Computer HardwareXbox GamesGameCubePlaystation 2PSOnePC/Windows GamesGameboy AdvanceDreamcastNintendo 64Gameboy ColorNintendo DSSony PSPXbox 360Nintendo Wii GamesPS3 Games

All Shenmue Forums
Neoseeker Forums » PC Games » RPG » Shenmue Online » is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

Shenmue Online Forum

profile  screens  wiki  discussion board  

REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START NEW THREAD
Options: Print   subscribe   remove   send to friend   PM this thread to a friendNeoPM
subscribe to thread Topic: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?
Heros Destiny
true seeker (2K Remix)



Heros Destiny's profileHeros Destiny's neohomeNeoPM Heros Destiny
since: Apr 2002
Sep 07, 04 at 11:20am
is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

being somewhat of a skeptic myself, i want to hear feedback from all the shenmue fans on whether or not this proposed MMORPG is going to have a positive impact on the continuation and success of the series.


personally, i think that a Shenmue III release would have been better advised before leaping into something this big, complex, and expensive....and almost totally different from the original series.


whether this game succeeds or fails, be it in terms of sales, or even the fan base it might create, i can't see it lending a helping hand in giving Shenmue fans what they've really wanted for the past 3 years; an ending to the original saga....


i'll be more detailed about my thoughts on the matter once some replies come in.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Nemesii
true seeker (2K Remix)



Nemesii's profileNeoPM Nemesii
total posts: 2155
since: Jul 2002
Sep 07, 04 at 1:47pm
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

Isn't the main problem (?) with the series a funding one? Not enough people are buying the games and so the continuation of the series is questioned..

MMORPG's always attract a lot of players, be they from well known series or totally original concepts, I think Shenmue Online will get a lot more attention from people who haven't bothered with the Shenmue games so far and could bring a lot more people into the series.

Could be a bit messy mixing PC with console though .

I don't think there's anything to lose really, if it's a success then it could cement a Shenmue 3 release. If it's a failure it'll just leave the question mark we had beforehand.

I don't see this as a change in direction, more of a sidetrack.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
LanDi Sama
Wright: GIMMIE A KISS
(moderator)

Action [DC]
Art Central
Artist's Gallery
General Dreamcast
RPG/ Strategy / Adventure [DC]
Sports and Racing [DC]


wiki staff
aceattorney
shenmue




LanDi Sama's profileLanDi Sama's neohomeNeoPM LanDi SamaLanDi Sama's Fan Art!
total posts: 6904
neopoints: 3467
since: Feb 2002
Sep 08, 04 at 9:21am
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

I'm going along with the general feeling that this is more of an add-on to the series, rather than a continuation. But you're right, it may be new and interesting, but it doesn't really give us a chance to see what's happening next in the story. I for one would be very disappointed if it did infact finish the story and I wasn't the one who controled Ryo to actually do it.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Heros Destiny
true seeker (2K Remix)



Heros Destiny's profileHeros Destiny's neohomeNeoPM Heros Destiny
since: Apr 2002
Sep 09, 04 at 9:47am
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

basically, i'm worried that this new game will draw attention away from the original series. the storyline is completely different, as is most probably the overall system specs, though we wont know this for sure until more news of the games development is released. it's still in beta testing stages at the momment.

to be honest, i think Shenmue Online will be a hit, with old and new shenmue gamers alike. but there's probably a few bits of information some of you might not know that i should have divulged earlier.




firstly, Yu Suzuki, although a big part of the Shenmue Online project, is now the former head of Am2. Sega decided to replace him with Hiroshi Kataoka (Fighting Vipers, OutTrigger).

however, this is in no way a bad move in terms of Yu's future, who has now moved to a more encompassing management position at Sega.

but as for the continuation of the old series, i'm personally a little nervous. Kataoka's promotion is one of many structural changes Sega has put into motion recently, and come October, a plan to abolish four production studios will be put into affect, and to follow will be the development of two new studios.


are we seeing a case of "out with the old, in with the new?" the poor success of the original Shenmue series, plus the ridiculous cost that went into making them, is certainly a viable reason why Sega might be looking for a change in image - translation; Shenmue Online.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
nobody important
She walk up on St. Andrews.
ultra seeker



nobody important's profilenobody important's neohomeNeoPM nobody important
since: Oct 2003
Sep 26, 04 at 8:31pm
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

More or less, I mean I love
playing Shenmue 1+2 alone.
But even with the massive worlds, it still
felt loney.

Though SEGA, I`m not sure they have lost a
lot of money and well I haven`t seen an online game
from Sega since PSO on the Gamecube and XBox
or that new Matrix Online game that`s coming out soon


-------------------

when it happens it moves all by itself
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Alex Ferguson
Can anyone recommend me a PS2 game?
Resident Neo



Alex Ferguson's profileNeoPM Alex Ferguson
total posts: 2550
since: Feb 2002
Nov 06, 04 at 9:13am
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

No, i don't believe this is the right direction for the series. Being a die hard fan of Shenmue and replaying the first two games over and over again, i am very worried about this 'Shenmue Online' game. Yeah, no doubt i'll buy it, but that isn't really the point, i'll buy it because it has 'Shenmue' in it. However, i believe now that Shenmue Online has been announced i do not think there is much chance of us seeing a Shenmue 3 unless Suzuki is trying to do what someone else touched upon in an earlier post where he may be using the MMORPG type game to attract a bigger fan base, but i do not believe this is what he is trying to do.


-------------------


Shenmue Online | Banner made by Tehuti | Sign my Guestbook
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Xal
hey guys what is going on here?
s-e-e-k-e-r



Xal's profile
since: Dec 2002
Dec 07, 04 at 8:39pm
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

After seeing some pics of this game, and brushing up on some Shenmue trivia, I would think that this would be a good idea. That is though, if the game is a MMORPG. Having it a MMO would kill it. As I stated in my post the series has prided itself on making live, vibrant worlds for a single play to explore, not thousands. However, having this game a co-op game would make it very interesting. Some of the pictures show two people fighting the LanDi, suggesting that this would be a alright co-op game. This would work, but how could they possibly implement thousands of people in such a story driven game?


-------------------
-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Cleric
can't stop
CruisiN'



Cleric's profile
since: Apr 2002
Dec 08, 04 at 9:29am
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

Well Xal, if it is MMORPG then it won't be as detailed a story, however it still can have quests everyone can do and a general plot like Landi Sama is trying to take control of Japan/China or another country related to Shenmue and you are part of the story in the quest to stop him and his thugs.

The video which shows everyone fighting Landi I figure is just for show, you won't be able to bundle Landi I would imagine as then the game would ultimately kill the series.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Xal
hey guys what is going on here?
s-e-e-k-e-r



Xal's profile
since: Dec 2002
Dec 08, 04 at 5:00pm
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

Just because the story isn't detailed, doesnt mean it isnt story driven. Why, just look at every crappy RPG.



-------------------
-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Cleric
can't stop
CruisiN'



Cleric's profile
since: Apr 2002
Dec 09, 04 at 1:24am
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

Well every MMORPG that is good that I can remember is gameplay driven, that is what I am guessing this will be like as its a spin-off.

quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Xal
hey guys what is going on here?
s-e-e-k-e-r



Xal's profile
since: Dec 2002
Jan 01, 05 at 8:34pm
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

^ Good point.



-------------------
-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
Crispy_Bacon
Relentless



Crispy_Bacon's profileCrispy_Bacon's neohomeNeoPM Crispy_Bacon
total posts: 9137
neopoints: 243
since: Aug 2003
Jan 02, 05 at 11:35am
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

Yeah, a spin-off. And nothing more. I hate the fact that Sega aren't pushing onto a third game in the series - a true sequel - because another dose of Shenmue would be so refreshing right about now.

Hopefully it will pop up soon after the release of Next-Gen consoles. Nevertheless, it's still nice to see Sega are holding the series high on its feet instead of letting it flop to the ground.
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
TheSherrif
unwashed heathen
(guest)

IP: Logged
Dec 08, 05 at 3:42pm
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

I'm worried about this too big time,
I heard there was originally planned to be like 12 parts or something in the saga. I thought that its set in the 80s because youll develop the path your father took and eventually get to the present when you will be like 40 and strong enought to fight Lan Di. Whatever the story was, im really disapointed it didnt continue. Shenmue 1 actually made me want to go and find out about japan, its people and its culture. And i think thats an awesome thing. Shenmue 2 felt like i was really undertaking the journey and i was so looking forward to shenmue 3. i hope i hope i hope
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  report
LanDi Sama
Wright: GIMMIE A KISS
(moderator)

Action [DC]
Art Central
Artist's Gallery
General Dreamcast
RPG/ Strategy / Adventure [DC]
Sports and Racing [DC]


wiki staff
aceattorney
shenmue




LanDi Sama's profileLanDi Sama's neohomeNeoPM LanDi SamaLanDi Sama's Fan Art!
total posts: 6904
neopoints: 3467
since: Feb 2002
Dec 08, 05 at 4:22pm
re: is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?

Shenmue Online is a spin-off, it's not really a continuation of the Shenmue story, it's just set in that world

And I think Yu Suzuki was planning 16 chapters altogether, Shenmue covering chapter 1, and Shenmue II covering chapters 3, 4 and 5 to my recollection.


-------------------
quote   quick quote   edit   quick edit   del  searchposts in thread  report
[All dates in (PT) time]Threads List   « Next Newest   Next Oldest »
REPLY TO THIS THREAD   START NEW THREAD


search:
All Shenmue Forums
Neoseeker Forums » PC Games » RPG » Shenmue Online » is Shenmue Online the right direction for the series?



Jump to another forum:

Powered by neoforums v0.9.7g (equilibrium)
Copyright Neo Era Media, Inc. 1999-2009

neoseeker forum community
Neoseeker.com   |   Forum Rules   |   Forum FAQ   |   Neoseeker Terms of Use   |   Supermods On Duty [ server id: nova ··· elapsed: 0.0899341106]
Affiliated sites:   GameGrep - Football Manager Wiki - Halo Wiki - MGS Wiki - GTA Wiki - Smackdown Wiki - Zelda Wiki - PS2seeker - Xbox seeker - DEVPEN - GFXcess