Complete each achievement to get the allotted gamerscore. The numbers between the () is the points given for each achievement.
| Achievement | How to unlock |
|---|
| Running Wild (20) | Performed 50 successful finishers in any mode over the course of the game. |
| Born to Fly (20) | Performed 10 successful regular aerial moves in a single match. |
| Five Moves of Doom (20) | Executed five signature moves in a single match. |
| Dominating (20) | Won a match against the CPU without losing any health. |
| Layeth the Smacketh Down! (20) | Won a match in under 2 minutes. |
| Punch Drunk (20) | Landed at least 100 strikes in a single match in any mode. |
| Man of 1000 Holds (25) | Won a match without using any strikes. |
| Slobberknocker (25) | Won a match without using any grapples. |
| Make Them Humble (25) | Won 25 matches by knockout. |
| Five Star Rating (20) | Achieved a five star rating while facing the CPU. |
| Mark of Excellence (20) | Earned a gold medal while facing the CPU. |
| The Apex Predator (20) | Completed the Superstars Path of Champions. |
| Breaking the Rules (20) | Completed the Tag Team Path of Champions. |
| Facing the Deadman (20) | Completed the Legends Path of Champions. |
| The New Generation (10) | Defeated a Legend with a Superstar. |
| Showing Them How It's Done (10) | Defeated a Superstar with a Legend. |
| Rising Star (20) | Completed Path of Champions with a created Superstar. |
| Reversal of Fortune (15) | Performed at least 5 grapple reversals during a match. |
| Chain Gang (15) | Performed a combo at least 5 moves in length. |
| The Next WWE Superstar (10) | Made a created Superstar. |
| Old School (15) | Completed all Fantasy Warfare matches as a WWE Legend. |
| Legend Killer (15) | Completed all Fantasy Warfare matches as a WWE Superstar. |
| Over the Top (15) | Won a Steel Cage match. |
| Suck It (20) | Won a Tornado Tag Team match as Triple H and Shawn Michaels. |
| Mega Powers (20) | Won a Tornado Tag Team match as Hulk Hogan and Randy Savage. |
| The New Face of Cyberspace (20) | Defeated a created Superstar in a Xbox LIVE match with your own created Superstar. |
| Main Eventer (50) | Won 50 Xbox LIVE matches. |
| You Can't See Me! (50) | Won 10 consecutive Xbox LIVE matches. |
| Comeback of the Year (20) | Won a match when your Superstar is at zero health. |
| Beating the Odds (15) | Won a Handicap match. |
| Totally Extreme! (15) | Won an Extreme Rules match. |
| He's Got a Chair! (20) | Landed at least 10 successful strikes with an object in a single match. |
| In the Spotlight (15) | Won an Xbox LIVE match. |
| Last Man Standing (15) | Won a Fatal 4 Way Elimination match. |
| The Champ is Here! (50) | Completed all three Path of Champions as John Cena. |
| Enhancement Talent (20) | Won 10 Xbox LIVE matches. |
| Mid Carder (25) | Won 25 Xbox LIVE matches. |
| The Bottom Line (50) | Defeated the entire WWE All Stars roster with a single created Superstar. |
| The King of Kings (50) | Defeated the entire WWE All Stars roster as Triple H. |
| The Ultimate Achievement (75) | Defeated the entire Roster and all three Path of Champions as The Ultimate Warrior. |
