Walkthroughs, should they be allowed on GG?

Not really. WT's don't count as any sort of news in the least. Theres already a FAQ and Walkthrough section on this main site, When i see the top stories clogged up with walkthrus i'll probably reconsider switching to N4G

_{Um, you guys do realize that gamegrep isn't just for news. It also has neat things like Pictures, videos, blogs...etc. So yes, I think they could be useful on gamegrep.}

I think guides are a neat addition to GG, particularly the video ones. VGB moreso again as they compile sets.

If we want to outlaw FAQs due to them being on Neo, sure (although then I'd vouch for more promotion of Neoseeker on GG). But we don't have video guides on there, so I'd prefer to keep letting them through, personally, and I suppose remove both categories, replacing them with a "video walkthrough" category or something.

Play ISDF, there is a cheat category too.

We're not so strict with the "social news" label.

To be honest, we already have Walkthroughs on neowikis and on neoseeker itself, so I don't see why they shouldn't be allowed on GameGrep. The problem I see if numerous WGs being uploaded. Also would you only allow User written ones? Net written ones? Or both?

[size=1][color=#666666]This message was edited by Dragoon on Dec 27 2009.

quote Dragoon

To be honest, we already have Walkthroughs on neowikis and on neoseeker itself, so I don't see why they shouldn't be allowed on GameGrep.

It just seems like needless duplication of functions to me. I'd prefer to see the section section on Neo upgraded and more heavily promoted and walkthroughs redirected there.

quote chautemoc

Actually it's not, and we may kill that category/refuse those articles soon, despite ratings. There's a lot of changes being discussed at the moment.

Woohoo!

^That's it.
We weren't referring to the wikis necessarily though -- there are FAQs/walkthroughs as well.

quote Curt Connors

quote Dragoon

You have to think about it this way, not everyone that access' Neoseeker goes to the NeoWikis and everyone that access' the NeoWikis may not to to Neoseeker. So to people that don't frequent neoseeker or the sister sites, and just want a walkthrough, they can find them in one place or another.

Yeah, I know. but my slightly OCD nature wants to see them tidied away neatly in one place. Sue me for having a useful mod quality damn you
I just naturally want to see things in one category.

So do I, which is why I make sure my wikis are nicely categorised.