re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5] - Page 22 - Interactive Role-Playing

Forum Options:	my.neoforum register members prefs search faq

Topic: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5] Options: Print subscribe remove NeoPM
Threads List « Next Newest Next Oldest »
The Shape True Addiction since: Sep 2005	Apr 29, 12 at 5:05am ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	Log in to remove this advertisement Btw loved how many people assumed it was Slim and Glot
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Fusion Neo: Essential total posts: 11636 since: Sep 2005	Apr 29, 12 at 6:04am ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	Not gonna lie, I was disappointed with A LOT of the play this game. First I’m gonna antagonize The Shape. After we set up a deliberate ploy to try and frame me to protect him, when it came down to crunch time he… didn’t bother to do anything, at all. Pretty much came close to costing us the win, there. Losing our recruiter that phase was one of the worst phases for it to happen – had he bought time with two more phases (which I’m sure he could have done, seeing as he’s The Shape and we had a guaranteed threat in Peanut) cult wouldn’t have had to struggle as much as we did to take home this victory. This was one hell of a miracle. Then there was the town, who kept letting Peanut walk phase by phase. I get why I was lynched (although I still think it would’ve made more sense to lynch Peanut that phase), but the phases after didn’t make much sense. There was a lucky call on The Shape, and he didn’t do himself or us any favors by not coming in, but he (Peanut) really should have died sooner than that – or even that phase. It could easily have been a mislynch with Shape, though it became abundantly clear it wouldn’t be once it was pointed out that he was lurking but not saying anything. So mainly, he should have been lynched Day Phase 7. I'll get to that. Anyway, I’m not sure if Peanut did a good job at keeping himself alive, or if town did a shit job, but I’m very inclined to believe the latter. The evidence against Peanut was insurmountable – his results on me were faulty, lie detectors do not work the way he was proposing – they can’t. Otherwise you’d get broken results like the ones he claimed to have on me. Then there’s Spud, who no one bothered to even think about being recruited despite having all but confirmed himself as town – at least until Ninetails came around, who was one of the most inactive townies in the bunch. Cult likes to recruit confirmed townies because no one will bat an eyelash at them, since they’re confirmed. Then no one bothered to question him until it was all too late. Sad. As for Day Phase 7… Don’t even get me started. “Let’s find the recruiter!” “…” “Okay, Peanut?” “Nah, let’s not lynch achieve.” When a lynch was crucial? Really guys? Lastly, a big “bleep you” to the people who were so sure I was cult – namely Smell the Chiken. I wasn’t cult until the phase I was lynched. It was pure luck that I was recruited then, otherwise all of you would have just made a giant ass of yourselves. By the way, everything I said was true – from hiding behind Rawer and being unsuccessful to hiding behind Peanut to being an Indy Survivor. Only thing was, I was able to be recruited since my role was so powerful. Talk about being right for all the wrong reasons. There was truly a lot of shocking play this game. From letting an indy survivor lead the town (Bri’s right, indies should stay away from town actions – I was just wanting to have a bit of fun by playing as a townie) to letting confirmed scum to walk for God knows how long, and no lynching in phases where LYNCHES WERE CRUCIAL. The only reason town did even remotely well was because of Musefan’s spectacular play, Oxygen + Scum team taking out cult members, and Olivier le Fou/Peanut taking out a lot of scum at night. Many of these weren’t town aligned. Hoping the play improves in future games. Don't get me wrong, I understand that fun is the number one priority in these games - it should be. But how is inactivity and just not doing anything considered "fun"? The phase I was lynched? That was fun, especially for me. It was heavily active and everyone was working really hard. That's fun, and that's how gameplay should be. However, I was VERY impressed with the play of other people this game, including KingSpud, Musefan, and Oxygen. Spud played an amazing game as cult, Musefan was the only townie to rip a whole into the non-town threats, and Oxygen did a good game of becoming a key town player when it mattered to fly under the radar as Paulie. Was just bad luck that he was detected. Anyway, time for the awards. Best Player: KingSpud Did for his alignment the most - without him, HoF would have lost. Makes this a pretty clear cut choice. Best Town: Mr Musefan Easy. Called out a bunch of scum, did his classic “claim JoAT to lynch scum” despite only being bulletproof, and having surprisingly accurate reads throughout. Best Scum: Pedigree Managing to get out of Musefan’s spotlight and being the last one to survive earns him an award, even if he just earned it by staying under the spotlight. Best Indy: Oxygen There were only 3, but still, Oxygen deserves this one without a doubt. Would never have suspected him as Paulie, did a wonderful job of playing off as town. Shit luck that you were lynched, mate. Best Cult: KingSpud Last one to survive and playing off “ultimate clear town leader” did our cult wonders. If it weren't for Spud, cult would not have won the game. I'd also like to say I hope this shines the spotlight on Spud as a player a little more, he's definitely shown that he has potential in this game. Most Dramatic Moment: Peanut v. Fusion That was an intense phase and probably one of my favorite of all time, haha. Almost compares to Peanut v. Musefan v. Glotnot in Lord of the Rings. Also, YAAAAY, a cult victory. That makes it two Neo Mafias in a row where cult has won the game. P.S. To those of you that got pissy at me using Haz's avatar, I lol'd. But I've changed it back so you can get your panties fixed.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
The Shape True Addiction since: Sep 2005	Apr 29, 12 at 6:29am ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	Tbh maybe I overestimated the town but I think in the ploy to get rid of you and protect me for a while had run its course and there was very little chance of me surviving. I wasn't online for the vast majority of the time when votes were stacking up, in fact I think I got on when the majority had already been reached, and I hadn't followed the game nearly enough to come up with anything worthwhile. It's a fair enough criticism overall in that I didn't really do anything all game, because I came in as a replacement after missing a lot of stuff I never caught up on (and I never got asked if I wanted in, just sent a PM, at which point upon drawing myself obviously I was going to stick around) and didn't go out of my way to catch up, but still I find your tone a little unnecessary.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Fusion Neo: Essential total posts: 11636 since: Sep 2005	Apr 29, 12 at 6:51am ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	I apologize if I came off as rude and/or condescending, I promise I never mean to and it's not my intention. But I did want to vent out my feelings in that I was a little disappointed that you viewed the forums a few times and didn't even try to defend yourself. Even a half-assed RLFierro claim might have had them stall a little bit (I'll be honest and say I think you overestimated the town, judging from their play as a whole ). It is just a game after all and so there's no harsh feelings of course, but in spirit of the game I wish you had done more is all. Obviously coming in as a forced replacement is a bit tough and it gets hard to catch up midway through a game, but your role was crucial to the cult and so that's why I'm a little more criticizing. Edit: Apr 29, 12 8:14am
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
The Blode Loose & Melty Neo or Bust total posts: 7452 since: Aug 2005	Apr 29, 12 at 7:52am ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	oh lil_leefy what did I do?
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Pedigree ... aka Captain Catfish Neo: Essential total posts: 12068 since: Oct 2005	Apr 29, 12 at 8:44am ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	Mr Musefan, farts that is all.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Bri Seeketh Maximus total posts: 5991 since: Jul 2004	Apr 29, 12 at 9:48am ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	This was my first Mafia game in quite some time and I find myself agreeing with a lot of what Fusion said. In the past, a townie could rest on his laurels and not worry, because multiple townies were in control (with scum infiltration here and there of course)...but this game, there was so much inactivity that it gave me the impression people didn't give a shit, and that was disheartening from a townie standpoint. Even scum/cult...you guys have to agree that a do-nothing town makes a win too easy. I felt manipulation through the game, but I never felt I had enough to go on to get a lynch on some of you. Thank the heavens Mr Musefan gave you guys somewhat of a run for your money. If he isn't in the Hall of Fame already (forgive me, my memory's shot), he needs to be. quote I wasn’t cult until the phase I was lynched. It was pure luck that I was recruited then, otherwise all of you would have just made a giant ass of yourselves. I directly helped get you lynched, but I had been suspicious of you for a number of phases. bleep, my scumdar's still way off. I blame it on being scum for like 6 games in a row last year. If this is the confessionals...I'd just like to say I wasn't too impressed with Bri's role-title. Amusing some of you feel that's what I represent.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
The Shape True Addiction since: Sep 2005	Apr 29, 12 at 9:55am ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	Agree on the inactivity. The town not doing anything was the main reason I didn't bother doing anything, because for the most part no posting was the best strategy. Unfortunately they did start to post without me noticing, but it still won out in the end.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Iconic I am the man of Constant Sorrow Permanently Plugged In since: Jul 2002	Apr 29, 12 at 11:09am ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	quote The Lost Soul mazx got in and I didn't? thats pretty bleeping homo, two neo mafias in a row I've been snubbed in Bo, it's just a game. Also, I've been around for like over a decade and I don't know who you or mazx is really. Just relax, I'm sure you'll be in the next Neoseeker game. You are The Lost Soul: Individual Aligned Why not me? I'm only slightly ribbing you, but yeah don't take too much stock into the fact you weren't in.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Drachbo Yo pretty ladies Two much Neo total posts: 2451 since: Mar 2008	Apr 29, 12 at 11:23am ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	First actual participation really so can't compare with anything, but I enjoyed it. Hopefully I can gather up some kind of experience and add more to the mix next time. :>
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Oxygen Still Seekin' since: Jan 2009	Apr 29, 12 at 12:33pm ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	I also struggle to understand why town lynched Shape. I thought maybe he was one of my targets so threw his name out there and the town were more than happy to oblige, which happened so often Mr Musefan had a really good game, I tried to get him lynched so he wouldn't find me out as the indy. I wasn't really sure what alignment you were Fusion. Being so involved in the game made me think you could have been cult trying to dictate the game but then Haz made sense as indy. I probably wouldn't have been so eagar to hop on Peanut's side in Fusion vs Peanut had you not been on my list. For the record I don't think I nightkilled anyone in the cult, that was all Peanut...who I didn't bother to kill or lynch because there was a chance he'd help but killing some of my targets>
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
The Lost Soul NeoXtreme total posts: 8108 since: Jun 2007	Apr 29, 12 at 12:49pm ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	quote Oxygen quote The Lost Soul quote SleepingNinetails quote The Lost Soul mazx got in and I didn't? thats pretty bleeping homo, two neo mafias in a row I've been snubbed in Boo hoo. Maybe you should try being happy for him, instead of whining about past events that can't be changed. I picked a random name out of a hat of lesser known people. I was new player of the year one year, I'd like to see what, say, Liveslikebeth or Mazx or Smell the Chiken or The Rock 13 have done. Nothing against those people, but I'd like to think I'm more well known around here for what I've done. And for those who wanna say I've been inactive, I wanna see you explain Uncle Paulie, Desmond, Homicide and Dash. >_> EDIT: I also noticed no orez or Glot. I can at least mildly understand me and orez, but no Glot? That's a spit in the bleeping face there. You're a retard. You want in over Rocky who's been here for years? And Paulie is a really well known figure and was the serial killer. Desmond is well known. Homicide has been rping for bleeping years. And Dash ran the biggest game on this foroum outside of Mafia and Wrestling Rps. It's battle for the IRP, not battle for Mafia Games. For what it's worth I haven't played an awful lot of mafia games recently but if you never posted again I'd literally have never noticed. >I'm a retard >Completely bleeping ignore my actual reasons for those names >Supply your own reasons I also feel the need to mention I've won best town, best cult and best mafia. I also like how no one cared to argue my point on Glot and just told me I need to get over myself. This is exactly why I didn't want Ipod doing the game. I'd have been cool with Glot, Oogs, maybe Dis, even if I didn't want one to happen in the first place. But I didn't trust Ipod's judgment, and leaving out me, orez and especially Glot kind of showed that to me >_>
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Oxygen Still Seekin' since: Jan 2009	Apr 29, 12 at 12:53pm ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	You do that stupid '>' thing so I don't even wanna read any further So what if he left Glot out? Who would he leave out in his place, Shape? Btw your reason was 'Im more well known round here'. Well, no, you're not. Maybe to Olivier Le Fou but not anyone like Slim, Shape, Bri, Haz. This forum's been here since before 2009 and I'd actually be more shocked if Rocky was left out rather than you, cause let's face it you're a bitch who's crying about being left out of the game whereas no-one else would give a shit.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Disenchanted Who's This Woman In My Bed?! Neolithic total posts: 6359 since: Jul 2008	Apr 29, 12 at 12:54pm ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	yo seriously, you and orez aren't that important. like, seriously. and Glot has been away from neo for literally a year or some shit now, I don't know why you're so insistent he should be in. for what it's worth i MIGHT have put you in, but I really can't make any promises. I wouldn't have gone to the awards section of the GD like right this guy won this he should probably be in.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
Iconic I am the man of Constant Sorrow Permanently Plugged In since: Jul 2002	Apr 29, 12 at 1:04pm ^ re: Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5]
	I roll my eyes back n forth.
	quote quick quote edit quick edit del posts in thread report
[All dates in (PST) time]	Threads List « Next Newest Next Oldest »

Thread title	From	Last replied
Now searching...

Neoseeker Mafia - Battle For The IRP [Game Thread 5] - Page 22

Hobbies

Sports

Skills

Chat and Lounges

Game Platforms

Mobile Platforms

Top Core Games

Top Portable Games

Top Communities