Moderator's Corner - Page 13

Debate thread. That went off nicely, but with a good majority of regulars, mind you.


And no simple debates like the

More annoying: vespoid/bullfango.
The "Who would win in a fight? Los v Tiggy?" was a good one.
Hell, we could have a MH version of SPIKE tv's "Deadliest Warrior" here.

Machi, do you know the Game where each person starts off with a certain amount of points, and the each person can post once a day with the info on what person they want to take the points away from?

I thnk I saw it in the old MHF2 thread, is it worth bringing up in this thread?

quote Sah_Kuh_Suckers

Hell, we could have a MH version of SPIKE tv's "Deadliest Warrior" here.

I want to bring this up again. It would be like the debate thread, except you'd argue exclusively who would win? And you'd have someone write up the simulated fight+victor.

examples:

5-man Town Guardian Squad versus 5-man Guild Knight Shadow assassination squad.
Lao versus Gao

quote Xeros_the_Slayer

Human vs Human in a Monster Hunter setting would be purely out of speculation with absolutely no fact backing it.

That's half the fun.


Guardians would use mostly melee weapons, and Shadows would use mostly ranged.
Boom. Debate.

EDIT:

I even got that part planned. For example: Guild Guard versus Guild Shadow.

Guard weapons:
Greatsword
Hammer
Lance
Bow
and the Rapier that is part of the Guild Guard tasset's design

Shadow weapons:
Light Bowgun
Heavy Bowgun
Sword and Shield
Crag shot & Clust shot combination
and the pistol that's part of the Guild Shadow tasset's design.

Crag and Clust shots would be the main way for the Shadows to break the Guards Shields. Crag first, hit them at their feet with a clust when they're stumbling back from the impact. It would be indicative of the under-handed, "gang-up style" since you need two people to operate a crag-clust combo.


And I see Heavy Bowguns as like a sniper rifle. Who needs "light stealth" when you're a 500ft away from battle, and inside a shaded area? I arranged the two to fighting styles. Bows you get out, fire, and keep moving. A very direct, un-sneaky way to fight. But the Heavy bowgun you stay put, and move only when you have to. Bows are similar to LBGs, but LBGs have that silencer aspect which makes them sneakier.

quote Xeros_the_Slayer

These are people that can brush off getting trampled by 5 tons of fangs and claws.

Of course, some realism has to be implemented to move things along. For example, Greatsword: One hit-kill. Hammer: One hit kill, with some attacks. But I'd like to see a Guard fight with a round the size of his face sticking out of his armor.

Anyways, these are points that the debaters should be making.
Basically, you would be assigned a team, and you debate over which side would win. It would be to a team's advantage to cover all of their weapons, (Or monster abilities) and rebut all of their opponent's points but it's largely free-style.

Hello. I did not want to start a new thread about this and was hoping I could ask this here in the Moderator thread.

I'm looking for a thread that I saw posted on here a few months ago. The thread was about different Armor combinations. I had saved a few sets to a word document but did not save a link to the page itself. ><

I really would appreciate a link to the page. Want to get a good setup for Hammer :]

Thanks for your time.

@Paradox: I thank you for your reply to my question, but unfortunately that is not the same thread. But I do thank you for showing me that thread. If I am not able to find the thread I was looking for I will just use the one you posted instead.

Perhaps if you see the format from the original you might recognize it.

what I copied into a word file:

Dual Swords:(mhds)

Chaoshroom
Kirin Jacket X
Kirin Longarms X
Kirin Hoop X
Kirin Leg Guards X
Gems: 5x Grinder Jewel, 1x Divine Protection Jewel, 2x Element Jewel
Skills: Runner, Divine Protection, Element Atk Up, Abnormal Sts Atk Up, Skarpening Skill Inc
Def: 557; Fire:2 Wtr:10 Thdr:18 Ice:2 Drg:-2
*Note: Must have a 1 socket weapon

Kaiser Crown X
Kaiser Mail X
Ceanataur Breaces U
Ceanataur Tasset Z
Ceanataur Greaves Z
Gems: 5x Grinder Jewel, 2x Artisan Jewel, 1x Master Jewel
Skills: Sharp Sword, Sharpening Skill Inc, Sharpness +1, Reckless Abandon +1
Def: 604; Fire:15 Wtr:2 Thdr:-3 Ice:-1 Drg:-4


Kirin Horn X
Naruga Mail X
Shinobi Kote (Heaven)
Obituary Anca X
Naruga Greaves X
Gems: 1x Dodge Jewel, 2x Artisan Jewel, 2x Master Jewel, 1x Element Jewel+
Skills: Evade +2, Element Attack Up, Sharpness +1
Def: 545; Fire:-3 Wtr:-3 Thdr:5 Ice:-3 Drg:3
*Note: Can substitute Sharpness+1 for ANY 8 slot skill you see fit (has two 3 slot pieces)

Sword Saint Piercing
Kushala Cista X
Ceanataur Braces U
Ceanataur Tasset Z
Ceanataur Greaves Z
Gems: 5x Grinder Jewel, 1x Master Jewel, 2x Artisan Jewel
Skills: ESP, Sharpness +1, Sharp Sword, Sharpen Skill Inc.
Def: 538; Fire:5 Wtr:6 Thdr:-5 Ice:3 Drg:-3
*1 socket weapon
$for shudmanul$

Longsword:(mhls)

Golden Hair Tie Shin
Kaiser Mail X
Kaiser Vambraces X
Golden Obi Shin
Golden Hakama Shin
Gems: 1x Celebrity Jewel, 4x Artisan Jewel, 2x Short Charge Jewel, 2x Expert Jewel
Skills: RA+2, Sharpness +1, Focus
Def: 606; Fire:19 Wtr:4 Thdr:6 Ice:-6 Drg:5
*Note: MUST have a 1 socket weapon


Silver Sol Z Helm
Silver Sol Z Mail
Rathalos X Vambraces
Rathalos X Tasset
Silver Sol Z Greaves
Gems: 5x Grinder Jewel, 2x Unsheathing Jewel,1x Swordsman Jewel
Skills: ESP, Art of Unsheathing, Attack Up Large, Sharpening Skill Inc
Def: 607; Fire:10 Wtr:-5 Thdr:1 Ice:-6 Drg:-5
*Note: Must have 1 socket weapon
**Good for GS as well
$credit to blazer$

So with the Hurt and Heal thread done, what else is on everyone's mind? Perhaps another H&H except with Generation 1 and 2 this time? What else could we bring to the table?