quote armless_man

A+ I love how this sprite just radiates "Tough". Using Aggron was a great choice - unexpected, but great - and all the different pieces come together nicely. I love how the spots are more concentrated in the middle of its body and slowly fade out, and overall this is an excellent sprite. Definitely deserving of the A+.

quote hiiiii

A Again, I appreciate the effort taken to make it look similar to Feebas, as most evolutions do look similar to their earlier form. I do like its massive jaw and the spots once again, but it didn't WOW me. Still, great work.

quote JiZZi

B+ I do like this entry quite a lot. I love how Feebas' lips got turned into a coloured jaw, and the fluff on its head. It genuinely looks "cute". Unfortunately, that means it genuinely looks nothing at all like Feebas. I would've liked it to look more like the Pokemon it evolved from, but by all means, it's an excellent sprite.

quote zelda_rulez

F I'm sorry. I appreciate the effort, and by all means it would've been great if it was in the right size, but unfortunately it wasn't. The recolour looks solid and the overall flow is good, but the size kills it. In the future, don't submit oversized sprites.

quote Aya Chan

B+ Despite the fact it looks quite similar to JiZZi's entry, I do like it a lot. My only problems with it are the outline, the light pink around the Chansey bits (they make an awkward edge before heading toward the stomach) and the shading (or large lack of it). The colours are rather monotonous, but I do like the sprite. With some fixes along the outline and some added shading, it would be great.

quote Master of Scyther

B I appreciate the effort, but not much was really done. A few edits on Huntail, throw on a fresh coat of paint, add some Wooper bits and call it a day! I like the colours, they look good on Huntail, but it's just nothing inventive or exciting. Don't be afraid to take some risks!

quote TwilightWolf23

B I cannot in good conscious give this a grade higher than a B. I appreciate what you attempted, but in short, it's a recoloured Gyarados without fins and with wings. That's all it is. I really would've liked to have seen more happen with it.

quote GuitarMan91

F I'm so, so sorry GM. The round's theme was to make an evolution for Feebas, not a new species to come by breeding with it. However, I feel all sprites deserve some feedback, other than thematic quality. The recolour was really quite shoddy, and never ever flip parts without editing them accordingly, especially if the original is still on the sprite. It's quite difficult to understand the anatomy of your sprite. I'm so so sorry.

quote samkuro

B+ This is a very interesting entry, but I do like it. Again, the colouring makes it seem too far from the original. If its body was yellow like Feebas, and the rest of the colour scheme flowed accordingly, it would've received a higher mark. The spriting you did on it was very nicely done, however =]

quote Artirtico

A I really appreciate how you used Linoone's frame for the body - It's always refreshing to see someone do something unexpected like that. The colouring looks excellent and the scratch is awesome. I would've loved to see it in Feebas' colours to get an A+.

quote aragornbird

B While this is by all means an amazingly executed sprite - And I really mean that. Everything is spot on *pokes the people who don't see how the tail curls around behind its body* xD - It doesn't follow the theme! The colours are far from Feebas, and doesn't look like it could come from it by any means. That's where you lost your marks. If the colouring was closer, and it was more fish-like than serpentine, I would've had no problem giving it a much deserved A.

quote NFS_Street_King

A I really like this entry. =] The colours look quite good and everything seems to flow. The fin on its head looks great, but I would've liked more fins like that along its body. Regardless, it's a great sprite. My only concern is that it looks nothing like Feebas at all, which is a problem for evolution themes.

quote insert username here

B+ I like what you did with the entry, though it's kinda boring. It's the right colours so that's a bonus, but it's pretty lackluster. I think you could've taken it a bit further but held back.

quote ArcadianSky

B+ An interesting entry. As I said earlier, it's interesting to see people do things unexpected, like use Scizor's claw as a head, or Milotic's tail as fins, though it didn't really win me over. The body is hard to follow, especially with Milotic's tail there, and the shading is pretty rough. A good entry, but hard to follow.


Great work this round, everyone.

-The Scoreboard-

First Place (A+) - Armless_Man
Second Place (A) - Hiiiii,Artirtico
Third Place (A-) - NFS_Street_King

_{According to the front page....}
ArcadianSky: 43 points
Armless_Man: 40 points
Silver Raikou: 13 points
FourthBeat: 11 points
Jizzi: 9 points
King Chaz: 9 points
Artitico: 9 points
Guitarman91: 8 points
christina2010: 5 points
Mizz Manga: 4 points
Halosiel: 4 points
Hiiiii: 4 points
Samkuro: 3 points
Charizard_Girl: 3 points
Insert username here: 3 points
Aragornbird: 3 points
NL2: 3 points
Stefcoolo: 3 points
Master of Scyther: 3 points
Aya Chan: 2 points
Crosby87: 2 points
legolunatic99: 2 points
Game_TesterWB1: 2 points
Banapiel: 2 points
Mr Blikey: 2 points
Skitzer309: 2 points
Dartex: 2 points
ShinyMilotic: 2 points
NFS_Street_King: 1 point
Fkital: 1 point
Boo123: 1 point
zelda_rulez: 1 point
TwilightWolf23: 1 point


New Theme will be set by Christina when she comes online :3 Any complainers during the wait will have their epiglottis bitten by an angry pelican. >=0