Pokemon B2/W2 Sprite Contest [Grass/Fire/Water Fusion - June 14th] - Page 4

I DEMAND JUDGING AND REASONS.

Your judge rules with an iron fist!

But no seriously guys, we've literally had arguments in this contest get so bad that 3 whole pages were filled with nothing but flaming in the span of an hour. It got so bad that a mod had to come and lock the thread for a week. While we may fun and games now, there was period of time where every little thing got blown way out of proportion. So it's my goal to make sure nothing like that happens again.

Also, seems like we got no takers on the banner contest. Sigh... guess I'll just update it at some point.

It's a Stantler Evo.

And with that the banner contest comes to a close. Unfortunately, our only entry didn't read the size requirements, so it's disqualified. I'll probably just make a new one at some point.

Hooray, not too late to enter!


Here's an Aerodactyl prevo that I made a while back. C+C appreciated as usual!

I find it more scary when the teachers don't give you homework and put faith in "your great study routine".
But I guess that's just me, considering I don't have one (and this exam makes up a big part of my grade).

Anyways, here's my entry:



I shaded it a bit strangely, I know that for sure. C+C appreciated, although no one seem to give any these days...
I'd give a description, but I need to study, so there's the entry, and I'll be gone now.

Judging
Eh, only two entries this time. But the show must go on.

quote Wombat

[C] Unfortunately your Aerodactyl prevo looks more like a miniature Aerodactyl than a new Pokemon. Though I suppose a smaller version of its evolution is a legitimate pre-evolution, it doesn't hurt to show off a little creativity in these contests. For the sprite itself, there's a lot of errors here that I know you've avoided in the past. There's a complete lack of black outline on everything scratched, and the outline near the end of the tail is broken. The shading on the belly is too flat, and the overall shape of the mouth and chin is awkward.

quote DarkFireEternal

[B-] On the other hand, you have many of the opposite problems as Wombat. I can't tell if this is supposed to be an evolution or pre-evolution of Absol. In fact, I really wouldn't have known it was related to Absol if the prompt didn't specify which Pokemon to use. It's missing a lot of the key Absol features, like the head scythe and blade-like tail. Design complaints aside, the sprite has too much black outline, especially on the legs. Shading in general could use some work, but it's most noticeable on the mane.

Winner:
1st: DarkFireEternal
2nd: Wombat

New Theme: I'm going to give you guys another shading exercise. Revamp a sprite from G/S/C. Remember, you'll need to redo the shading, not just recolor it!
Due Date: November 20th
Judge: 4EverSeaMusic

It's Whitney.