GTA vs Scarface

Which one???

I like scarface better

quote Subzer0

This is actually tough because I'm a big GTA fan and SA is my 3rd favorite game of all time but I have to go with Scarface. This game is just phenomenal. Worth every penny. Kudos to whoever made the game.

I agree!I bought this game for 50 Dollars and it is worth every penny.And also to me this game beats GTA by a long shot.

GTA:

1.the usual

Scarface:

1.big cash
2.addictive drug deals
3.occaisionally good driving
4.excellent gun action
5.some pretty bad ass missions
6.lots of game play value
7.takes nearly forever to beat
8.makes GTA look like a child's toy box
9.some annoying things here and there

San Andreas:

1.decent story
2.fun driving
3.decent gun action
4.freedom to cause chaos
5.dogfights
6.a few bad ass story missions
7.huge map
8.lots to do
9.but half of it is tedious

I think it's safe to say Scarface is better than GTA in a lot of cases. But San Andreas is still on top for me.

Way better!Worth the 50$

hell yeah it was worth the £30 its wayyyyy better than GTA, yeah how the fook can they give it a 6 9.5 AT least

I give Scarface 9.5/10. Awesome game and it makes the GTA series look like shit. I'm still a big GTA fan.

I never thought I would say it, but this game is better than any GTA game! I would go as far as saying that GTA almost sucks compared to this game. It's that good.

San Andreas beats Scarface overall, in my opinion. But that's no discredit to Scarface, as SA takes some beating in my book.

I'm just very happy that finally there's a sandbox game to entertain me till the release of GTA 4! All credit to the developers, Sierra, for providing some competition for good ol' Rockstar. There are plenty of elements in Scarface that improve on the GTA formula - but I what I respect the most is the fact that Sierra haven;t been afriad to copy the good bits from GTA, like the principal controls, the map system, the attention to small details, etc.

Good on 'em for being a serious contender! Easily 8.5/10 ... the critics (especially Gamespot) will be privately admitting they got this one wrong, I'm sure of that.