Neoseeker : Articles : Motherboards : Socket 775 : MSI P35 Platinum Motherboard
Hardware Newsletter:
Email:

News Headlines
New Articles

Compare Prices

Motherboards
Abit
ASUS
Gigabyte
MSI
eVGA
Intel
Tyan
More...

Processors
AMD
Intel
More...

Memory
DDR
DDR2
DDR3
More...

Video Cards
ATI
eVGA
XFX
BFG
Sapphire
More...

search for lowest prices

send article   hardware newsletter   article comments (3)
MSI P35 Platinum Motherboard - PAGE 6
J. Micah Grunert - Tuesday, June 26th, 2007

Since we've profiled a couple of other Intel P35 chipset based motherboards in recent weeks, it seems prudent to see where the MSI P35 Platinum sits in that crowd. And as usual, we turn to our standard complement of motherboard benchmarking hardware.  

 

  • Intel Core 2 E6400 processor (Socket LGA775, 2.13 GHz, two cores) processor
  • Corsair TWIN2X1024 PC-8500 DDR2 memory (4-4-4-12/2T 800MHz)
  • XFX 7800 GT video card 
  • Corsair HX620W Modular power supply 
  • Noctua NH-U 12 CPU cooler 
  • Seagate Barracuda 7200.9 SATAII 80GB hard drive
  • Sony DDU1613 DVD-ROM optical drive 
  • Microsoft Windows XP Pro SP2
  • NVIDIA 93.71 graphics drivers
  • NVIDIA 9.53 chipset drivers
  • DirectX9.0c February 2007
  • DotNetFix2.0

    Again, these are the standards for our motherboard reviews. There was one issue in particular with the memory during the initial system setup, but I'll save that little nightmare for the conclusion of my article. But who are we going to testing against?  

  • Asus P5K Deluxe WiFi (Intel P35 chipset)
  • Gigabyte P35-DS3R (Intel P35 Express chipset)
  • Asus P5B-E (Intel P965 chipset)
  • MSI 975X Platinum (Intel 975X chipset)

    It's the clash of the Intel chipset titans! As these competing boards stand, the Asus P5K Deluxe WiFi was pretty decent, though it did pale somewhat when compared to the Gigabyte P35-DS3R motherboard. But give them some time to refine the BIOS and or related drivers, that's when the P35 chipset will start to shine. The Asus P5B-E is a great board, and even won the distinctive Neoseeker Overclocker's Award. And finally, the MSI 975X Platinum may not have stood out in the digital crowd, but is a nice piece of hardware nevertheless.

    So what can these Intel chipsets do with our collection of benchmarks?

  • PC Magazine Business Winstone 2004
  • PC Magazine Multimedia Content Creation 2004
  • RightMark Memory Analyzer
  • SiSoft Sandra CPU and Memory
  • HDTach
  • WinRAR
  • TMPGEnc MPEG2 Video Encoding
  • XviD Video Encoding
  • LAME MP3 Audio Encoding
  • RightMark Audio Encoding
  • Call of Duty
  • Doom 3
  • Quake 4
  • Comanche 4
  • Halo
  • Jedi Knight: Jedi Academy
  • Unreal Tournament 2004

    But before we bust our way into benchmarking, there is one very important issue I should touch upon. It's with regards to the initial 1.0 BIOS that the MSI P35 Platinum motherboard had shipped with. To put it bluntly, it turned the P35 into a paper weight. It wasn't dead mind you, but just having complications with the Corsair PC-8500 memory modules we use for our motherboard testing. When the afore mentioned memory was installed, the system would hang endlessly, and those little POST code LED's would (in their colorful language) indicate a memory error.

    I've seen problems like this before when a motherboard won't boot due to low memory voltages. I'll take a moment to detail the rather arduous process we went through (and it was a team effort) to get the MSI P35 Platinum running. Point form too, just to save some keystrokes and keep you from any of my profanities for the frustration.

  • Installed two sticks of the Corsair TWIN2X1024 PC-8500 DDR2 memory, wouldn't boot.
  • Installed 1 stick of the Corsair PC-8500 in DIMM slot 1 and it still wouldn't boot. 
  • Installed two sticks of Corsair PC-5400 memory hoping that the lower voltage requirements would allow us to boot. It didn't.
  • Tried 1 stick of the Corsair 5400 in each and every DIMM slot, and it still wouldn't move.
  • Finally, tossed in a single slice of G-Skill PC-6400 memory in DIMM number 1. Low and behold it boots!
  • Got into the BIOS, set the memory voltage to 2.4V, powered down.
  • Tried the Corsair PC-8500 memory again, but to no avail.
  • Tried the Corsair 5400 again, but it didn't work.
  • Switched back to the G-Skill PC-6400 and updated the BIOS from version 1.0 to the latest 1.1 revision.
  • Moved back to the Corsair 8500, got it to the BIOS.
  • Set the memory voltage to 2.4V.
  • Everything is golden, working perfectly, never better.

    It was a marathon of testing and re-testing to find something that would work, but as for it being the simple matter of a BIOS update, that wasn't surprising at all. I've encountered numerous motherboards that have the worst initial BIOS release, and most often the issue at hand has to do with memory module compatibility. Fortunately, by the second BIOS release most every problem is gone (usually thanks to hardware reviewers like us) who are able to worm out these little problems. Yep, we're pretty much Beta Testers.

    But to get to the point, the 1.1 BIOS revision worked wonders for the MSI P35 Platinum, and I hope they start shipping with that 1.1 version BIOS flashed to the board. No one wants to have two or more sets of memory on hand to get  a motherboard running.

    On final note before we get into the testing phase of this review; I (and other here) have been running into a lot of difficulty with RightMark Audio is recent months. The problem seems to be growing, and seems to be an issue with the current RealTek audio drivers. Unfortunately, I could not get RightMark Audio to give me any solid figures in time for this review (it came back every time complaining of errors during testing). As for such, there will be no RightMark Audio testing today.

    Benchmarks, here we come!

     

     

  •  


    Article Index

    1.Introduction
    2.The Chipset
    3.Board Impressions
    4.Bundled Hardware
    5.The BIOS
    6.Test Setup & Benchmarks
    7.Business Winstone & Content Creation
    8.WinRAR & HDTach
    9.Lame MP3 & RightMark Audio
    10.TMPGEnc & Xvid
    11.Call of Duty & Comanche 4
    12.Doom 3 & Quake 4
    13.Halo, Jedi Knight & UT2K4
    14.Overclocking Setup
    15.Overclocking Results
    16.Conclusion

    Submit our article to: diggDigg this! de.le.ciousdel.icio.us

    Get updates when we publish new articles
    Email Address:
    (0.0344/d/nova)