Complete each achievement to get the allotted gamerscore. The numbers between the () is the points given for each achievement.
| Unlockable | How to unlock |
| That's gonna leave a mark (20) | Powerbomb an opponent on top of a steel step in any match type. |
| Possession is 9/10 of the law (20) | Steal your opponent's taunt 3 times in any One on One match. |
| Put'em in a body bag (20) | Turn your opponent's entire limb damage meter red in any match type. |
| I'd like to thank the academy (20) | Defeat a Powerhouse Superstar with the Possum Pin in any match type. |
| You've got a bit of red on you (20) | Get busted open by your opponent on legend difficulty in any match type and win. |
| Who says originality is dead (20) | Create an original CAS, ring entrance and created Championship. |
| King of the mountain (20) | Place first in every type of tournament in Tournament mode. |
| If it bleeds... (20) | Bloody every ECW Superstar on the roster. |
| Submission-sensei (50) | Win a Normal Submission match without having your Struggle Submission hold broken once. |
| Stop yapping and fight (20) | Argue with the referee 4 times in a match and win. |
| That's one for the record books (20) | Eliminate 20 opponents in a 30-Man Royal Rumble. |
| Now that's hardcore (20) | Bloody and defeat a Hardcore Superstar on legend difficulty in an ECW Extreme Rules match and win. |
| The best there was... (20) | Win a 20-minute Ironman match on legend difficulty without surrendering a point to your opponent. |
| A fighting champion (75) | In ranked online matches, defend a CAC title 5 times against 5 different players within 24 hours. |
| Gold digger (70) | Win a Created Championship 10 times in ranked online matches. |
| On fire (75) | Win 30 consecutive ranked online matches. |
| Now offering non-stop flights (20) | Stand on a ladder and suplex your opponent out of the ring in a ladder match. |
| Better luck next year (10) | Be the first Superstar eliminated in a 30-Man Royal Rumble. |
| What the... (10) | Preview the Mexican Stretch Corner Grapple in Create A Move-Set. |
| Escape Artist (20) | Wiggle free from every Ultimate Control Grapple at least once. |
| On The Job (10) | Lose 5 consecutive ranked online matches. |
| You've got guts (20) | Complete a ranked online title match. |
| Rope a dope (20) | Perform a succesful springboard attack off each side of the ropes. |
| This year's inductee (350) | Play as a GM in 24/7 Mode and obtain the GM of the Year Award. |
| This is coming out of your check (20) | Destroy 15 tables and 10 chairs in a TLC match. |
| Send'em back to Louisville (10) | Opponent who has more limb damage than you. |