general Forum Feedback - Page 24

Geohulk, that was the main objective of the new rules, so mission accomplished. I really wanted to make sure members knew what you're allowed to do here, and less about what they weren't allowed to do. So I removed a lot of Solitaire's old rules, and made the ones left behind more specific. Then I just added bits that detailed what you can do that makes the anime forum good. If you have anything you think I forgot to say, or something that you think needs clarification, it's still subject to changes. Is the part about Illegal Anime and Manga clear enough?

Ah yeah. The previous rules said that there would be no hentai discussion here. Like, at all. Animalover and I still need to discuss this I think, but yesterday I think we felt like it was time to give that another go. As in, I think we can trust people to have mature discussion about it. No okays yet, but we'll see. Besides I'm not really sure anyone actually wants a thread for it anymore. Vermillion used to post in it a lot I remember. I'm also not sure I want to read through every post made in a thread about hentai. XD

Obviously, and I should really add this even though it probably goes without saying: you can't post explicit images. That definition is really hard to draw the line on though. Honestly what would be considered "ecchi" is normally fine here. That's a good point though and I'll definitely throw that in somewhere.

I could dig the FMA tournament. It seems like it would be a fun debate.

The other one just seems to be a popularity contest to me.

I don't mind a tournament idea. This sounds like our own miniature ISML to me. Haha. I approve. It would probably end up being a popularity contest in either case. I mean, in the end lolopinions right? So how does the debate work? Who judges? Moderators?

Briefly read some of this (Yes I lurk this forum like a boss) And In the Dragonball forum, we did something else somewhat similar.

http://www.neoseeker.com/forums/88/t1612106-dragonball-forum-debate-tournament-character-edition/#0

It wasnt about who would win in a fight, because of obvious reasons, but who's character was better. So this is a possible template to use or draw ideas from.

I think that'll be great idea - Especially in like a year or two's time when you might have people wondering which series they missed out on that they haaave to go back and watch, and which ones to avoid. Plus reviews are just generally fun to write.

I keep forgetting to check this thread. I still like the idea of a mini-ISML-esque tournament.

We're starting this early?