ReQuests, Feedback, and Suggestions - Page 4

Sometimes the easiest way to determine which one(s) should be allowed back is to take them all away for a while and then experiment with opening each thread and leaving the others closed for a while.

Chaos Swordsman you are RUINING MY NEOSEEKER LIFE!(and others)

Catalogue of Reasons:

a) My mate TheRock13 says that monkeyboy made The True Pokemon Story 2DAYS before Suicidal vanished.

b) Pokemon Mystery Epic was mainly for Tytorita's english class.

c) There was supposed to be an event on 5/2/07(britain) in The True Pokemon Story and now it has been ruined.(I was about to enjoy that!)

d) I'm trying to get 50 posts (as it is my current target) but as you've closed virtually ALL the threads that I go on here I can't.

e) As others have said this forum is now dead.

f) There isn't spam in the RP's.

I think thats probaly it I'll edit this post if I find any more reasons.

I hope this will show you how much my neo-life has been ruined.

By the way Kyros:

quote

With the forum's current state, it appears as though there is no need for a new moderator; Chaos Swordsman is perfectly capable of handling the forum while Suicidal Insanity is gone

This is a bit wrong if you look at the Catalogue of Reasons.

B*O*D* HELL! I HAVE NO REASON TO LIVE! THE TRUE POKEMON STORY HAS BEEN CLOSED! I AM GOING TO DIE! THERE WAS ABSOLUTELY NO SPAM IN IT AT ALL! THERE ARE ABSOLUTELY NO RP THREADS AT ALL! THIS FORUM IS *bleep*ED UP! I am annoyed.

quote TheDPMaster11

Catalogue of Reasons:

a) My mate TheRock13 says that monkeyboy made The True Pokemon Story 2DAYS before Suicidal vanished.

b) Pokemon Mystery Epic was mainly for Tytorita's english class.

c) There was supposed to be an event on 5/2/07(britain) in The True Pokemon Story and now it has been ruined.(I was about to enjoy that!)

d) I'm trying to get 50 posts (as it is my current target) but as you've closed virtually ALL the threads that I go on here I can't.

e) As others have said this forum is now dead.

f) There isn't spam in the RP's.

A, B, and C) Does that have any bearing on the reason why it was closed? No.

D) Post count doesn't mean anything; it's the quality that matters.

E) Like I said, it's up to the community whether the forum dies or stays alive. If you refuse to take me up on my offer, then I'm not going to even consider re-opening them. However, if you make an active attempt at genuine game discussion, you might find that some of the story and game threads will come back eventually.

F) Since when did I say there was spam in the RP threads?

This message was edited by Chaos Swordsman on Feb 07 2007.

I'd like to bring the text at the top of every page in this forum to your attention.



This forum is intended for discussion. While story/RP threads are not pure spam, they are most certainly not discussion. If there is actually some discussion in a forum, then a few of those threads are fine. However, when there is not discussion in a forum, and the game/RP threads are what the forum is running on, it creates an unacceptable situation.

Basically Chaos Swordsman is putting the RP thread in your hands. Use the other threads in the forum the way that they are meant to be used (for discussion) and when the forum has enough discussion to prove that the activity will not be based on an RP thread, one will certainly be created.

You're acting like Chaos Swordsman is being ridiculously uptight and strict here, when in reality he's being quite lenient.

There are many discussion threads in this forum, many discussion threads are repeated, most of them get their questions answered on the third or fourth post. I think most members in this forum have completed the game and know what they are doing, that is why not many people come to discuss in this forum.

I have got a comprimise, What if we can do a RP but it must also involves discussions about the game, would that be fair, Chaos Swordsman

Read my post and keep in mind the deal that Chaos Swordsman has put on the table. This really is a simple concept and personal attacks at him are not going to help. He's not going to compromise further, he's already done that enough. If you want an RP thread you're going to have to discuss other things first.