Complete the outlined tasks, and earn the Trophies.
| Trophy | How to unlock |
|---|
| Down But Not Out (Bronze) | Get a hit with 2 strikes on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| Grab Some Pine (Bronze) | Get a strikeout to end the inning on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| Run the Risk (Bronze) | Steal a base after the 6th inning tied or down by 1 run on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| A Pitcher's Best Friend (Bronze) | Turn a double play on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| To the Rescue (Bronze) | Bring in a pitcher, get a save with the tying run on base on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| A Virtue (Bronze) | Face 10 pitches as the batter on Pro or higher in a non-simulated game. |
| Don't Call It a Comeback (Bronze) | Face 10 pitches as the batter on Pro or higher in a non-simulated game. |
| Keep on Truckin' (Bronze) | Truck the Catcher and score on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| This is Why I'm Here (Bronze) | Be successful in a major-league clutch moment in My Player Mode. |
| Trifectas Maximus (Bronze) | Throw a MAX pitch 3 consecutive times with Total Control on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| One Man Show (Bronze) | Throw a Perfect Game or a No-Hitter on Pro or higher in a 9 inning game, in a non-simulated game. |
| Time to Run for Mayor (Bronze) | Hit 3 Home Runs in a single game with the same player on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| I Came, I Saw... (Bronze) | Hit a Walk-off Home Run on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| Stooges (Bronze) | Strikeout all three hitters in the inning on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| High Crimes (Bronze) | Rob a Home Run on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| Thou Shall Not (Bronze) | Throw out a runner stealing a base on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| State Farm - The Road to Victory (Bronze) | Get 3 consecutive batters on base on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| Still Kicking (Bronze) | Strike out a batter with a pitcher who has low composure on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| It's Never Too Late (Bronze) | Get a 2-out RBI Hit on Pro or higher, in a non-simulated game. |
| King of the Hill (Bronze) | Get to the top of the Best of the Best ladder in Home Run Derby Mode. |
| My Fellow Man (Bronze) | Complete and win an online league game. |
| The Team to Beat (Bronze) | Beat the New York Yankees in a completed online match. |
| Count It (Bronze) | Complete and win a ranked match. |
| The Road to Greatness (Bronze) | Complete and win 3 ranked matches in a row. |
| The Spice of Life (Bronze) | Complete 10 online matches using 10 different teams. |
| Domination (Bronze) | Strikeout 200 batters with your profile. |
| A Whole New You (Bronze) | Choose a signature batting stance or pitching delivery in My Player or Create Player. |
| Learning the Ropes (Bronze) | Achieve gold in all the drills. |
| Hurlers (Bronze) | Unlock 20 pitcher cards. |
| Swingers (Bronze) | Unlock 25 hitter cards. |
| The Call (Silver) | Get called up to the Majors in My Player Mode. |
| The Goal (Silver) | Accomplish a Team Season Goal in My Player Mode. |
| The Top (Silver) | Become the #1 ranked player in your My Player organization. |
| The Star (Silver) | Make the All-Star team in My Player mode. |
| The Start (Silver) | Get your player's overall rating to 65 in My Player Mode. |
| The Truth (Silver) | Get your player's overall rating to 85 in My Player Mode. |
| The Hall (Silver) | Make the Hall of Fame in My Player Mode. |
| One and O (Silver) | Play and win opening day in Franchise Mode. |
| What's Your Ring Size? (Silver) | Win a World Series in Franchse Mode. (play at least 20 games) |
| Remember Me (Silver) | Break a record in Franchise Mode. (play at least 20 games) |
| Booked a Ticket (Silver) | Clinch a Postseason Berth in Franchise Mode. (play at least 20 games) |
| A Day in the Life (Silver) | Play a game of MLB Today. |
| Mid-Summer Classic (Silver) | Play the All-Star game in MLB Today. |
| Production (Gold) | Drive in 250 RBI with your profile. |
| A Job Well Done (Platinum) | Unlock all Trophies |
| Secret Trophies | - |
