Topic: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
|
|
| Showing posts by Relmutsie AN in this thread (30 posts by Relmutsie AN out of 460 total posts in the thread) About this feature: Posts by unique authors made between the messages by Relmutsie AN are shown as collapsed so you can have some idea of the members participating in the conversation around them. If the number of posts between Relmutsie AN's posts are too high they will be hidden.
|
Sakura | |
Matt Player Of AC | |
| ... 3 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Zeta | |
Gotenks | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
Log in to remove this sponsored message
I think the Johto Region Game needs a lot of re-consideration. For starters, it is not very organised. At all. The owner clearly has no experience and everything seems to be rushed and working in his favour. The HoH event was cancelled. The questions are barely understandable and whilst trying to explain the questions, he practically gives answers away or doesn't help at all. You've had one drop out, and a shit load of others being disqualified because they "didn't get their entries in on time".
I think it either needs to be restarted with a new host or just re-considered entirely.
Alas, that's just my opinion...thoughts?
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
| Advertisement Neoseeker | Sponsored message |
|
| Log in or register to remove this sponsored message |
Sakura | |
Zeta | |
| ... 8 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Gotenks | |
Swag | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
I think he means it's annoying for the people who have to say the same thing 3-4 times a week. And tbh, it is getting boring.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
ProudLoz | |
Gotenks | |
Mishtram | |
Dark Arcanine | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
By the power of Grayskull, please tell me that did not happen.
Why is it that a trainer card contest is allowed, yet a simple idea like putting a date in the header gets everybody in uproar? The header suggestion is a VERY simple suggestion, and it can practically serve as a countdown, who cares who ignores it? That's a small suggestion. It's worth considering. It's not worth both sides putting 5 tampons up because somebody says no.
As for the trainer card contest...why? Seriously. Another way to tell people how inferior they are and how the tiniest details let the whole card down in the eyes of the judge, who has established that they are better than everyone else? Oh yeah. That's a great addition to the forum. Aren't there enough of those already?
brb, putting in tampon
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
ProudLoz | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
...So the trainer card contest is a method of migration...
...Right.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
ProudLoz | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
Whatever you say ZL. 
However, there's one thing I don't get. You make it sound as though putting the release date in the header is going to drive people away. True, if people come here just to ask when it's released and just see it in the header, they aren't going to post. But I'm going to assume that when you say the forum needs activity, you mean regular activity; 5 threads per week about the same thing, isn't activity. I just don't understand why it's such a bad thing.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Stormy | |
Sakura | |
| ... 5 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Dark Arcanine | |
Zeta | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
No clans. For god's sake, no clans. 
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Origin | |
Matt Player Of AC | |
| ... 5 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Shadowz | |
Morrigan | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
So what does that have to do with this forum anyway (beside the fact it's a horrible idea)?
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Morrigan | |
Shadow Bolt | |
| ... 4 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Icekickseverything | |
MegaBassMan | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
Great idea guy! To bring more people to the forum, create a massive spam fest!

The general clan forum idea would not work. You are honestly just better off going to a Pokemon social forum. Oh, wait, we have one. Nobody uses it though.
Better yet, just host your own...I've always been in favour of running your own forum for clans (hell I did it before...but that's a different story) since it keeps all the little children away who're desperate to join every clan they possibly can.
Obviously people would be against this idea, but it's always been my take on the whole thing. Clans are, in essence, social forums, and they really shouldn't be on a site like Neoseeker. We have General Pokemon for that.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Sakura | |
Dragoon | |
| ... 5 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Slash | |
Silver Soul | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
So Heart Gold isn't enough? And anyway, what's wrong with the All Pokemon forums link? 
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Silver Soul | |
Gotenks | |
| ... 9 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Croka | |
Kanto | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
It's funnier how you're trying to bring up a dead subject. Clans aren't happening.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Sakura | |
Impact | |
| ... 5 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Gotenks | |
Dragoon | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
The game isn't even released in America yet...
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Dragoon | |
Tf916 | |
Dark Arcanine | |
Old Man Zangetsu | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
quote Old Man Zangetsu
Well I think we can do a clans sub-foru
No for the millions of reasons stated. Move on already.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Old Man Zangetsu | |
Dragoon | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
Not according to Mishtram.
The idea has been shot down more than enough times in the past. The decision not to create a clan sub-forum for Platinum was final, and has been shot down continuously. Honestly, if you absolutely NEED a clan set up, then use the disasters of forums that have already been set up for this kind of purpose.
You're talking about promoting a mod who will dedicate every single minute of his/her free time cleaning up after the crap that 90% of the population will imminently create.
Just no. No more clans.
EDIT: Oh, TWO mods? Yep, that'll make all the difference.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Old Man Zangetsu | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
You're using SSBB as the only example. You're forgetting that it's probably the only successful clan forum there is. You take a look at Diamond, Pearl and ACWW.
At the end of the day, it's not up to you - it IS up to the administration. So yeah, I'm afraid that means the supers are 100% right.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Dark Arcanine | |
Old Man Zangetsu | |
| ... 5 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Avalith | |
Origin | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
OMZ, before trying to pin everything on the moderators, think about the members for a change. The moderators can clean up all they want. What matters is if the community will do it all again.
The moderators don't cause the mess, and they're not responsible for everything. You keep bringing them into the scenario as if you know that a ton of shit is going to happen. If that's the case, why in the hell do you support the idea in the first place? Members are responsible for what shit goes down in the forums, and not moderators. Sure, you can bring up the SSBB example all you want, but this is not SSBB Crews. This is Pokémon clans. They don't work. They've never worked. You've acknowledged that. And now you just want to bring in more moderators clear up that imminent shit hole.
Avalith is the section moderator, and he knows what's best for the forum. You're questioning him as if he doesn't have any say in the forum while you do.
Your 2 or 3 good clans are nothing compared to the 100s of other shitty clans that will be imminently created.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Old Man Zangetsu | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
quoteWhat? I'm saying the mods in the past of the forum havent done their fullest. I dont think I hinted that the mods in general will always be the cause. Otherwise, why would I point out the success of the mods at SSBB? You've said that the forums have failed because of bad moderating, when in reality that's not the case at all. It's failed because of all the shit that members did post and continue to post. I will defend Quierta in this one situation; she has tried the best she could.
Please, just for one minute, remember that we're not talking about SSBB. We are talking about Pokémon.quoteIf a moderator lacks in his or her duty, and allows a member to spam, is it honestly the members fault? They wouldnt know any better. If they do something and arent stopped, they wont think its a wrong thing to do. Then that's their own fault for not knowing the rules and deciding not to read them. Duh.quoteWait what? We've had more than 1 clans forum? Diamond and Pearl are the only pokemon Clans I know of. 1 failed attempt doesnt mean it will ALWAYS fail. Giving clans one more attempt will prove weather or not they will always be a failure or not. They failed once. Why give them another chance knowing that there's a high possibility that it'll fail again?quoteNo, I havent. I have acknowledge that the Diamonds forum is a nightmare, but not clans in general. Again, we're not talking about clans in general. We're talking about Pokémon clans. If we were to talk about migrating clans from SSBB and Animal Crossing, it would PROBABLY work. But this is Pokémon.
I'm not trying to tell you that you can't speak your opinion.
Seriously though, to assume that people don't know what they're talking about because they haven't been in clan...that's because nobody wants to be in a clan anyway, because they take one look at it and jump to the conclusion that it's a shit hole. The state of the forum scares new people away. Definitely scared me away.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Old Man Zangetsu | |
Dragoon | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
The only option I've seen you give is to promote more moderators. I will quote myself on this one. Moderators aren't responsible for everything that happens, and shouldn't be made responsible for a member's lack of self control.
This is my last input on the matter since I'm going round in circles...
EDIT: OH RIGHT, we all need babysitters always telling people what to do because people have no self control or maturity whatsoever. Obviously. Can't believe I missed that.
I'll just leave this here...
quote Avalith in Platinum
Now, please, let's drop the whole thing. Having the same debate in two forums is pointless when the answer is never going to change. There will be no clans for Platinum, Heart Gold, or Soul Silver.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Old Man Zangetsu | |
ProudLoz | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
He knows more about moderating than you do, I think you'll find.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Dragoon | |
Old Man Zangetsu | |
| ... 5 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Dark Arcanine | |
Zeta | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
It's pointless to put a date in the header when there's literally 2 weeks until it's released.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Zeta | |
Dragoon | |
Symphonic Abyss | |
Icekickseverything | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
The game's released this week guys. I'm sure everything you asked for will be sorted.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Symphonic Abyss | |
Dragoon | |
Icekickseverything | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
Just relax. It'll happen when it happens. No need to rush anything. The supers know exactly what they're doing.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Gotenks | |
Symphonic Abyss | |
| ... 3 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Old Man Zangetsu | |
Avalith | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
Just a side note; if a super replies to you, you're probably better off leaving the announcements to them, rather than taking it upon yourself to show an admin-type message (I believe), which is against the rules.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Fluroclad | |
Dragoon | |
| ... 8 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Old Man Zangetsu | |
Gefloung | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
quote Zeta
Not to mention it is a highly outdated concept now with the search feature.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^ All that needs to be said.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Fluroclad | |
Gefloung | |
| ... 3 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Soda | |
Icekickseverything | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
Some people don't pay attention to the sub forums. You think they'll see it stickied at the top of the forum?
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Icekickseverything | |
Cobalt | |
| ... 4 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Avalith | |
Dragoon | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
One important question first needs to be asked.
Why?
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Icekickseverything | |
Fluroclad | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
quote Icekickseverything
Lol, easy access. Instead of going back to the main SS forum to get from trading to battles (and vice versa) you just click the link.
It saves one click. AMAZING.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Icekickseverything | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
If someone has managed to make their way to the trading forum, then also going to the battling forum will take nothing more than a few seconds. You're putting forth an idea that looks revolutionary on wood but in reality there are countless other methods of getting there you don't seem to have taken into account, including favourite forums, my.neoforum, the back button, multiple tabs, and the like.
I think that's all the recent suggestions are; demands to make something simple even simpler. Just pointless suggestions inspired by man's pitiful laziness. They make me rest my face in my hands, thinking "of all the suggestions, you thought of that?". Honest opinion.
The header/footer contest is still going on, if you haven't noticed, so maybe once that's done the links you so require will be put up.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Icekickseverything | |
Symphonic Abyss | |
| ... 6 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Gefloung | |
Superstar | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
I was thinking maybe a Pokéwalker sub forum shared between HG/SS. Would make sense.
So, what can I say about Gefloung? He's a...uh...good modera...um...well, he's a nice guy, and uh...well...um...he closes threads for a perfectly valid rea...um...uh...hm...he has good communication with the communi...hm...uh...
Ok, I got nothing.
Well, he is really good at stopping children on the playground fighting. And he does care a lot about what his community thinks of him. He's really appreciative of where he is. OH, and he definitely knows when things have to stop.
I love him so much. 
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Origin | |
Dragoon | |
| ... 3 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Gefloung | |
Gary M | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
quote Gefloung
No. But you have to realize that I have other things to do. I still don't quite see how that makes up for ignoring flaming...you obviously took the time to put them back into view.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Dragoon | |
Gefloung | |
| ... 5 additional posts not shown due to thread length. |
Gary M | |
Poke_Master | |
Relmutsie AN
SHIKAKA!!!NeoXtreme
total posts: 8011 since: Jul 2005
|
re: Requests, Feedback, and Suggestions
|
I still think there should be a subforum for the Pokéwalker.
-------------------
|
|
quote
quick quote
edit
quick edit
del posts in thread report
|
Reenee | |
Dragoon | |
InDiGo | |
Symphonic Abyss | |
Zeta | |
| [All dates in (PST) time] | Threads List « Next Newest Next Oldest » |