I'm going to side with IP (if the debate is still up) Because setting tower and ruins aside (which is foolish for me to say seeing as as you read this I'm raiding the tower gearing up for the next secret shop) money is tight in this game, unless you like to camp at an arena for 100 turns, which I hate seeing as a duelist criticals at some point, leaving me to restart the chapter and over-looking the arena altogether. So best way to get money, is to sell those items you recieve but probably won't use, unless you play every fight strictly safe. And by items you probably won't use I mean antitoxins, pure waters, body rings, (I nabbed one just 5 minutes ago, didn't know what impact it had on combat and sold it), and some other upgrade item that doesn't make a large difference in the long run, (Like this goddess icon I'm bored stiff with because the luck it'd generate comes easily in 2-3 upgrades, excluding Knoll, who I'm probably going to use it on this second...) and also torches, I hate them. The only mission I've found them usable is Ghost Ship, and one of them to know what the Deathgoyle came into range. All of those (excluding upgrades) sell for about 300, which doesn't sound like much, but its better than a cramped supply caravan full of junk that you have enough staves and vulneraries to overlook them entirely. Then again my ideals on torches and purewaters may just be personal expirence (which "Means Nothing", that quote being quite true, just enjoyed putting it in), I'm sure there's people who agree, and that you can simply use a unit with higher resistance (or Barrier staff) or avoid (vs. poison) to get by that situation.
As for views on light magic, the critical rarely does matter, excluding large monsters or enemies with high enough resistance to laugh in the faces of Shine and Lightning and then steal their lunches when the adults aren't looking, even then it probably won't finish them.
Roster picks: (I've been expirementing with them lately, and not to say these are the best, but just my favorite classes, and I haven't delved into Creature Campaign enough to upgrade them ALL, but if I were to, thats whats listed.)
Joshua: Swordmaster
Gerik: Hero
Natasha: Valkyire
Neimi: Ranger (Forest Knight)
Artur: Bishop
Moulder: Bishop
Gilliam: General
Ewan: Sage
Marisa: Swordmaster
Ross: Pirate -> Berserker
Kyle: Great Knight
Forde: Paladin
Franz: Paladin
Amelia: General
Lute: Sage (sages look so cool IMO >.>)
Knoll: Summoner
Garcia: Warrior
Colm: Rouge (Rennac comes in-game too late for my tastes)
Vanessa + Tana: Falcoknights
Cormag: WyvernLord
I think that's about everyone... if I missed someone, well oh well.

You miised L´Archel Knoll and marisa, aslo promoting Ross onto berserker instead of hero is a very bad idea, since the hero has better defences that the berserkers, aslo Ross max Evasion as a hero is 90% as berserker 80%, aslo his skill is much better, promoting Natasha onto the valkyre section it makes you lost the Ultimate bishop, 28 skill 28 spd, max Luck, 20 of def max res, you will be losing a powerfull tank, aslo is an a bad idea make ewan a sage sinc the summoner class is the one that swit hims more, most of your promotions are fine, but Kyle as paladin is better that a GN

I did not miss Knoll, you must have skipped over him, it says "Knoll: Summoner"
Also, if you noticed I said about the Ewan and Lute sage things, "Lute: Sage (sages look so cool IMO >.>)" I didn't add L'Arachel mostly because I forgot, and I never use her, ever, unless I use her horse-back abilities (My Mage Knight Lute also covers this job if I have her) as a mounted healer, which is once in the Rausten Court. I said Valkyre because it is a very... nice looking unit, to say it best, and only two can become one L'Arachel and Natasha, and since I never use L'Arachel, Natasha it is. Ross and Garcia, I don't use either in the long run, and they usually rot in the back of my unit picks with Gilliam who is always out-done by Amelia. Always As for Kyle, he has uber Defense, and Strength, both of which are complimented by GK. (Knight ) And Marisa is also in there.

Valkyrie > Bishop for Natasha, seeing how her best supports are Franz and Seth (both mounted units).

I prefer giving up mobility for the slayer skill.

quote Holy Warrior

Duncan Idaho
Well thats the way that you play your game

quote Duncan Idaho
and i play it to my way

quote Duncan Idaho
for me

quote Duncan Idaho
it lends me

quote Duncan Idaho
my favorite weapons

quote Duncan Idaho
mainly i

quote Duncan Idaho
abuse

All of these statements makes your argument worthless.

It has nothing to do with how anyone plays the game, because PEMN. The only "person" that really matters in debates is the Tier Player who plays the game perfectly (perfectly as in beating the game in the most efficient way) under all of the preset conditions, effectively destroying all bias. IP isn't saying he would never use a Body Ring on a Bishop in his game. What he is saying is that using a Body Ring on a Bishop is a negative to the entire team regardless of who does it. I'll reiterate the point,

Personal Experience Means Nothing

If you refuse to accept this point, all of your arguments will be based on it making them all null and void. Learn to debate please.

Yeah, slayer skill is awesome for all those dracozombies, but the valkyrie's winning everywhere else thanks to her mobility.

quote Insanity Prevails

Yeah, slayer skill is awesome for all those dracozombies, but the valkyrie's winning everywhere else thanks to her mobility.