What a horrible idea for a TV show, and an even worse idea for a game. Well, at least the game will be an accurate representation of the show - you don't need to be able to sing, success is purely based on how well you can push buttons.

Wow. That's really stupid. They shouldv'e done what Karaoke (sp) Revolution did and give you a headset to sing with instead of button mashing. >_<

I happen to like American Idol, thank you very much. As a matter of fact, I'm wearing the shirt right now. And I am very much looking foward to getting the game and no I'm sure it's not just about "mashing buttons". So get a life. Clay rules!

not only that, it is a rol playinmg game

I have nothing against Clay Aiken--he's a good singer. BUT...I'm not a big fan of the show, nor am I supporting the game itself. I mean--what do you DO in this game anyway?

allieg8tor, you foolish mortal, i saw what Egm gave american idol for a rating, and from what i saw, i have seen better atari games than that, and most atari games suck bad.

I also saw the rating. I don't buy Atari games--they're all so...bad. ..;

does this game even exist i mean what is the point of creating an american idol game if you can see it on tv i mean what do you do in that game sing or something

i luv teh merican idles. teh r s0 c00l. clay is wiked! so iz black! i play teh game at skewl. and after. iots wicjked! do u ever play amercas idol? it is wiked! i feel like im a americas idle when i play americans idol. it is wiked! i pretend to date the grrl. sheez hot! i look teh cover of americos idel at nite, i l00k at teh grrl hooze pretty. is hard tho, the game. why thay make teh game s0 hrd? THAT SUXKS!

quick everybody, point and laugh at Walmartian's broken english and bad taste of video games! Muhahahahahahahahaha!

oh oh can i join 2?

muhahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

WTF?
Why is this game in the RPG section?

this is gay. why do they make the game if the show sucks and why did they put it in the rpg section???i don't even know why they made a forum for this.

is this an American Idol rpg? if so can I be Clay Aiken?

I wanna be simon!!

And i would so beat the poop out of Paula.

And the awsome ability to make people cry!

HAHA!