Pokémon Emerald

"It just would be nice for Nintendo and Game Freak to supply the other demand next time: the demand of something actually more different, or at least palpably new, for our hard earned. Let the pitchfork laden debate begin."

"Despite being made mostly of recycled parts, Emerald proves that the Pokémon formula still works. As a result, the game remains an enjoyably light RPG experience."

"...with the release of Pokemon Emerald, I will admit that my enthusiasm for a rerun this soon after FireRed and LeafGreen -- two reruns themselves -- is somewhat low. There isn't a whole lot new in this green cartridge that can really validate its release outside of Nintendo's business model of simply making money. And this is made even more clear when you realize that Nintendo didn't give players a free Wireless Adapter this time. Yes, I'm not quite as enthusiastic for Pokemon Emerald. But I just can't ignore that the game's entire design is based on a stunningly great role-playing game with an amazing amount of depth."