PES vs. FIFA - Page 6

quote Highbury Highs

PES graphics are insanely good.

No they're not.

In game they're dreadful, jagged edges, crooked and far from "insanely good".

Graphics in replays are very good. That's compromised by there being a slight delay between gameplay and replays, which is very annoying. Before the game too they're ok. But Messi/Ibrahimovic's faces look like they've been assaulted by a hive of bees. Dreadful models. Which is strange considering Messi is meant to be the star.

And I found the passing horrifically slow. Any time I tried to inject some speed the players couldn't handle it, and took an age to do as I said.

quote Mycon

Don't know how you can say the passing is slow, I think it's much slicker than in FIFA. Through balls are quality, if a little too good but it means you can score from some fantastic passing moves. In fact passing is one of my favourite things about the game.

Only had one problem with keepers so far and it wasn't with the European teams so I just presumed it was a shite keeper.

Co-sign the top paragraph. PES's passing this year is too much

I had my first keeper mistake today as well Had to come sometime

quote Cashis

The passing is not slow at all, the turning is fine imo, there's nothing wrong with the control, I've had some lovely traps and take-downs and there's nothing wrong with the dribbling either.

One thing I think that could do with improvement is the sprinting, defenders catch up with you too easily at times.

With the passing it's like everytime you receive the ball it gets stuck under your feet which is irritating. For me on FIFA it just seems more fluid and seems to flow a lot better than on PES.

And the turning is awful bar with players like Messi and Ribery. I mean Olic may not be as good at dribbling but it doesn't mean he turns on the ball like a tank.

Played some more today. Its not so much keeper errors but it seems that shots they could save they Dont. Also Dani Alves got out paced by Klose several times during a game which is completely unrealistic. Seems like there is no variation between pace with the players.

quote Chelskiman

I still haven't had a keeper error yet, so I'm pleased about that.

Why? Keepers always make mistakes

There should be more, in both games.

quote DjedwardSmith

quote Highbury Highs

PES graphics are insanely good.

No they're not.

In game they're dreadful, jagged edges, crooked and far from "insanely good".

Graphics in replays are very good. That's compromised by there being a slight delay between gameplay and replays, which is very annoying. Before the game too they're ok. But Messi/Ibrahimovic's faces look like they've been assaulted by a hive of bees. Dreadful models. Which is strange considering Messi is meant to be the star.

And I found the passing horrifically slow. Any time I tried to inject some speed the players couldn't handle it, and took an age to do as I said.

Have to disagree with both points there. The graphics are far from dreadful, I think that the player models are very good and are better than FIFA, Fifa don't seem to go into as much as detail as they probably should for a lot of the player models. I've seen some of the most realistic player models in any football game ever on the newer PES's for all it's criticisms I really don't think you can say they're dreadful.

I've already said how I don't think the passing is slow but each to their own.

I'm a neutral but post more in the pes forums.