Minecraft Wiki - Page 7

[quote=Exonerate|message:31056804]
That's a ridiculous claim to make. My complaint is about the creation of this NeoWiki, what action could I possibly take when it's already been created? I'm not exactly going to take it down myself am I?

I realise it's already been made and nothing is going to change that but it doesn't mean I'm not allowed to complain about it. That's such a weak stance to have. People complain about things that are happening in their countries all the time but it's not like they can do anything about it. Complaining isn't pointless either because it sparks responses in other people, people may now contribute more to the NeoWiki because of what other people have said arguing against my points, or in spite of my points. On the flip side, people may have now decided not to contribute it because of my points.

The original idea of this thread wasn't to discuss what could be put on it anyway, but to promote the editing of it, which I disagreed with. Therefore I'm entitled to post here.
[/quote]If you don't want to edit don't and can I just say this argument is pointless as everyone has their opinions.

Yeah, stub is only really used if it's a few lines or so.

The wiki is really behind. And before you say for me to do it. I couldn't write a wiki for my life.

Can I just say i agree with Benedict ?

Why Remake somehting that already exists?

You wouldnt remake wikipedia from scratch, you just add more to it. So why remake a Minecrfat wiki, or a CoD wiki, Or any wiki even?

quote Chaosfire

Yeah, I'm beginning to realize that, there are already 2 major minecraft wiki's. The official at Wikipedia.com, then the Minecraftwiki. Plus, no doubt large amounts of minor ones.

Wikipedia is about everything. They cover minor areas of everything.
This wiki is *bleep*ing pointless. If it was for example, a tutorial wiki, I haven't seen one of them recently, it may be a lot more useful.
Same with most other wikis such as pokemon, trying to compete with bulbapedia. It is funny.

quote 99pool

I'm confused on why people are arguing about the minecraft neowiki. If people have fun editing, why can't you just let them.

Fun editing? lol what

quote 99pool

quote Benedict

quote 99pool

I'm confused on why people are arguing about the minecraft neowiki. If people have fun editing, why can't you just let them.

Fun editing? lol what

Well if people didn't have fun, they wouldn't do it.

Yes they would. If your friend asked you a favor, although you may not like it you would help. Same situation here, but useless.

Im actually helping here, im only doing a bit here and ther but i added some basics to the page for map.