Requests, Feedback & Suggestions

Forum Options:	my.neoforum register members prefs search faq

Topic: Requests, Feedback & Suggestions Options: Print subscribe remove NeoPM
Threads List « Next Newest Next Oldest »
ViNCeNZo Neo or Bust total posts: 7803 since: Aug 2004	Dec 18, 07 at 9:46pm ^ Requests, Feedback & Suggestions
	Log in to remove this sponsored message Hello, and welcome to the Player Help & Guides Forum. We (the forum moderators) decided to create an additional Suggestions thread in this forum seeing as the place was actually created, but a lot of work still needs to be done. On a first note, I have a few questions for regular posters of the Player Help & Guide Forum: What do you think of the Forum in it's current state? Where do you think this Forum needs improvements? Would you like more organized threads, and if so, what should go in organized threads and what not? If members would create Player Guides, would you use them for reference? Would you want to write Player Guides yourself? If you have any suggestions about the Player Help & Guide Forum apart from these questions, feel free to post them, as these questions are merely guidelines Please note that this thread counts as suggestions thread for the Player Help & Guide forum only. The other sections of the forum have their own suggestions threads. This message was edited by ViNCeNZo on Dec 18 2007. This message was edited by ViNCeNZo on Dec 18 2007. ------------------- You must gather your party before venturing forth.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Advertisement Neoseeker	^ Sponsored message

	Log in or register to remove this sponsored message
Underated Permanently Plugged In total posts: 13571 since: Jul 2006	Dec 18, 07 at 9:57pm ^ re: Requests Feedback & Suggestions
	quote ViNCeNZo What do you think of the Forum in it's current state? It's reached it's goal (keeping the main forum tidy) but it's in a huge mess and doesn't look very good. quote ViNCeNZo Where do you think this forum needs improvements? quote ViNCeNZo Would you like more organized threads, and if so, what should go in organized threads and what not? Exactly what you have said, more organised threads are needed. We could have a 'Rate my player' thread which would basically be the same as the 'rate my team' thread but obviously just to post up players you've found. There could be a set challenge thread. Basically with a load of challenges on the first page like the one in the main forum. For example one could be get Sergio Aguero to score 50 goals and gain 20 assists in all competitions in one season etc etc. When I think of more ideas I'll post them up. quote ViNCeNZo If members would create Player Guides, would you use them for reference? quote ViNCeNZo Would you want to write Player Guides yourself? Yes, I support the suggestion of writing player guides and yes I would write player guides myself. I think it would be handy to know how other people bring the best out of certain players and it would help people who struggle with certain player instructions etc etc. Overall, I think that this forum is working very well and it has reached it's goal. With the changes I've suggested and with extra changes that I'm sure will happen, it could make the forum look a lot better and more professional.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Danger Alba gu bràth Neolithic since: Aug 2004	Dec 18, 07 at 10:33pm ^ re: Requests Feedback & Suggestions
	Hey ViNCeNZo, how are you doing buddy? V: Pretty much alright thank you. And yourself? This forum's doing alright. It's fulfilling the reasons for having the forum in the first place. I would like player guides but that's a hard task to ask from the moderators, it's more for the members making these threads (I'm sure the members answering people's questions in this forum could do a great job making player guides! ). There doesn't seem to be a lot that needs improving, just the thread titles look a bit messy. More simplistic and neater titles would make the forum look a bit more organized but isn't necessarily required. This message was edited by ViNCeNZo(moderator) on Dec 19 2007. -------------------
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Carlyon Seeketh Maximus total posts: 5193 since: Aug 2006	Dec 18, 07 at 10:36pm ^ re: Requests Feedback & Suggestions
	It's ok, a bit messy though. I still feel a RMT/BMT idea would be good as I have seen it work very well in the Pokemon forums too. -------------------
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
SuperSimmo Chris Benoit FTW true seeker total posts: 1033 since: May 2007	Dec 18, 07 at 10:38pm ^ re: Requests Feedback & Suggestions
	I would be interested in writing player guides. anyone mind if i have a go? -------------------
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
ViNCeNZo Neo or Bust total posts: 7803 since: Aug 2004	Dec 18, 07 at 10:52pm ^ re: Requests Feedback & Suggestions
	Yeah sure, I have been looking for a nice Player Thread but I cannot find one at the moment. It would be cool however if you could pay attention to the layout a bit. Like in a SOMS. If you're going to have a go and it looks good, we can actually use yours as an example if we're gonna story the Player Guides. ------------------- You must gather your party before venturing forth.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Carlyon Seeketh Maximus total posts: 5193 since: Aug 2006	Dec 18, 07 at 10:58pm ^ re: Requests Feedback & Suggestions
	This is a perfect example of a player guide already done. -------------------
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Lazzara #riseabovehate 4 lyf Permanently Plugged In total posts: 13222 since: Mar 2004	Dec 19, 07 at 1:10am ^ re: Requests Feedback & Suggestions
	Honestly, I don't see any point why we need a player guide. Some players are random, so yeah, I don't think it's a good idea. And making a guide for one player is rather useless, to be honest. Why? Because the majority of forum members want a help in this sub forum, not an explanation of a player. ------------------- i will stand, take my stand at the back the motherbleeping bus cuz im a proud ass bleep ✪ Fandango Crew ✪
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Footy Manager King PS3_iD : JSSnowball ultra seeker total posts: 1362 since: Jun 2007	Dec 19, 07 at 2:31am ^ re: Requests Feedback & Suggestions
	IMO i think the Player Discussion forum is quite messy and it needs to be a bit more organized. I also think that a 'Player Guides' thread would be very useful for FM'ers seeking advice on how to get full potential from their players. And i personally would consider creating a player guide. ------------------- My DigiPort \| PM Me
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Lone Warrior Eternal total posts: 28377 since: Jun 2005	Dec 19, 07 at 1:06pm ^ re: Requests, Feedback & Suggestions
	quote Lazzara Honestly, I don't see any point why we need a player guide. Some players are random, so yeah, I don't think it's a good idea. And making a guide for one player is rather useless, to be honest. Why? Because the majority of forum members want a help in this sub forum, not an explanation of a player. We're talking about well known and widely used players. I'm not expecting to see a "Kyriakos Papadopoulos Guide", but guides about Sergio Aguero, Rafael Van der Vaart, Mika Aaritalo (pre-patch), players that can excel in one position when given the right instructions. Plus, we are not going to base this forum on player guides, but they could make a nice addition to this effort. Edit: Thread Index / Screenshot Request thread created. I thought we could fulfill two purposes with one thread, since the forum doesn't have too many generic threads to warrant a Thread Index and I do see a few threads requesting player stats while it would be much easier to gather them all in one thread so that one person can take care of them all. It's still a trial period, so feedback is always welcome. This message was edited by Lone Warrior on Dec 20 2007.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
The Shape True Addiction since: Sep 2005	Dec 20, 07 at 8:40pm ^ re: Requests, Feedback & Suggestions
	Half these guides are shit, far too short for the most part and look like some have been done for the sake of it.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Underated Permanently Plugged In total posts: 13571 since: Jul 2006	Dec 20, 07 at 8:42pm ^ re: Requests, Feedback & Suggestions
	quote The Shape Half these guides are shit, far too short for the most part and look like some have been done for the sake of it. I agree with that, there are a few guides that the creator has put no effort into what so ever. Could we please implement a system in which a moderator has to preview the guide first before it gets published?
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Sam Wise Men Say Permanently Plugged In total posts: 14748 since: Oct 2006	Dec 20, 07 at 8:44pm ^ re: Requests, Feedback & Suggestions
	quote Underated quote The Shape Half these guides are shit, far too short for the most part and look like some have been done for the sake of it. I agree with that, there are a few guides that the creator has put no effort into what so ever. Could we please implement a system in which a moderator has to preview the guide first before it gets published? Exactly what I was just about to say, I mean most of these guides contain nothing of which we cannot find out by simply looking at a screenshot of the player & his statistics. -------------------
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
The Shape True Addiction since: Sep 2005	Dec 20, 07 at 8:50pm ^ re: Requests, Feedback & Suggestions
	The guide comments are just as bad, instead of "gg mate 10/10 kutgw!" it should be people offering their own views and experiences etc etc.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Lazzara #riseabovehate 4 lyf Permanently Plugged In total posts: 13222 since: Mar 2004	Dec 20, 07 at 8:50pm ^ re: Requests, Feedback & Suggestions
	This is madness. The only "good" guide was only by The Shape, but someone deletes it As I've predicted before, the player guide is not really a good idea. And as The Shape has pointed out, if the guide contains of discussions of the player, that's okay- but the majority of people are commenting the lay-out instead, so yeah... ------------------- i will stand, take my stand at the back the motherbleeping bus cuz im a proud ass bleep ✪ Fandango Crew ✪
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
[All dates in (PST) time]	Threads List « Next Newest Next Oldest »

Thread title	From	Last replied
Now searching...

Hobbies

Sports

Skills

Chat and Lounges

Game Platforms

Mobile Platforms

Top Core Games

Top Portable Games

Top Communities