Computer HardwareXbox GamesGameCubePlaystation 2PSOnePC/Windows GamesGameboy AdvanceDreamcastNintendo 64Gameboy ColorNintendo DSSony PSPXbox 360Nintendo Wii GamesPS3 Games

Neoseeker Forums » GameGrep Forums » GameGrep Bugs » A study of Duplicate articles not detecting

Moderated by: Krunal
REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START NEW THREAD
Options: Print   subscribe   remove   send to friend   PM this thread to a friendNeoPM
subscribe to thread Topic: A study of Duplicate articles not detecting
Redemption
"N" Custodial Engineer.
(admin)



Redemption's profileRedemption's neohomeBlogged: Tweaking the Xbox Gamercard Page [Jun 30 6:31 pm]Redemption's gallery (180 images)
total posts: 4810
GameGrep pts: 1064
since: Mar 2000
Jul 11, 08 at 1:47pm
A study of Duplicate articles not detecting

quote Deathsythe
The majority of them were deleted already, but lemme look through my inbox for some links:


This one was the most recent, and unfortunately all I could find at the moment.
I added Japanese Gamers Have Already Gave Up on WiiFit, and it didn't show the original.

I'll keep digging through my inbox for some more.



Also - an issue I've been meaning to address - the link that is provided in the PM when GG news is set to be removed often just links to http://www.neoseeker.com/news/11267-/, which is clearly not the article in question (the number is different each time, but the end result is still the same)

Sorry for not bringing that up sooner.





In the above example the titles are: The problem with trying to match those up as dupes is that the system relies on the article title to determine duplication. Those two titles are very different, in fact, they almost don't have any words in common at all (even WiiFit vs Wii Fit).

And the other problem is the two sources are totally different. We need to start investigating NEW WAYs of helping users identify dupes. Some ideas that might work:
  • Showing the users all news posted in the past 72hours relating to the game you are attaching to. (we might have to change the way the submission form works to do this)
  • Encouraging users to view the game page of the games you are writing for, where all the latest news is listed. (eg for [img link=Wii Fit]http://www.gamegrep.com/games/wii_fit/[/img])
I'm not really sure what more we can do. This is not a failure of the system, its the fact that detecting dupe articles which use different text is very difficult.


-------------------
The further back you can look, the farther ahead you can see. <paraphrased>
- Winston Churchill
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Guugley
Forget About It
Seeketh Maximus



Guugley's profileNeoPM Guugley
since: Oct 2006
Jul 11, 08 at 5:49pm
re: A study of Duplicate articles not detecting

It seems like you mis-used an image link for a normal link code.

There's nothing really you can do about this though, is there? Like you said there could be something that shows all the articles submitted within the last 72 hours and I suppose that could do, but it would be quite a lot of work for the approvers/moderators. Maybe if you could seperate the articles within the past 3 days into categories (Or are they referred to as 'entities'? I haven't submitted for ages now) then it would make the job easier, but if it was simply a list compiled of each article then it might be asking a little too much.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Deathsythe
Avasythe: Dividing by Zero since 2008
(moderator)

Wiki Staff Applications


wiki staff
advancewars
digimon
fable
guitarhero
neowiki




Deathsythe's profileDeathsythe's neohomeNeoPM DeathsytheDeathsythe's gallery (15 images)
total posts: 6756
neopoints: 1181
GameGrep pts: 7447
since: Jul 2002
Jul 14, 08 at 5:20am
re: A study of Duplicate articles not detecting

For another example let me cite this:

I just put through this article |GG,

Which potentially can be a duplicate of this article|GG

Though it did not show up in the potential duplicates.

quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Avalith
Avasythe: Dividing by Zero since 2008
(moderator)

RPG/Adventure [DS]
Wiki Staff Applications


wiki staff
chrono
neowiki
yugioh




Avalith's profileAvalith's neohomeNeoPM AvalithAvalith's gallery (4 images)
total posts: 18800
GameGrep pts: 3520
since: Jul 2003
Jul 14, 08 at 10:38am
re: A study of Duplicate articles not detecting

It's been like this for months.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Deathsythe
Avasythe: Dividing by Zero since 2008
(moderator)

Wiki Staff Applications


wiki staff
advancewars
digimon
fable
guitarhero
neowiki




Deathsythe's profileDeathsythe's neohomeNeoPM DeathsytheDeathsythe's gallery (15 images)
total posts: 6756
neopoints: 1181
GameGrep pts: 7447
since: Jul 2002
Jul 15, 08 at 6:48am
re: A study of Duplicate articles not detecting

Here is another potential one.

(E3) Fallout 3 Demo didn't show Finally: Fallout 3 In-Game Footage as a potential dupe.


They are from totally different sites, and the gametrailers link really doesn't tell much, but even the article headline didn't matchup with it.

If you look to here it doesn't even show up as a related article.


quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Deathsythe
Avasythe: Dividing by Zero since 2008
(moderator)

Wiki Staff Applications


wiki staff
advancewars
digimon
fable
guitarhero
neowiki




Deathsythe's profileDeathsythe's neohomeNeoPM DeathsytheDeathsythe's gallery (15 images)
total posts: 6756
neopoints: 1181
GameGrep pts: 7447
since: Jul 2002
Jul 16, 08 at 12:44pm
re: A study of Duplicate articles not detecting

Two articles regarding the 80GB PS3 [1][2].

Same issue, didn't show up as potential duplicates, doesn't even show up in related articles.


quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Akira_EX
Scribblenauts
(moderator)

General Wii




Akira_EX's profileAkira_EX's neohomeNeoPM Akira_EXAkira_EX's gallery (2 images)
total posts: 12544
neopoints: 4103
GameGrep pts: 16478
since: Sep 2001
Jul 18, 08 at 3:50am
re: A study of Duplicate articles not detecting



-------------------


[What's New on the Wii Shop Channel?]
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Deathsythe
Avasythe: Dividing by Zero since 2008
(moderator)

Wiki Staff Applications


wiki staff
advancewars
digimon
fable
guitarhero
neowiki




Deathsythe's profileDeathsythe's neohomeNeoPM DeathsytheDeathsythe's gallery (15 images)
total posts: 6756
neopoints: 1181
GameGrep pts: 7447
since: Jul 2002
Jul 21, 08 at 8:26am
re: A study of Duplicate articles not detecting

quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
[All dates in (PT) time]Threads List   « Next Newest   Next Oldest »
REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START A NEW THREAD


search:
Neoseeker Forums » GameGrep Forums » GameGrep Bugs » A study of Duplicate articles not detecting



Jump to another forum:

Powered by neoforums v0.9.6 (equilibrium)
Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2009

neoseeker forum community
Neoseeker.com   |   Forum Rules   |   Forum FAQ   |   Neoseeker Terms of Use   |   Supermods On Duty [ server id: nova ··· elapsed: 0.0685851574]
Affiliated sites:   GameGrep - Football Manager Wiki - Halo Wiki - MGS Wiki - GTA Wiki - Smackdown Wiki - Zelda Wiki - PS2seeker - Xbox seeker - DEVPEN - GFXcess