Pokemon Diamond Sprite Contest XIII {Requesting Closure} - Page 23

quote ShinyMilotic

Judging:

Are you sure there are 27 entries? If so, which one am I missing? Anyway, I think I'll take up an offer from Chaz, I'll judge half, and he can judge the other half, otherwise this would take me all afternoon to do quality judging, and I aint exactly an expert at judging revamps.

quote Pokemon Rocks

[B] A fairly solid effort, revamps are pretty much all about shading, and your shading aint bad from my point of view, but it could be better. Also I notice the outline of the Pokemon is a little choppy at places, be careful with that.

quote Lunaria

[B/B-] It looks pretty good, but the style of shading makes it a bit different to normal. There really isn't much else to comment about since it's just a revamp, but not too bad.

quote hugs 4 hackers

[B+/A-] I could almost mistake this for a D/P sprite, nice job! It really wasn't a very hard Pokemon to do though, meaning you can't earn much higher than this.

quote Cobalt Ace

[B] Once again, the shading isn't great, but it isn't bad, and the sprite itself doesn't look too bad, it doesn't look like the easiest Pokemon to revamp.

quote stoneobelisk4000

[B/B+] I don't like the shading in some places, but I guess if you did it any other way other areas would look awkward. Not a bad try for your first every revamp.

quote samkuro

[A-] Some of the dark shading could be a touch lighter, but besides that I can't really fault anything, well done.

quote Ahmed000

[B/B-] This sprite scares me. The sprite looks alright, but the shading is not the style I was after. Good effort though.

quote Shiny Mew

[C] You have ruined the sprite a bit when attempting to recolour with that dark purple, practice some recolours and you should improve pretty fast.

quote Constellation

[A-] The shading inside the ears is the wrong way around, but the rest is good, and I'll be nice and not give you less than samkuro. =p

quote Necromancer Wii

[A-] Hmm, I quite like the way this one turned out even though it isn't the average style of shading, it turned out well, good job.

quote jjoploo

[B] Similar to some other sprites, the sprite looks good but the shading could be improved, not a bad effort.

quote Rascal Lover

[B+/A-] Hmm it looks good, I like it when people revamp Pokemon which have a bit of detail on them. The shading isn't like the normal sprites you see, but I now see this is how most people do it, soo...

quote Lizz

[B] The shading needs improving, that's all there is to it. Nice animation by the way.

There is my part, Chaz will finish the rest when he has time, so if yours hasn't been judged yet, unlucky I guess. =D

Me and Chaz might need to discuss who the top 3 should be before he posts, incase our judging styles are too different.

Judging Time

Firstly I'd like to to thank the majority of the participants of this thread for their patience throughout this round. All of our judges have had a stressful week and a half so judging had to be shifted around a lot. I blame Time Difference myself but you can blame whoever.

Now I'm going to be a bit risky here, I'll be posting the grade now, since to most people that's what they want. Then, I WILL edit this with the comments. I am only doing this because then you get your grades before something comes up and I have to stop half way through commenting. I hope you are all good with that. Plus the next round will start sooner.

quote Moony Jay

[B]

quote SquirrelLord

[C+]

quote smurfyeah

[A-]

quote HiHi

[B+]

quote Leoina

[A-]

quote Ingoe

[B]

quote H20firefly

[A]

quote WhiteGold

[A+]

quote fossilhunter

[A+]

quote Artirtico

[A+]

quote Dragon Warrior1

[B-]

quote IncrediblyIncredible

[A]

quote JosiePika

[Auto-F] This one I can comment on now since you will certainly have questions, I'm sorry but I only asked for the sprite to be revamped to Di/Pe/Pl not Emerald.

quote wilson7555

[b][B-]

1st Place: Artirtico, WhiteGold, Fossilhunter
2nd Place: H20firefly, IncrediblyIncredible
3rd Place: Samkuro, Constellation, Necromancer Wii, Leoina, smurfyeah

Those who received B+/A- had a debatable grade, so will not be either on the scoreboard or included in the Hall of Fame.

Scoreboard:[/b]

Artirtico 48
aragornbird 44
FourthBeat 36
WhiteGold 35
Shiny Milotic 32
ArcadianSky 30
Jizzi 25
armless_man 21
Rascal Lover 21
AyraCalaelen 14
fossilhunter 14
Silver_Raikou 12
Weavilax 12
King Chaz 11
Eclipse 10
Necromancer Wii 8
white_knight319 7
Boo123 6
Legion of Shunta 6
Legolunatic99 6
Nrock55 6
samkuro 6
Absolved 5
Celestial Pichu 5
Constellation 5
H2Ofirefly 5
emporer_caopi 4
Kanon_fan 4
BanddudeX 3
Bluepheonix 3
Dartex 3
EMOliciousnot 3
jets15 3
jjoploo 3
Minirizzle 3
NFS_Street_King 3
ShinyAbsol 3
SnoopyMaster 3
Charizard_Girl 2
Dramon-Killer 2
DuoDude56 2
IncrediblyIncredible 2
JosiePika 2
Mega_shuppet 2
Multi Platform Gamer 2
namtlaks1 2
NL2 2
Petdiams47 2
Smurfyeah 2
Cooldude83 1
DarkShadowGlaceon 1
Duckloaf312 1
Guitarman91 1
insert username here 1
lauren_dreamer 1
Leoina 1
Lmjkdd6 1
marc32 1
Moon Jay 1
Nicostrato 1
Neon_Bobcat 1
Nintendoid 1
Overlord 1
Sizzle_Bandicoot 1
stefcoolo 1
wilson7555 1

Now the theme because of Obama's coming victory.

Theme: USA
Description: Create a Sprite that has to do with USA. If you have any queries for the theme either post in the thread or PM one of the judges.
Judge: Aragornbird (or King Chaz if he is not able)
Theme Setter Guy: ShinyMilotic/Aragornbird
Date: 12th November 2008



Chaz

Hmm, can we do non-pokemon sprites for the contest?
Like hats/flags.

I know nothing about the American electon thingy! Apart from the fact Obama is winning, his daughter, I think, is called Sasha, and my sister says Obama eats feet. .

HELP ME SOMEONE PLEASE!

You can just do a sprite of an animal found in the USA or something, if that makes it easier.

Okay, so I decided that I would do a wolf, and this is just a rough draft, in case I don't have time to work on a better one, but this is a Suicune, recoloured using Quilava colours. Hope you at least semi-enjoy it? lol



EDIT 2: Got rid of non-entries.

Alright, sorry.

Unless it's for the contest, most likely not

if its an american pokemon sprite comic...