I have Gustafa at Red Heart and did all of his heart events,I have the Blue Feather,the Harvest Goddess came back,and I have the Big Bed but when I asked him he said I'm so happy but no.
I did use Action Replay to make hime a Red Heart and get all of the Harvest Sprites back but it shows a Red Heart for him and I can use the Harvest Sprites for help.

Please tell me what to do I am clueless.

ok but what does he like again??

what about relax tea.I use all the herbs and 1 tea leave i would do hot milk but already sold cow

Well I did what you said and he still said no what should do now??

This message was merged with other messages by Princess Alyak (moderator)

You have all sprites,the big bed,red heart,you have the kitchen,and the house upgrade,maybe there's something missing,what do you have?,because is very rare that you have all requirements but he say not.....

this is from fogu:

When his Love Points are 60,000 or higher then you can marry, but only if you have completed the other requirements. Besides having the man at a red heart color, you need to also own the Big Bed, activated all 4 of his Heart Events, and have rescued at least 60 Harvest Sprites. Only after you have completed all 4 tasks can you give him the Blue Feather. The Feather will become available for purchase at Karen's store once you have a man up to an Orange (50,000 LP) heart level.

and if you didnt activate the heart events here:

Black Heart Event
» Walk from Beach to Turtle Pond
» 9:00 am to 5:00 pm, not Tuesday, sunny day

As you leave the beach area you'll hear your name being called from near the Turtle pond. Gustafa wants to know if you would chat with him for a bit. Answer that you would (うん、するする). The topic circles around having pride with your work and he asks if you have it as well. Respond that you do (当然持ってる) and Gustafa will start singing! He apologizes for his outburst and wishes you well with your work.



Purple Heart Event
» Exit your farmhouse
» 6:00 am to 8:00 am, sunny day

When you leave your house in the morning Gustafa will be at your front door. He says he would like to go bird watching since today's weather is nice. Gustafa invites you to go along with him. Respond that you'd like to go (うん、行こう) and the two of you will head off to the Beach.

At the Beach Gustafa says that it's easy for him to make tunes from this spot. Since the small and large waves have different shapes he never gets bored watching them. The tunes he thinks of seem to float in one after another. Gustafa asks if wordless image also come to your mind. Tell him that you too have them float in (浮かんできてるかも). He says that must be the nature of music. Gustafa thanks you for the long conversation and says he needs to make this image into a song. He will then walk you back to your farm.



Blue Heart Event
» Walk from Main Pathway to Your Farm
» 7:00 pm to 10:00pm, not Tuesday, sunny day

Walk into your farm and Gustafa will follow behind you. He says it's a nice night and invites you to go for a walk with him. If you agree to talk a walk with him (いいね、行こう) then the two of you will go off for a walk.

Gustafa decides to rest for a bit at the Turtle pond. The atmosphere around the pond is just as enjoyable at night as it is during the day. At night the pond is quite beautiful. The stars reflecting on the water are equally as beautiful, and the cosmos spreads wide above. It's easier for Gustafa to hear the sound of the wind during the night. He enjoys the valley during the day and night that he starts singing again. Gustafa then walks you back to your house.



Yellow Heart Event
» Gustafa's house
» 6:00 am to 8:00 am

After he welcomes you to his house, Gustafa explains that he just finished making a new composition and now he has to consider what kind of tune would go with it. He suddenly gets an idea to make a tune in your image! Would you teach him some small, simple things you do on your farm? It would help him get a good idea for his tune. Tell him it will be fine (いいですよ) and you'll immediately start showing him different things you do on your farm until Gustafa becomes inspired.

When you finish with your demonstration, Gustafa feels that listening to your story makes him want to live on a farm too. He would probably enjoy it. Gustafa figures he can now quickly make a tune and thanks you for your help.

Ya I did all those things but it still dont work...I'm hopeless

did u use action replay in order to bring the Harvest Goddess back? That might be the problem. if u didn't rescue 60 sprites, it might not work