shweet!

Wow... I could just see the mass explosions now... Most of the Galaxy wrecked... Both ships trying to gain an advantage...

Or... You can look at it this way:

The Destruction of the Second Death Star lead to the Collapse of the Galactic Empire.

The CONstruction of the Star Forge Lead to the Collapse of the "Infinite Empire" (That's how the Gaurdian in the Dantooine Ruins refers to the Rakatan).

My vote then Goes for the Death Star.

The only Rakata was that diary, "The Rak" Remember? But the star forge didn't annihalate planets, it still provided the potential for ruling, the universe! I like it better

could the star forge make multiple death stars?
because if it could i think it could kick the deathstars
butt.even if the star forge was easily destroyed
faster than the first and second deathstars.you
could make limitless weapons and troops the deathstar
is good at blowing up planets but stardestroyers destroyed
terris so wowid have to go with the star forge

Star forge can only make ships. The star shipd only destory the city on taris, not the planey like the death star can. Plus the death star has a shield!

Technically the Death star didn't carry it's own independent Sheild. It relied on a Ground based Sheild emitter. In that case it is entirely plausible that the Starforge could have its own sheild Designed, which would be even more useful since it could sit in one place and still be effective, while the Deathstar had to be able to move around in order to carry out its function.

I am usre they could give it it's own shield!

not think of it this way, what if the Star forge and the death star were controled by the same side.. (bum,b bum buuuuummm!!!)

ok? maybe we should ask then, which station would win dependent upon its contollers...

Star forge being controlled by Revan, Malak and Bastila.

Death Star being controlled by Darth Vader and palpatine.

Revan has unbelivable battle knowledge and tactics, however then the emporer can see into the futer.
Malak and vader are both super freaky and have machine on there face at some point.
BUT bastila has battle meditation.

If we went on who was controlling it id say star forge. im pretty sure that the star forge could out number, hence out gun the empire 3 to 1.

But...the death star could blow up the star forge as if it was paper...

Put a leviathan ship thing in the way of its beam

I'd not be surprised if the Star Forge had an uber powerful weapon. I might, the fleets of ships that it could send in a moment could probably beat down the Death Star to nothing, but I bet it has a few weapons of it's own that lash back nicely.

I wonder what would happen if it ever turned that energy beam on the Deathstar.

Or they did it at the same time, lol, draw. (unless they hit but this isn't dragon ball z)

no, most of you ppl dont get it. ill do it in a turn based style, letting the Star Forge go first:


1. Star Forge (SF) begins by mass building a huge fleet of ships. Death Star (DS) begins by charging up the main laser.
2. SF launches huge fleet of ships. DS continues charging up laser.
3. SF fleet comes to DS and begins attacking, and realizes it cant be damaged thanks to the shield generator located on Endor. Also, fleet is getting shot down by the DS's defence turrets. DS continues charging laser.
4. SF fleet flys down to Endor's surface, and begin looking for the shield generator. DS continues charging laser.
5. SF fleet finally finds shield generator and opens fire on it. DS is done charging main laser and fires on the SF, destroying it in one hit.
6. SF fleet destroys generator and flys back up to space. DS now launches its own fleet of TIE fighters and interceptors, including Darth Vader and his fighter.
7. Battle insues as SF fleet get partly side tracked by DS fleet, while trying to attack the DS. DS fleet and defence turrets continue slowly taking down the much larger enemy fleet. Darth Vader is racking up a high kill list and is untouchable.
8. SF fleet still havent figured out that the only way to destroy the DS is by attacking it inside. Thanks largely to Vader, the SF fleet is being whittled down with no way to replenish the ships since the SF is gone.
9. Finally, the DS fleet begins to outnumber the SF fleet, and slowly but surely, the SF fleet is entirely destroyed.
10. The Death Star wins. End scenario.

OR, ALTERNATELY, JUST FOR FUN. DS vs. SF vs. THE BORG (Star Trek):

1. SF launches massive fleet. DS begins charging main laser. Borg Cube (BC) flys in and stops halfway.
2. SF fleet sees BC as bigger threat (also cause its closer than the DS is) and begins attacking it. Despite the huge fleet attacking, the BC loses only about 2% of their shield strength. DS continues charging laser.
3. After a bit, BC has adapted to SF fleet's weapons, and so they no longer do any damage at all. DS continues charging.
4. DS fires main laser at BC. BC's shields drop 53%. Darth Vader wets his pants (j/k). BC fires salvo of Gravimetric Torpedos at SF which shreds it to pieces.
5. SF fleet continues attacking BC. DS launches fleet, including Vader. BC fires EMP around the ship and destroys 3/4 of the SF fleet.
6. DS fleet sees the remaining SF fleet as weaker so attacks them. BC moves in closer to DS.
7. SF fleet is destroyed. DS fleet begins attacking BC but once again, they adapt and weapons do nothing. BC fires another EMP destroying all but Darth Vader and a few other TIE fighters.
8. BC fires a couple torpedos down to Endor where the shield generator is, destroying it. Vader decides the battle is hopeless and flies away.
9. BC transports hundreds of Borg Drones into DS and begin assimilating all stormtroopers, imperial officers and everyone else inside. Only a couple Drones are killed before they adapt to the laser fire.
10. Nothing can stop the Borg as they assimilate the Death Star and everyone, including the Emperor, who is ganged up on by 50 or more Borg. The Borg win. End scenario.

This message was edited by shinobi_razor on Sep 17 2006.