Players You Think Will Be (Noticeably) Overrated - Page 3

Yeah I'd agree with Mycon, that's about right. He's still capable of changing games and does have some good traits, 80 is a fair rating. I think that Raul Meireles will probably he overrated, he's a good player but I can imagine he'll get a 82/83 rating when he's more around 80/81.

Jack Wilshere as he's officially on the UK cover for FIFA 12.

quote shaunybaby

RVP is the most over rated striker I've ever seen. He best tally for a season is what? 18? that's shite for a player that is sitting in front of Fabergas, Nasri, Rosiscy(sp?), and Arsharvin. Any other "World class" player would crack 20 a season.

I always laugh when i see Robben, just the way he runs.

So you wouldn't have a striker that managed 18 goals in a season where he was constantly injured? 18 goals in 25 games in a fantastic record. On his day he is one of the best strikers around.

As for overrated players, i say: Jordan Henderson, Edin Dzeko, Kaka and James Milner.

The Rock 13 he will be because of City's new deal with EA. All of the City squad are most likely to be drastically overrated.

anelka isn't that good in my opinion although im not a chelsea fan so you can see why

quote Jamesy

quote shaunybaby

RVP is the most over rated striker I've ever seen. He best tally for a season is what? 18? that's shite for a player that is sitting in front of Fabergas, Nasri, Rosiscy(sp?), and Arsharvin. Any other "World class" player would crack 20 a season.

I always laugh when i see Robben, just the way he runs.

So you wouldn't have a striker that managed 18 goals in a season where he was constantly injured? 18 goals in 25 games in a fantastic record. On his day he is one of the best strikers around.

And the years before that? Admittedly he has shown he's a good player with a lot of potential, but a player that hasn't played a full season in n nearly five years should not be rated as much as he is. He definitely would not be in one of my teams.

quote Eh Croissant

What is all this shit about Neymar? The guy is the epitomy of the soft modern day pansy footballer. He, like Robinho and Suarez just embarrased me at the Copa America. Talented they may be, but boy do they collapse in a heap every five seconds. So much so when they do beat a man the commentator calls it world class.

Neymar will never be fit to lick the boots of Messi, Forlan or even Pato.

And his haircut is ridiculous.

He gets a lot of backlash from the media when he does that, he seems to be improving and goes on for several games without that but then he goes and falls easily at another one. A current plague of the Brazilian league is how players want to highlight a foul they've suffered and make a scene that wasn't necessary and in many cases makes the referee doubt the foul.

Outside the falling over issue with Neymar, the kid has got a lot of talent that is extremely rare especially for his age. All he needs to do is get a few embarrassing plays against Barcelona in December. If you want to compare him with Messi, Neymar's faster, has superior dribbling (and includes awesome tricks into his feints, Messi has no feints/trick skills... though he doesn't need it, like Zico in the 70s/80s), shoots well with both legs and from outside the box. Messi is above him as he just has more experience, still has better passing, and plays a little bit more direct.

The haircut is stupid and stupid young players in Brazil are copying him from haircut to socks.