Complete each achievement to get the allotted gamerscore. The numbers between the () is the points given for each achievement.
| Achievement | How to unlock |
|---|
| 1-2-3 (10) | Retire all 3 batters faced in an inning (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| A Day To Remember (100) | Throw a no-hitter using any number of pitchers (minimum 9 innings, Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Advanced Mind, Advanced Pleasure (50) | Complete 10 games using advanced controls. |
| Another Level (20) | Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked 'Legendary'. |
| Buy a Pack (20) | Use your duplicate cards to buy a new pack of cards. |
| Card Master (50) | Win a Card Battle match on Xbox LIVE. |
| Cards Shmards (20) | Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked 'Earn 100 Cards'. |
| Catch 'em Nappin (10) | Successfully bunt for a hit (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Contender (20) | In franchise, have your team make the playoffs (min 20 games played). |
| Control Artist (5) | Throw a Total Control Pitch with superb execution. |
| David vs. Goliath (20) | Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked 'Goliath'. |
| De-Railed (20) | Successfully prevent a runner from plowing over your catcher and scoring (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Domination (30) | Win at least 105 games in one season (min 20 games played) |
| Double Triple (30) | Hit two triples in one game (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Eagle Eye (10) | Get a Base on Balls (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Earn 100 Cards (50) | Unlock 100 different types of cards. |
| Earn a Team (30) | Unlock all the cards for a team in card series 1. |
| Fantasy Cards (10) | Create a complete card team. |
| Frozen Rope (5) | Get a line drive base hit using Right Stick Hitting (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Glove of Gold (10) | In franchise, have a player win the Player's Choice Best Fielder award (min 20 games played). |
| Goliath (20) | Hit 5 home runs in one game (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| He's Got a Gun! (20) | Throw out a runner at homeplate from the outfield using Right Stick Throwing. |
| Hold! (5) | Get credit for a hold (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| I'm a Winner! (10) | Win a ranked match on Xbox LIVE. |
| Keep it Down (5) | Complete a 9-inning game without giving up a home run (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Layer Cake (10) | In franchise, win a game at each minor league level (A, AA, and AAA). |
| League Participation (10) | Play a game in a league or tournament on Xbox LIVE. |
| Legendary (50) | Win a 9-inning game on Legend difficulty. |
| Live Wire (20) | Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked 'Win 20 Online'. |
| Makin' a Splash (20) | In franchise, have a rookie earn the Rookie of the Year award (min 20 games played). |
| Platinum Bat (10) | In franchise, have a player win the Player's Choice Best Hitting award (min. 20 games played). |
| Quality Start (5) | Have your starting pitcher give up 3 or fewer runs in 6+ innings of work (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Red-Handed (10) | Throw out a runner attempting to steal a base (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Save! (5) | Get credit for a save (min 3 batters faced, Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Skillz (5) | Make a spectacular defensive play (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Slugger (20) | Win a Strikes Only match on Xbox LIVE. |
| Star-Studded (20) | In franchise, have 3 or more players make the All-Star Team (min 15 games played). |
| Strikeout the Side (50) | Strikeout all 3 batters faced in an inning (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| The Brink of Stardom (10) | In franchise, have a player win the Minor League Player of the Year award. |
| The Train's Comin' Through (20) | Score a run after plowing over the catcher at homeplate (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| Triple Double (20) | Turn 3 double plays in one game (Pro difficulty or higher). |
| What Makes YOU So Special? (50) | Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked a Top 'em achievement. |
| What's Your Fantasy? (5) | Complete at least 25 rounds of a fantasy draft in franchise mode. |
| Win 20 Online (30) | Win 20 ranked matches on Xbox LIVE. |
| You're Not So Tough (50) | Top 'em: In a ranked match on Xbox LIVE, beat an opponent who has unlocked 'A Day to Remember'. |
