ive heard this arguement all around the internet, annd i may as well bring it here, anyone in this forum should of heard of big daddys, but how many of you know of pyramid head, hes in silent hill 2, and the movie, but the question is thisly, which one is scariest and who do you think would win in a fight.


o, if you still dont know who p.head is, hes the one with da *bleep*in knife

I'd say Pyramid head would win and he's scarier

I haven't really played silent hill so i couldn't say really.
But from the youtube videos he looks rather slow and daddies got all that armor on and are super fast.

But obviously hes more scary big daddies are more cool than scary .

id say pyramid head, he can take his tiime, that armour wont help big daddy in the end.

Pyramid is scary as hell,but in a fight, the Big daddy would win,HANDS DOWN.

Pin head from Hellraiser

nah Pyramid head would put fear in people because of how freaky he is and well a gigantic buthers knife that can reach you from 7ft away. Big Daddies are seen more as protectors and are cooler. You can associate with them more or less but obviously get on their bad side and well they can be scary but both are very different.

Like I said Big Daddies are protectors...Pyramid head is just a pyschotic freak

pyshco or not P.H. is cool, from now on i would 'ppreciate if anyone who wants to say who would win gives a reason, im going with pyramid head, he is cool,he survives a shotgun blast right next to him, when hes practicly barechested, anyone who takes a good ammount of time playing silent hill 2 will know p.h. strikes fear into you when you are about to face him, i was happy when i heard daddy, because i knew i was getting an adam top up

quote mynamegoeshere

pyshco or not P.H. is cool, from now on i would 'ppreciate if anyone who wants to say who would win gives a reason, im going with pyramid head, he is cool,he survives a shotgun blast right next to him, when hes practicly barechested, anyone who takes a good ammount of time playing silent hill 2 will know p.h. strikes fear into you when you are about to face him, i was happy when i heard daddy, because i knew i was getting an adam top up

p.h. can run, in some levels he does,

"big daddy would drill the hell out of him"

if p.h. couldtake a chainsaw with out a scratch, without diving suit armour on, maybe drills are stronger but still, jack takes out loads a daddys in the game, and hes not the jesus version of a devil god is he hes a 2** year old ***************

Mynamegoeshere, you are comparing a shotgun blast to a massive whirling drill being plowed by the force of a big daddy behind it...compared to that a shotgun blast is like getting hit with a leaf

However it is like comparing freddy to jason. Two complete different nightmares with two complete different weaknesses.

To be fair I would say in a fight they would be quite even. Bouncer against PH would be slow at first and wouldn't attack until he is provoked or a little sister is in danger. Considering that PH would be able to get a decent shot with the huge knife and cause major damage...if he was smart he would hit for the drill arm first, if not the most Bouncer would lose is his right arm or considerable damage to his diving suit.

Bouncer would then drill through PH while PH is slow on readying a next attack

A rosie against PH would be the same except Rosie would use the tactic of moving back and shooting rivets/proxi mines at PH.

Sure PH would put up a good fight against both of them but I doubt he would do much

Big daddy for the simple fact that u never got anything from killing pyramid head (ok bragging rights at the most) but at least with big daddy's you can go back and fourth to different areas and stock up on the inventing supplies...


plus i thought big daddies were a bit scarier...pyramid head was freaky in the movie but it loses its scare appeal after a while

quote mynamegoeshere

p.h. can run, in some levels he does,

"big daddy would drill the hell out of him"

if p.h. couldtake a chainsaw with out a scratch, without diving suit armour on, maybe drills are stronger but still, jack takes out loads a daddys in the game, and hes not the jesus version of a devil god is he hes a 2** year old ***************

and ph is practically invincible, a form of the dark god xucilbara, under his(her?) shell, big daddys just a human doped up on ADAM

quote shadowj

Mynamegoeshere, you are comparing a shotgun blast to a massive whirling drill being plowed by the force of a big daddy behind it...compared to that a shotgun blast is like getting hit with a leaf

quote HilaryDuffGta

that u never got anything from killing pyramid head

quote mynamegoeshere

pyshco or not P.H. is cool, from now on i would 'ppreciate if anyone who wants to say who would win gives a reason, im going with pyramid head, he is cool,he survives a shotgun blast right next to him, when hes practicly barechested, anyone who takes a good ammount of time playing silent hill 2 will know p.h. strikes fear into you when you are about to face him, i was happy when i heard daddy, because i knew i was getting an adam top up

i meant this

quote mynamegoeshere

p.h. couldtake a chainsaw with out a scratch,

quote shadowj

pyshco or not P.H. is cool, from now on i would 'ppreciate if anyone who wants to say who would win gives a reason, im going with pyramid head, he is cool,he survives a shotgun blast right next to him, when hes practicly barechested, anyone who takes a good ammount of time playing silent hill 2 will know p.h. strikes fear into you when you are about to face him, i was happy when i heard daddy, because i knew i was getting an adam top up

unless I am dyslexic I think that says shotgun

quote mynamegoeshere

ph is practically invincible, a form of the dark god xucilbara

quote mynamegoeshere

just a human doped up on ADAM

quote shadowj

shotgun blast right next to him, when hes practicly barechested