Complete the outlined tasks, and earn the Trophies.
| Trophy | How to unlock |
| Custom Sweater (Bronze) | Complete an EA SPORTS Hockey League match while wearing a Custom Jersey |
| Boosted Up (Bronze) | Complete an EA SPORTS Hockey League match with any one attribute boosted by +9 |
| Practice, Practice, Practice (Bronze) | Play at least 8 hours of game time in EA SPORTS Hockey League Practice |
| EASHL Sophomore (Bronze) | Play 100 Ranked matches with your online Be A Pro character |
| Boost Master (Bronze) | Purchase or unlock 20 Boost items |
| Top Draft Pick (Bronze) | Get your created Pro drafted in the first round of the NHL Draft |
| Stayng Power (Bronze) | Remain on NHL team after the Pre-Season with a created Pro |
| Penalty Killer (Bronze) | Kill of a 5 on 3 powerplay lasting at least 1 minute in a ranked versus match |
| Come Back King (Bronze) | Win a ranked versus match starting the 3rd period down by at least 2 goals |
| Shootout Start (Bronze) | Win 5 Ranked Online Shootout matches |
| Schooled! (Bronze) | Play and win a Ranked Online Shootout match using a OHL, WHL, or QMJHL team |
| Getting Started (Bronze) | Open a Hockey Ultimate Team Starter Pack |
| HUT CPU Win (Bronze) | Play and win a Hockey Ultimate Team single player match versus at least a Pro level CPU |
| HUT Online Win (Bronze) | Play and win a Hockey Ultimate Team online match |
| Jumbo Pack (Bronze) | Open first Jumbo Pack |
| Looking for Deals (Bronze) | Visit a Hockey Ultimate Team Trading screen |
| Box of Cards (Bronze) | Open 15 Card Packs |
| Taking on the CPU (Bronze) | Enter a Hockey Ultimate Team single player tournament |
| Taking on the Public (Bronze) | Enter a Hockey Ultimate Team online tournament |
| Try It On For Size (Bronze) | Visit the Hockey Shop and equip an attribute boost into a boost slot |
| Up and Comers (Bronze) | Play and win a match using an OHL, WHL, QMJHL team against a Pro level CPU NHL team |
| Good Preview (Bronze) | Play and win a Pre-Season match in Be A GM mode |
| Proven Worth (Bronze) | Play and complete a game while scoring a goal with a newly drafted skater in Be A GM mode |
| Poached (Bronze) | Sign, from another team, a level 3 or above Restricted Free Agent in Be A GM |
| Sacrifice the Body (Bronze) | Block a shot without a stick |
| Fist Pump (Bronze) | Perform a User Controlled Goal Celebration |
| Faceoff Victor (Bronze) | Play and finish a ranked versus match with a Faceoff percentage of at least 75% |
| EASHL Playoffs (Silver) | Be a member of an EA SPORTS Hockey League team when they participate in a monthly playoff |
| Filled Up (Silver) | Complete a Be A Pro game with all Boost Slots of one equipment type filled |
| HUT playoff Contendor (Silver) | Qualify for a Hockey Ultimate Team monthly playoff tournament |
| Team Colors (Silver) | Collect both a Logo Card and all Jersey Cards from the same team |
| 5 Star Battle (Silver) | Beat another 5 star team with your 5 star team in a Hockey Ultimate Team online match |
| Legendary GM (Silver) | Receive your Legend Plaque in Be A GM using at least Medium difficulty |
| Look Ma, No Stick (Silver) | Without a stick, perform a kick or glove pass that leads to a goal |
| EASHL Playoffs Champ (Gold) | Be a member of an EA SPORTS Hockey League team when they win a monthly playoff match |
| EASHL Veteran (Gold) | Play 250 Ranked matches with your online Be A Pro character |
| One Down (Gold) | Win a Hockey Ultimate Team online trophy |
| HUT Champion (Gold) | Collect 5 Hockey Ultimate Team Online Trophies in your Collection |
| Raise Your Banner (Platinum) | Acquire all Bronze, Silver, and Gold trophies |
| Secret Trophies | - |