras Surf 2 Guitarist 1 PO Champion Janine 1 Jolteon Jolteon Kimono Girl B Kimono Girl G Kimono Girl R Koga 1 Kris Lance 1 Lance 2 Leafeon Luxio Floppy Magikarp Medium Mega Ampharos MegaAerodactyl MegaAlakazam MegaBlastoise MegaBlaziken MegaGyarados MegaHoundoom MegaKangaskhan MegaMewtwoX MegaMewtwoY MegaPinsir MegaScizor MegaTyranitar MegaVenusaur Missingno Misty 1 Misty 2 Mother Johto Mother Kanto Monica Morty 1 Mr Fuji Oak 1 Oak 2 Officer 1 Nidorina Nidoqueen Nidorino Nidoking Victreebel Tentacruel Ponyta Slowpoke Shiny Ninetales Axew Volcarona Larvesta Throh Sawk Cottonee Maractus Clefable Vulpix Ninetails Shaymin Sky Forme Ariados Mareep Flygon Shuppet Togekiss Lucario Togetic Eevee Psyduck Slowpoke Marill Magikarp Victini Elekid Mawile Arcanine Makuhita Muk Shedinja Spinda Scraggy Pikachu Raichu Chikorita Pichu Unown Treecko Torchic Mudkip Espeon Lugia Bulbasaur Charmander Squirtle Cyndaquil Turtwig Totodile Chimchar Infernape Mewtwo Mew Natu Flaaffy Snivy Ampharos Tepig Celebi Bellossom Shiny Dratini Dratini Dragonair Dragonite Oshawott Vaporeon Jolteon Flareon Leafeon Glaceon Umbreon Slaking Luxray Pidgey Wobbuffet Wynaut Zapdos Monferno Swampert Feraligatr Corphish Machamp Blaziken Ludicolo Shiny Charizard Moltres Articuno Shadow Lugia Raikou Entei Suicine Ho-Oh Regirock Latias Latios Rayquaza Kyogre Jirachi Deoxys Groudon Uxie Azelf Dialga Mesprit Palkia Heatran Regigigas Cresselia Giratina Phione Manaphy Darkrai Arceus Shaymin Teddiursa Slugma Ursaring Cinccino Genesect Meloetta Aria Forme Keldeo Resolute Form Keldeo Meloetta Pirouette Forme Mienshao Lilligant Haxorus Pansear Pansage Panpour Scraggy Victini Reshiram Audino Zekrom Snivy Oshawott Tepig Whimsicott Sawsbuck Swanna Seaking Starmie Tauros Gloom Vileplume Snorlax Crawdaunt Ambipom Ivysaur Venusaur Charmeleon Charizard Wartortle Blastoise Bayleef Quilava Typhlosion Feraligatr Croconaw Alakazam Kadabra Grovyle Sceptile Combusken Marshtomp Paras Grotle Torterra Prinplup Empoleon Parasect Servine Serperior Pignite Emboar Dewott Samurott Dugtrio Jynx Diglett Shiny Gyarados Absol Hydreigon Cobalion Terrakion Virizion Tornadus Therian Forme Tornadus Thundurus Thundurus Therian Forme Sableye Spiritomb Shiny Ditto Ditto Kingler Jigglypuff Kyurem White Kyurem Zorua Zoroark Deino Mienfoo Cubchoo Landorus Landorus Therian Forme Black Kyurem Butterfree Ekans Arbok Nidoran Female Nidoran Male Zubat Growlithe Abra Bellsprout Tentacool Gastly Haunter Gengar Horsea Goldeen Staryu Mr Mime Gyarados Lapras Poochyena Zigzagoon Linoone Wurmple Shiftry Ralts Kirlia Wingull Gardevoir Mime Jr Masquerain Shroomish Slakoth Feebas Regice Registeel Happiny Shiny Sneasel Magnemite Magneton Litwick Lampent Chandelure Quilava Breloom Spiky Eared Pichu Stunfisk Rattata Sneasel Blissey Heracross Weavile Smeargle Sawsbuck Autumn Sawsbuck Winter Sawsbuck Summer Sawsbuck Spring Shiny Dratini Magcargo Lotad Politoed Spoink Darumaka Bouffalant Zweilous Eelektross Staraptor Omanyte Azumarill Burmy Plant Cloak Porygon 2 Burmy Trash Cloak Porygon 2 Surskit Larvitar Spheal Luvdisc Jumpluff Whiscash Castform Chimecho Gorebyss Nurse Joy 1 Picnicker 1 Piplup Unfezant Female Unfezant Male Pokefan FanClub Chairman Porygon Psy Duck Rare Candy RBY Surf Red 2 Red 1 Riolu Rocket Grunt F Rocket Grunt M Sage Sailor Shiny Celebi Shiny Espeon Shiny Latias Shiny Latios Shiny Rapidash Shiny Milotic Shiny Milotic Shiny Charizard Silver 1 Sliggoo CabbageSpeehs Squirtle Sylveon Sylveon Team Aqua Team Magma Togekiss Wobbuffet Trozei Tuscany 1 VarietyBlack Venusaur Wartortle WiFi Trophy Youngster 1

hideOriginal Post

May 29, 10 at 8:26pmlucario333

Ok i hope its not just me thinking red is r the reasons lives rite next to "red"
2.he lives in pallet town
3.has the same pokemon as ash

i know what ur thinking.....Red came b4 ash rite?
ur half rite
when they made the anime would u name the main char red? instead they named him ash

im not asking for a fight this is just my opinion, and urs is well come too.

so plz if u think red is red give me some reasons:D

Thread Recap (last 10 posts from newest to oldest)

Mar 14, 14 at 8:02am
Theory Fan

I think that ash and red are two seperate people but ash came FIRST. While not a realible source but holding evedince look at the animr. In a hoenn region episode ash andvthe crewvare having a pinic with misty. Misty recieves a call in which we find out she has become the CERUALEN GYM LEADER! Seem famialer? So we know this is when misty is gym leader but what about brock? While I have no evedince it is reasonable to infer that he became a gym leader during thebevents of unova.

Dec 01, 13 at 11:24pm

Ok so Red is NOT Ash ok?! My pikachu knows volt tackle does that make me Ash? God I hope not Ash is a loser.

Oct 22, 13 at 4:53pm
I know, right?

Ok this is simple.. Ash Ketchum is to pokemon what Alice is to resident evil. They dont exist! in the original versions of each franchise. Ash doesn't appear in the manga nor games.. same with alice and RE games... they are just a "main" character for the movie and anime ALONE and kinda makes the franchises have a principal character figure since both pokemon and RE have changing main character roles.

Sep 27, 13 at 7:30am

Ash is based off of Red, like most people are saying. They are two different characters.

Now with that said, how about this: Would the writers ever put the two in the same game or anime episode? Would that cause too much confusion to the average fan?

Sep 07, 13 at 6:28am

Ok I dunno how old this post is but after everything I've read no one has said the correct information. And the guy who said you can choose ash as a name in red/blue, you are incorrect. Pokemon yellow is the only game you can have the pre set name of ash.

Ok so for who you are in pokemon yellow: the correct answer is neither red nor ash. You play a mix of both of their stories but not their complete story. Red never gets a charmander or squirtle (ill explain that in a minute) and ash never takes down team rocket or becomes champion. With that said pokemon yellow was made so the player could feel as if they were playing as ash, while using the red model.

Ok so this is reds story taken from the manga. His first pokemon is a poliwag. His first starter is a bulbasaur. He catches a pikachu in pewter city. Here are the reasons why he has an espeon, blastoise, and charizard at mt. Silver when you face him in g/s/c. In the manga he rescues an eevee that has the ability to evolve into jolteon, flareon, and vaporeon and change back into eevee. It has this ability because team rocket altered it. Once it evolves into espeon it looses that ability. Thus the reason why he has an espeon at mt. Silver. As for the charizard he has, it is not his. He gets blues charizard from a trade. Blue lends him his charizard so he can fly to mt. Silver to recover. He trades green her blastoise and that is why he has those 2 pokemon. With that being said the red you face in s/g/c isn't completely based off the manga as he does not have his pikachu at that point in time. Though overall it is based off his pokemon he had at that moment at mt. Silver.

To set the record straight red is originally what satoshi wanted the main character of pokemon to be, while ash was created for the anime to appeal more to children.

Jun 24, 13 at 3:47pm

Red since he's Pokémon Trainer in Brawl.

Not sure why he bred his Blastoise and Venusaur for Brawl though.

Jun 03, 13 at 6:16pm

i simply think red or ash is just both the same person just Nintendo decided to keep a name besides the other just like charizards wings r blue in the game but green ish in the anime? It's just an example

May 24, 13 at 2:45pm

Red and Ash are actually the same the real difference is you cant see reds eye but u can se ash's and all of red Pokémon's are fully evolved and ash's aren't.

May 07, 13 at 7:04am
Jeremy Lin

Red is not ash he doesn't even look like him . Yes he have a pikachu like ash but does that make him ash? actually have an aerodactyll a poliwharth snorlax gyrados and a venusaur no he do not have a charizard and a blastiose he borrowed them from blue and green.ash is a useless pokemon trainer that can't even defeat a two person cell from team rocket ps how red got an Lapras ? I am still finding out

May 07, 13 at 7:04am
Jeremy Lin

Red is not ash he doesn't even look like him . Yes he have a pikachu like ash but does that make him ash? actually have an aerodactyll a poliwharth snorlax gyrados and a venusaur no he do not have a charizard and a blastiose he borrowed them from blue and green.ash is a useless pokemon trainer that can't even defeat a two person cell from team rocket ps how red got an Lapras ? I am still finding out

Powered by neoforums v2.3.0 (Bolieve)
Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2014   |   Forum Rules   |   Forum FAQ   |   Neoseeker Terms of Use   |   Supermods On Duty [ server id: web2 ··· elapsed: 0.4802]
Chat and Lounges
Game Platforms
Mobile Platforms